The Other Side of the Ocean – What Happened in Pennsylvania?


Date posted: July 25, 2013

During the time when the Gezi events were at their peak, a certain group in the United States planned to carry out a demonstration in the area where Fethullah Gulen is currently residing by organizing over the Internet, similar to the way they had in Turkey.

For weeks they shared with tens of thousands of people over e-mail, Facebook and Twitter the digital fliers and slogans they had prepared. Similar to the “5-5-5-K” plan that had been plotted against Adnan Menderes, with the slogan “on the 5th of the 5th month, at 5 o’clock in Kızılay” the “13-13-13-P” plan was targeted at Mr. Gulen with the slogan “ On July 13, 2013 at 13:00 in Pennsylvania” yet, whether it was for the ill luck of the number 13, who knows, the plan was unsuccessful.

A week before the set date, through its reflection on the Internet and written media, almost every Turk living in the United States had heard of the demonstration. Within the framework of the laws in the United States pertaining to freedom of speech, one is free to carry out any demonstration provided that other persons will not be harmed and that it will not include any form of violence. The reason for expressing this detail is to call attention to the fact that although this planned demonstration is not considered illegal according to the laws and was announced to quite a vast group of people, the turnout failed to exceed 50-60 people. The video records show us that the promoters have also made frequent reference to this detail but have put forward excuses such as those who were lost on the way or those who were unable to locate the correct address.

Because the small town in which Mr. Gulen lives was comprised of one-to-two story houses lined along the sides of a narrow single-lane road, far away from any social domains or shopping centers, there was no convenient spot in which the demonstrators could park their cars, not even a small pathway in which they could walk with posters in their hands. In the video records of the demonstrators, this reality was expressed as such: “Because they were blocking the way of traffic on a single-lane road with no path for pedestrians, causing life-threatening danger, the police had “rightfully” sent them away from the area, referring them to another location 8 km away.”

A nearby church closed off their parking spaces just as the American homeowners who were neighbor to the retreat center also did. Even if the demonstrators reflect this as though the Americans had been subject to threats, this does not express any legitimate reality. Those who do know very well that if an American truly were to have been threatened, s/he would not merely grin and bear it; they would march immediately to the police department. The reality is this: Aside from sincere support to their neighbors who have been loyal to them for years, who have shared their meals during the many Ramadans spent together, these people did not want any form of unrest in the quiet and tranquil neighborhood in which they lived, and so they behaved according to the directives of the security forces.

The demonstrators were not even able to honk a horn as they passed by the retreat center, let alone stop in front of it. Contrary to what has been claimed, there was never a march-with-posters-in-hand in that area. The pictures and footage belong to the demonstration carried out by a group of 60 people, at most, in a small park 5 miles away from the retreat center in which no American other than the couple of police officers were present. Also in these video records, it is noteworthy that the demonstrators started arguing amongst each other, that the leader had trouble controlling the group and even said, “I’m out!” at one instance. In short, even those who were a part of it accept the fact that this demonstration was one that was quite imposed, constrained and coerced.

It is inappropriate to belittle people and their actions if they express a certain standpoint even if they are only six people, let alone sixty. However, the expressions used in the first fliers that read: “we must pound at the door of snakes, we must silence and defeat it” were signs of insult and attack rather than the expression of an opinion. Nevertheless, the message coming from Mr. Gulen was very welcoming: “They are welcome to come and have a cup of tea with us!” However, their response to this was that much out of proportion!

The slogans shouted out by the demonstrators and the posters they held in their hands were way below humanistic values and expressing one’s thought. The level of vulgarity was not fit for even the overly excited fans of neighborhood soccer teams. It did not fit the profile of Turks in the United States; it did not reflect the elite Turkish image and quality.

Beyond all else, there was no logic behind this demonstration, which was seen as a continuation of the Gezi events. After all, Fethullah Gulen was “a person that had expressed the fact that the Gezi Park demonstrators should be listened to and not responded to through excessive methods”. In expression of this reality, the words of Oray Eğin—who stands closer to the demonstrators rather than Gulen—in which he described the demonstration as “illtimed and void of intellect, the biggest secularist failure in the history of protest and a subject of mockery” leaves no need for any other description.

