Turkey’s Fading Democracy

Dr. Alp Aslandogan
Dr. Alp Aslandogan

Date posted: February 11, 2014


Not long ago, Turkey was considered a model of constitutional democracy in the Middle East. For this reason, President Obama chose Turkey as his first majority-Muslim destination. But this 90-year old democracy is now facing a major crisis. Four corruption investigations that touched the sons of three ministers and the prime minister have sparked massive government reaction, led to the collapse of rule of law and significantly undermined the foundations of Turkish democracy.

Here’s how the shining light of democracy in the Middle East began to fade: On Dec. 17, after a 14-month investigation, Turkish prosecutors and police detained several high-profile, politically-connected individuals after alleged attempts by the interior ministry to interfere with the investigation. Millions in cash were recovered from shoeboxes and bookshelves, along with electronic steel vaults, images, videos, telephone conversations and payment records that implicated these individuals.

In two related investigations, the director of state-owned HalkBank and four ministers are suspected of receiving bribes from an Iranian businessman who has been allegedly aiding Iran bypass international financial sanctions. A third investigation includes evidence of rigging state construction tenders and granting permits for protected historic areas. The fourth investigation, which involves a charity led by the prime minister’s son, was stalled after the lead prosecutor was removed. Since the investigations began, three ministers and five parliamentarians from the ruling AK Party (AKP) have resigned.

That the AKP’s third term is mired in systemic corruption is discouraging for Turkey’s democracy. Even more worrisome, though, is the fact that corruption has led to an authoritarian trend in which those who refuse political obedience are profiled and discriminated against.

Instead of allowing the legal investigation to proceed unimpeded, the government chose to remove Istanbul’s police chief and replace him with a bureaucrat with no relevant experience. It pacified the prosecutor, discredited him with a media smear campaign and then removed him from the case. The interior ministry removed hundreds of police investigators from their posts and required the replacing investigators to inform their politically appointed superiors of any future investigations. Media’s access to the police is also restricted. Online media coverage of legal investigations are threatened with a bill that places websites, blogs and social media under political censorship.

Prime Minister Erdogan has blamed the current investigations as part of an international political conspiracy by the U.S. ambassador, influential preacher Fethullah Gulen, Wall Street Journal, BBC and the “interest lobby.”

Targeting Gulen‘s sympathizers, also known as “camia” or “Hizmet,” is not just convenient; it is strategic. Media elements affiliated with the Hizmet movement speak directly to AKP’s voter base and unlike the civil society groups that AKP managed to endear through various mechanisms, Hizmet movement has maintained its independence. Therefore there is really nothing that stops Hizmet participants from presenting the inconvenient truths about AKP’s elite leadership.

The AKP already has tight control of both the executive and legislative branches. The opposition parties are unable to pass legislation, oppose AKP’s legislation or start a parliamentary investigation against any member of the executive branch. And now, since the corruption investigations, there is a full-scale effort to tame the judiciary.

AKP advisers and parliamentarians have issued tweets and other forms of messages threatening the prosecutors involved in corruption investigations with deadly consequences. A prosecutor in the city of Izmir who was pursuing a graft probe involving a relative of AKP’s mayoral candidate declared that he was threatened by the undersecretary of the justice ministry to halt the investigation or “face the results.”

AKP is also gearing up to pass a legislation that will dramatically increase the powers of the justice minister in the Supreme Council of Judges and Prosecutors, empowering the justice minister to approve or reject investigations of members of the judiciary. This legislation, if enacted, would completely remove the independence of the judiciary and bring it under political control. It has already received strong criticism from the European Union.

All this already undermines the basic democratic tenet of separation of powers. But it gets worse.

Never in Turkish history has a single person or party achieved this level of media subservience. Today, AKP leadership controls Turkish media through an approach of carrots and sticks. Several media groups receive preferential treatment in exchange for AKP-friendly editorial policies. Some of these media organizations were acquired by AKP-friendly businesses through questionable funds and processes. Opposition CHP leader brought the question of whether Prime Minister was personally involved in the transfer of Sabah media group to a friendly business to Turkish parliament.

Media not friendly to AKP, on the other hand, are threatened with intimidation, inspections and fines. These media group owners face similar threats to their other businesses. Columnists have been fired for criticizing the AKP leadership — some of whom described the ongoing owner-censorship publicly.

Another dimension of AKP’s increasingly authoritarian trend is the use of the National Intelligence Service (MIT) to spy on and profile citizens and civil servants. Last June, Turkish newspapers, such as the liberal Taraf daily, revealed draft legislation that would give unprecedented powers to the National Intelligence Service (MIT). While this legislation was not brought to the parliament, reports were published about MIT signing protocols with Ministry of Education and Turkish Airlines to spy on and profile citizens.

On December 4, AKP deputy chairman Huseyin Celik admitted to such profiling and claimed, in an almost comedic fashion, that this was an old habit of MIT that the AKP-appointed intelligence chief was unable to stem. This is unfortunate because for decades, citizens who did not embrace the Kemalist ideology had been profiled and discriminated against and some of the current AKP leaders personally suffered from this policy in the past.

