Keep Incirlik, Extradite Gülen?


Date posted: July 19, 2016

Michael Rubin

The coup over and his power entrenched, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is now seeking to leverage his new strength in the diplomatic arena. For close to three years, Erdoğan has insisted that Fethullah Gülen, a Pennsylvania-based Islamic thinker who was once his ally, is actually a terrorist mastermind. The real reason Erdoğan targets Gülen is because Erdoğan refuses to share the spotlight. He cannot tolerate the fact that Turks might respect others more than him. He also loathes economic competition. Erdoğan has reportedly accumulated billions of dollars since assuming the premiership and his ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) is flush with cash. He regularly uses the mechanisms of state—police, banking boards, tax audits—to punish any businessmen who donate to opposition political parties or causes with which he disagrees.

Erdoğan’s problem with Gülen is rooted in the business empire established by Gülen and his followers. They ran a network of schools and tutoring centers upon which ordinary Turks (and hundreds of thousands of students outside Turkey) came to rely, not because they agreed with Gülen’s religiosity, but rather because they valued the education they would receive. When Gülen refused to follow Erdoğan’s increasingly erratic diktats, Erdoğan not only confiscated Gülen’s enterprises in Turkey, but he traveled the world and demanded leaders shutter schools founded by Gülen’s followers even though, in many cases, they were the best schools available and counted children of presidents and ministers as their students. Gülen’s followers responded by leaking evidence (including illegally recorded phone conversations) showing Erdoğan’s deep complicity in corruption, as well as the cynical use of religion by close aides, like Egemin Bağış. For Erdoğan, politics is personal. Those who cross him in a real or imagined way must not only be punished; rather, they must be ruined or killed. In recent months, he has labeled Gülen and his followers to be terrorists, no different from the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and perhaps even worse than the Islamic State (ISIS, ISIL, Daesh).

For Erdoğan, politics is personal. Those who cross him in a real or imagined way must not only be punished; rather, they must be ruined or killed. In recent months, he has labeled Gülen and his followers to be terrorists, no different from the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and perhaps even worse than the Islamic State (ISIS, ISIL, Daesh).

The smoke had not yet cleared in the streets of Istanbul and Ankara when Erdoğan and Turkish state media blamed Gülen. Erdoğan has demanded that the United States extradite Gülen who has lived for 17 years in a compound outside of Saylorsburg, Pennsylvania. It is a request that Erdoğan and his fellow travelers have made repeatedly since political conflict erupted between Erdoğan and Gülen back in 2013. In 2015, I addressed the debate about Gülen’s extradition, here at COMMENTARY.

The compound in which Gülen sits is less a camp than a study center with guest houses arranged around a community center and a path around a small fish pond. It looks a bit like any number of time-share developments that sit around minor ski resorts. There is no evidence of the militarized camp that some Turks (who have never been to the location) describe, although there is a small guard post similar to what one might find at any golf course or gated community. Regardless, the idea that Saylorsburg could be the center of a coup plot is risible.

Alas, Secretary of State John Kerry seems to want to appease rather than stand on principle. He has said the United States would consider an extradition request so long as Turkey provides evidence. Standards of evidence in Turkey, however, leave a lot to be desired.

Dancing With the Devil, my history of U.S. diplomacy with rogue regimes and terror groups, discusses the Carter administration’s internal deliberations in the wake of the Islamic Revolution about whether to extradite the shah of Iran who, like Gülen, came to the United States for medical treatment. Carter, his National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski, and Secretary of State Cyrus Vance, believed that doing so could alleviate tension with Iran’s revolutionary leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. It did not, because Khomeini interpreted even the willingness to comply as a weakness to exploit.

Rumors abound that, behind-the-scenes, Erdoğan seeks to tie U.S. use of the Incirlik air base from which some operations are launched against the Islamic State to the extradition of Gülen. If that is true, then it is time to deploy another carrier strike group to the Eastern Mediterranean in order to pick up the slack or to shift personnel and equipment to Romania or Jordan. A true ally would not try to obstruct the international campaign against the Islamic State for the sake of a leader’s personal vendetta. To acquiesce to the extradition would be to signal that it’s open season to blackmail the United States.

Let us hope that Mr. Kerry studies history.

Source: Commentary Magazine , July 17, 2016


Related News

The anti-thesis of radical Islam

The Hizmet movement is Turkey’s strongest civil Islamic movement, and it can employ social dynamics to resist the AK Party. The race for the local polls slated for March 30 is between the AK Party and the Hizmet movement, not between the AK Party and other political parties.

EU and Turkey’s rights abuse

How did Turkey plunge into this mess of freedom suffocation, and what has really gone wrong with the once-admired President Erdogan ? While I keep pondering on these questions, I believe it is not too late for the Turkish government to retrace its steps and embrace full democratic norms.

Gülen files criminal complaint over illegal wiretapping

Illegal wiretapping has been an issue in Parliament as well, as opposition parties have asked for a parliamentary session to address wiretappings carried out by the National Intelligence Organization (MİT). Main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) İstanbul deputy Ferit Mevlüt Aslanoğlu called for a parliamentary session to inform deputies about the technical details of wiretapping.

Pro-Erdoğan journalist: Gülen followers should be kept in detention camps, given food tickets

Cemil Barlas, a staunch supporter of Tayyip Erdoğan and commentator for the pro-government A Haber TV, said during a program that followers of the Gülen movement, which the government accuses of being behind a failed coup on July 15, must be kept in detention camps and should be given food tickets.

The Gülen Movement: a modern expression of Turkish Islam – Interview with Hakan Yavuz

In a way, they [the Gülen movement] represent a new model of Islam in Turkey, at peace with democracy and modernity. This also reflects the Anatolian understanding of Islam, i.e. the Sufi conception of morality is at the centre of the movement. I would consider it as a movement based on the re-imagining of Islam and consisting of loose networks under the guidance and leadership of Fetullah Gülen.

520 children of imprisoned mothers growing up in jail, yet Turkey celebrates Children’s Day

As Turkey celebrated the 97th anniversary of the foundation of the Turkish Parliament and Children’s Day on April 23, at least 520 children with imprisoned mothers have been deprived of enjoying the day as they are obliged to grow up in jail.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Groundless terror probe into Kimse Yok Mu aims to intimidate civil society, GYV says

Conceptual contradictions when it comes to rhetoric about ‘parallel state’

[Part 5] Gülen says ballot box is not everything in a democracy

[Political Scandal a la Turca] What is happening in Turkey right at this moment?

A Ramadan Birthday Dinner

Real democrats cannot politicize Islam

Turkish volunteers reach out to orphans in Nairobi

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News