America Shouldn’t Give up Fethullah Gülen to Turkey


Date posted: November 20, 2018

Doug Bandow

The United States has not lapsed into a dictatorship, contrary to some of the rhetoric which accompanied Donald Trump’s election as president two years ago. There is much to criticize in his administration, but so far the American republic survives.

However, there were reports—denied by Trump—that he was considering targeting the rule of law to promote foreign interests. The administration allegedly threatened to subvert the extradition process to placate Turkey’s authoritarian leader Recep Tayyip Erdoğan to insulate Saudi Arabia’s dictator, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, also known as MbS, from his role in ordering the murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi. In this case, two wrongs would make an atrocity.

The epicenter of the controversy is Turkish Muslim cleric Fethullah Gülen. The Pennsylvania resident and green card holder went into exile in the United States almost two decades ago. He has publicly promoted a moderate Islamic message and created a large network of businesses, schools, and other institutions around the world. Critics impute more nefarious hidden motives to his activities.

It’s hard for an outsider to judge such claims. Many individuals and organizations within the so-called Hizmet movement do non-political good works. However, Gülen once allied with Erdoğan as the latter gained control and consolidated power in Turkey. The two later had a bitter falling out as policemen and prosecutors, some Gülen followers, led seemingly well-grounded corruption investigations targeting Erdoğan and his associates. The regime responded by purging the security services of Hizmet members.

Then came the 2016 coup attempt. Erdoğan blamed his erstwhile Islamic ally even before the plot had collapsed—and well before anything was known about its genesis. Although there were “Gülenists” involved, they appeared to play only a secondary role. Indeed, the movement never had significant influence within the military.

Erdoğan played the failed coup rather like Adolf Hitler used the Reichstag fire: as a fortuitous opportunity to crush critics as well as enemies. Indeed, there were suggestions that the Erdoğan government was aware of the plot but chose to allow plotters to proceed in hopes of reaping political gain. The truth may never be known.

The claim that Gülen—aged and in fragile health, a resident of a nation allied with Turkey, and already subject to extraordinary international scrutiny—organized a military putsch seems far-fetched. European intelligence services doubted the possibility. U.S. officials who rejected Ankara’s extradition request obviously were not impressed with Turkey’s evidence.

For instance, supposed confessions collected in the midst of a brutal crackdown cannot be trusted. The regime launched an indiscriminate dragnet, arresting anyone with the slightest connection to Hizmet, torturing suspects, retaliating against independent judges, and suppressing dissent—even by schoolchildren. Some 50,000 Turks have been imprisoned. Another 150,000 have been forced from their jobs, both public and private. Journalists, academics, politicians, and others who criticized Erdoğan were treated most harshly, often charged as terrorists. Indeed, the regime now calls Hizmet as FETO, the Fethullahist Terrorist Organization, without any evidence that Gülen or his followers committed terrorist acts.

Ankara sharply criticized the United States for allegedly sheltering Erdoğan’s enemy. In fact, the Turkish president inadvertently confirmed claims that he was arresting foreigners to use as bargaining chips when he publicly offered to trade American evangelical pastor Andrew Brunson for Gülen. Nor was Brunson the only American detained in dubious circumstances. A dozen others languish in prison, but without Brunson’s visibility. For instance, Turkish-American Serkan Golge, a NASA scientist, was arrested while vacationing in Turkey. Ankara also barred his wife and two sons, U.S. citizens all, from leaving. Turkey’s “evidence” that Golge was a terrorist was that he had an account in a bank owned by a Gülenist and possessed a dollar bill, supposedly a symbol of the conspiracy. Others arrested include university professors and a real estate agent.

Despite Erdoğan’s loud demands for Gülen’s extradition, the former might prefer Gülen to be free, allowing the Turkish president to blame Washington for his troubles. Gülen is modest and soft-spoken. Hard to demonize, he would not be a good villain in a show trial. Politically he is more useful to Erdoğan in America than Turkey.