Within the last year, the AKP elite has either implemented or attempted many other undemocratic policies and actions. These include harsh reaction to the peaceful protestors at Gezi Park, attempts to regulate student homes and introducing draft legislation banning prep courses that prepare students for nationwide college placement tests, making it illegal to run math and science tutoring centers.

AKP’s 2011 election manifesto prominently featured a new, civilian-based constitution. The half-hearted effort to draft a new constitution was abandoned after it became clear that the inclusion of a powerful office of presidency was infeasible. Operating under a constitution drafted under the 1980 military junta while the junta members face civilian courts is ironic.

In the face of systemic corruption allegations and mounting evidence, the strategy chosen by AKP elite appears to be to subjugate the judiciary to political control, and hence stifle current corruption investigations and block future ones. In an attempt to justify this blatant assault on the independence of the judiciary, and other authoritarian measures, Gulen-inspired Hizmet movement is used as a scapegoat.

Against mounting criticism of their authoritarian measures, AKP elite’s often-repeated argument that they represent the will of the people is fragile. Free and fair elections require public access to information and the lack of unfair advantage by those in power. In Turkey, public access to information is restricted by media control and censorship. And businesses that are given government contracts are required to return the favor by donating to AKP-designated charities and assist AKP election campaign financially — thus giving AKP an unfair advantage. The intimidation of the judiciary and the constant shuffling of police prosecutors make it nearly impossible to investigate any corruption case that involves members of the AKP leadership or their relatives.

The current trend is toward the hegemony of the executive branch of the government and the situation is regarded as a move away from EU democratic states and toward the authoritarian regimes of the region.

Under normal circumstances, the 58 percent of Turkish population who supported the democratic constitutional amendments of 2010 would punish this trend at the ballot box. In a recent poll conducted face-to-face with 1,545 adults by MetroPOLL Strategic and Social Research Center, 60 percent of those surveyed agreed that the prosecutors were right to proceed with the corruption investigations, versus only 26.5 percent who did not. 90 percent of those surveyed said that they would not support the ruling party if its leaders turned a blind eye to corruption.

These are clear indications that Turkish people, when informed accurately, would send a clear message to their government regarding corruption and authoritarianism. But, with the ongoing intimidation of the judiciary and media censorship, will they get an accurate picture of their government’s performance? Will Turkey be able to overcome this conundrum? If history is any indication, we can keep our faith in the democratic wisdom of Turkish voters.

Source: Huffington Post , February 11, 2014

Related News

To escape punishment, punish them all

The Turkish prime minister has decided that if he continues to be angry and vengeful, his power will be cemented. In his latest address in Parliament, he pushed his angry discourse to higher — or lower — levels, to make clear that he will not forgive and he will punish. Since he has chosen the Hizmet movement as the enemy, all he wants to do is inflict harm, regardless of on who or what.

Turkish American ‘balance alignment’

Ali H. Aslan, Washington D.C. If, when I began working in Washington 16 years ago, someone had come up to me and said, “The day will come when nearly 50 senators and representatives from the US Congress will participate in a Turkish gathering,” I would have said he was dreaming. And if someone had also […]

Cameroonian Governor Thanked Turkish Nation for the Turkish Schools

ENSAR TUNA ALATÜRK – BURSA Abakar Ahmat, the Governor of Ngaundere state, Republic of Cameroon, paid a visit to Sahabettin Harput, the Governor of Bursa, Turkey. Mr. Ahmat thanked Mr. Harput for the Turkish schools in Cameroon on behalf of the Turkish nation. Governor Ahmat was accompanied during the visit by the Mayor of Ngaundere Hamadou Dawa, […]

Turkish Olympiads and achieving peace

ORHAN OĞUZ GÜRBÜZ A utopia ushers in a new era. We explore and take courageous actions thanks to our dreams of what is possible. Turkish colleges around the world are sponsored by entrepreneurs who are members of a movement in Turkey that has made serious progress in creating this utopia. If you describe languages, religions, […]

Pregnant behind bars with a two-year-old kid

Elif Aydın, 31, is one of the educators arrested in Turkey over the past three years. She was two-months pregnant when she was sent to prison. The pregnant woman stayed by sharing the same bed with his son in prison for months.

Kimse Yok Mu distributes aid to Syrian refugees

As Turkey is trying to meet the needs of the hundreds of thousands of Syrian refugees who have taken shelter in Turkey from the war in Syria, charity organizations have scrambled to launch massive aid campaigns to lend a hand to the embattled refugees, with Kimse Yok Mu providing food and aid for 2,500 Syrians in İstanbul every week.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Policeman, teacher wife and premature baby under arrest over Gülen links

MHP: Gov’t should not harass its citizens who open Turkish schools abroad

Hizmet schools win 64 out of 120 TÜBİTAK medals despite gov’t pressure

Nigerian govt demands immediate resolution from Turkey

Concluding statement of the International panel on Mary announced

Liberals silent as Turkey targets its own Khashoggi

Amir Hussain on Fethullah Gulen and Hizmet Movement

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News