Our purpose is certainly not to insult the people that travelled from kilometers away for the sake of an opinion and an ideal—though its target and outcome have proven to be controversial. We are merely reflecting the mistakes that were made in the process. We are calling attention to the interesting contradiction of the way they waved the American flags and repeated with pride the fact that they were American citizens in video records claiming to be about ‘nationalism’. We are merely trying to voice the fact that if they had showed their own citizens a tenth of the obedience, respect and esteem they showed to the American police officers, then such a demonstration would never have been called for.

Even if we, personally, have failed to maintain our proper manner, notice the difference in the way Fethullah Gulen—whose civilized ‘invitation to tea’ was rejected and who was chosen as target to these demonstrations and unfitting slogans—approached the matter: “A human bears hostility towards that which he does not know; we are the ones at fault for, all this time, we have been unable to acquaint ourselves to them.”

Source: HizmetMovement.Com , July 24, 2013


Related News

Gülen’s lawyer issues written warning to pro-gov’t media outlets

Nurullah Albayrak, the lawyer representing Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, on Thursday issued a written warning to pro-government media outlets on social media for their persistent use of the expressions “parallel structure” — a term invented by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan to refer to followers of the Hizmet movement — and “Fethullah Gülen terrorist organization” — referred to in the dailies as FETÖ — on the grounds that they are making baseless claims regarding the faith-based movement.

Australian NGOs support Gülen against PM Erdoğan’s insults

Erhan Bozkurt, a director at AUF, spoke at the press conference, which representatives from the federation’s 38 NGOs, which have been operating all over Australia for 25 years, attended. The Turkish community in Australia, Bozkurt said, was deeply wounded by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s insulting language toward both Gülen and the members of his movement, stating that no other religious scholar has been targeted by this many acts of defamation in recent history.

Interview with Henri Barkey on the Hizmet Movement

Henri Barkey, who has been one of the leading Turkey analysts in Washington, joined journalist Ruşen Çakır’s live broadcast via Periscope. He made interesting comments about the claims of the “parallel structure,” the situation of Fethullah Gülen in the US, and the appointment of trustees to the Zaman daily.

AKP Twitter troll asks gov’t to kill all Gülen sympathizers in jail

A pro-Justice and Development Party (AKP) Twitter troll has called on the government to make plans for the massacre of all Gülen sympathizers who are currently behind bars in the event of a second coup attempt in the country.

Erdoğan draws ire from all segments of society over bid to close Turkish schools

Members of opposition parties, prominent businessmen and figures in the education world have severely criticized President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan for campaigning for the closure of Turkish schools in African countries that are affiliated with the Gülen movement, also known as the Hizmet movement, inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, who is a former ally of the president.

Erdoğan’s abstract enemies: parallel organization and superior mind

Totalitarian regimes rely on their ability to manufacture enemies. In his New Year message, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan referred to a host of “external enemies” and “traitors.” The ruling party characterizes these traitors as the “parallel organization” and “superior mind.” The phrases “parallel state” and “Pennsylvania organization” are used synonymously with the “parallel organization” as well.

Latest News

Logistics companies seized over Gülen links sold in fast-track auction

That is Why the Turkish Government could Pay 1 Billion Euros

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

Grondahl: Turkish community strong in wake of threats from back home

In Case You Missed It

Hiring based on ‘color lists’ a violation of Constitution, analysts say

Texas Agency Finds No Wrongdoing by Harmony Public Schools

German Politician: Turkey like Nazi Germany after Reichstag

Dismissed after coup attempt, teacher detained during visit to imprisoned relative

TUSKON to gather 2,000 businessmen from all over world in İstanbul

Flynn stopped military plan against ISIS that Turkey opposed – after being paid as its agent

17 Percent Students Of Nile University Are On Scholarship

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News