Even without Gülen, Ankara is pursuing his followers around the world. No proof of involvement in the coup is needed—many victims have only a vague, distant, even imagined connection to someone or something linked to Hizmet. Ankara made extradition requests to eighty-three nations for hundreds of people. In some cases the Erdoğan regime pressured friendly governments to grant extradition. Turkey also sent a flood of dubious warrants to Interpol. When legal means failed, the regime simply kidnapped its targets. Before being appointed as President Trump’s first national security adviser, Michael Flynn, who lobbied for Turkish interests, allegedly was involved in just such a plot involving Gülen.

Internationally, Turkey has been moving away from America. Erdoğan emphasized his hostile attitudes by facilitating the Islamic State’s operations in the early years of the Syrian civil war; his son is thought to have handled Syrian oil captured by the Islamic State. More recently, the regime threatened to attack U.S. forces in northern Syria working with Kurdish militias. Although a North Atlantic Treaty Organization member, Ankara has developed growing political and military ties with Russia.

The administration maintains the fiction of a bilateral alliance, making little response to Erdoğan’s growing dictatorial tendencies and hostile foreign policies. However, until now President Trump seemed prepared to allow the legal process involving Gülen to proceed unhindered. Which meant the administration made no obvious effort to thwart the law and hand over a legal U.S. resident to a dictatorial regime in which a fair trial was not just unlikely, but inconceivable.

Until now, it seems.

As part of its fixation on Iran, the Trump administration tightened its relationship with the even more aggressive and reckless Saudi Arabia. Long a totalitarian and intolerant state domestically, Riyadh funded Islamic radicalism abroad, including in America, and provided both money and manpower to terrorists, including Al Qaeda. The crown prince’s foreign policy has been particularly shameful and dangerous: starting a brutal war of aggression against Yemen, kidnapping the Lebanese prime minister, and launching a political offensive—backed by military threats—against Qatar. He inaugurated some economic and social reforms but simultaneously intensified political repression.

Most dramatically, his government recently murdered, in its Istanbul consulate, the American resident and dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi. Amid a cascade of lies, Riyadh eventually acknowledged that its officials were responsible for the gruesome murder. The only question was how high the decision went. A hit on an American resident and high-profile journalist, by a fifteen-man hit squad, using both consulate and consular residence in a leading Muslim nation and U.S. ally, almost certainly required MbS’s approval. Furthermore, the CIA reportedly uncovered evidence pointing to the crown prince’s assent. The murder was shocking but unsurprising: the regime has kidnapped, imprisoned, and executed many critics over the years.

Turkey, engaged in a battle for political supremacy in the Middle East, has used the Khashoggi murder to embarrass and weaken MbS. The weight of evidence has forced even the Trump administration to criticize the Saudis, but officials have done everything possible to exonerate the crown prince. So desperate are they to protect a murderer in high position that they reportedly ordered the Justice Department to initiate a new review of the Erdoğan government’s extradition request for Gülen.

An administration official told the Turkish Hurriyet Daily News that U.S. officials already had spent more time on his case than others . The source complained about the difficulty in meeting the “very high evidentiary standard.” Time was necessary to ensure that when a request is formally made, “it is detailed enough to have a chance of success.” In general, there must be “probable cause” that the claimed act is covered by an extradition treaty and the subject committed the crime. Many activities typically are excluded from extradition, including political offenses. Thus, whatever the administration’s intentions, extradition remains a legal rather than political case. Even Secretary of State Mike Pompeo acknowledged that “it’s mostly a Justice Department issue.”

Of course, this hasn’t stopped administration officials from politicizing the matter. According to the source, “The U.S. and Turkey have been discussing the Gülen network for many years. It is a positive story in recent months that we have stepped up our cooperation.” But positive for whom?

This enhanced “cooperation” might have been the quid pro quo for Brunson’s release. The latest alleged administration mandate is even clearer: find grounds to sacrifice Gülen. (The administration said NBC’s story was “mistaken,” but the television channel claimed several sources.) According to NBC: “The renewed efforts, however, come as Trump administration officials are seeking to placate Erdoğan over Khashoggi’s murder.” Send the modern sultan’s critic back, and Ankara might go easy on Saudi Arabia’s wannabe-king.

The only good news, according to NBC, is that Justice Department officials have pushed back. They understand that this issue is a fundamental red line for America’s commitment to the rule of law. The administration would lose any remaining moral authority if it sacrificed a man’s liberty and even life to assist one abusive ruler in his paranoid crusade against critics to protect an even worse dictator from accountability for murder.

The Trump administration has paid short shrift toward concerns about human rights. When adversaries brutalize their populations, the president and his aides grow ostentatiously sanctimonious, denouncing abuses in Iran and Cuba, for instance. However, when arrests and killings are committed by Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and other friendly dictatorships, administration officials grow strangely silent.

The murder of Jamal Khashoggi was too blatant for the administration to ignore easily. But Washington apparently hopes to moderate the consequences of that crime on Riyadh by placating Ankara. Doing so would not be just bad foreign policy. It would sacrifice the rule of law in America. And that is far too high a price to pay irrespective of the foreign policy objective.

Doug Bandow is a Senior Fellow at the Cato Institute. A former Special Assistant to President Ronald Reagan, he is the author of Foreign Follies: America’s New Global Empire.

Source: The National Interrst , November 19, 2018


Related News

Minister Şahin praises Journalists and Writers Foundation for courageous coverage

SEZAİ KALAYCI, NEW YORK Family and Social Policy Minister Fatma Şahin has praised the Journalists and Writers Foundation (GYV) for its members’ courageous coverage of important issues at a time when the country is taking steps for democratization. Şahin’s remarks came during a panel discussion on women’s issues held by the GYV and Peace Islands […]

Police raid successful Gülen-inspired schools in western Turkey

Just after another Gülen-inspired school was raided by the police in the southern province of Gaziantep on Monday, private schools established by the volunteers from the Hizmet Movement were raided in the western province of İzmir on Tuesday morning.

Washington Post: Biden needs to give Turkey’s Erdogan some tough advice

Mr. Biden ought to candidly tell his host that the US did not instigate the coup and that it will not relinquish Mr. Gulen to a witchhunt. Mr. Erdogan may not want to hear it, but he also should be reminded that crushing the rule of law will dim Turkey’s prospects. Mr. Erdogan may bask in the crowds today, but using the coup as a pretext to purge the media, academia and other spheres of independent voices will not strengthen the nation in the long run.

Man abducted by Turkish intel exposes torture during 9-month enforced disappearance

Gökhan Türkmen, who was allegedly abducted by Turkish intelligence officers and kept in a non-official detention center for 271 days, has said he was tortured, subjected to severe threats and sexually harassed and abused during his enforced disappearance.

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

The Turkey Tribunal, a civil society-led, symbolic international tribunal established to adjudicate recent human rights violations in Turkey, started proceedings in Geneva on Monday where rapporteurs pointed to the use of systematic torture by the government against alleged members of the faith-based Gülen movement and Kurds.

Turkish Charity in Virginia send 30 thousand blankets to Syrian refugees

Organizing an aid campaign in USA’s Virginia state, Turkey’s Kimse Yok Mu (Is Anybody There?) charity association managed to collect 30 thousand blankets and USD 70,000 for Syrian refugees in Turkey.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Turkey Systematically And Deliberately Jails Women As Part Of Fear And Intimidation Campaign

Aydan Meydan from Bosna Sema School won the “Inspiring Educator Award”!

Gulen Institute Youth Platform 2015 Winners

Tape politics

Gülen’s teachings discussed this time in New York

Analysis: Power of Turkey’s Fethullah Gulen

Erdoğan: both asset and liability for AKP

Copyright 2024 Hizmet News