Gülen Community and Gülen’s Reminder

Hadi Uluengin
Hadi Uluengin


Date posted: November 3, 2012

Hadi Uluengin, April 13, 2011

Last week in this column I wrote that large masses whose common denominator is to adopt Fethullah Gülen’s spiritual leadership cannot be referred to as a ‘cemaat’ or religious community or brotherhood. I made this claim because the Gülen Movement’s (aka Hizmet movement) pluralism in quantity and diversity in quality means that it must now be defined as a ‘camia’ or a social community.

What is more important and fatal is the movement’s inability to provide a satisfactory answer for claims and accusations with respect to a ‘lack of transparency.’ This inability provides a fertile ground for the ‘monster’ fantasy of the above-mentioned circles. To put in a rather modern fashion, the Fethullah Gülen Movement is suffering from an ‘image problem.’

Generating differences is natural, and such is the case in every intensifying body. To cut a long story short, with the exception of loyalty to the charismatic figure who has been compelled to live in the US against his will, participants in this movement do not act in a monolithic manner. Nor are they part of any centrally organized hierarchy.

Despite the reality that this phenomenon of transition from a religious brotherhood to a community has most definitely occurred—a process of expansion and diversification—the ‘other’s’ perception of the Gülen Movement has not changed. By ‘other’ I refer to those large masses who are essentially from secular, urban, and Alevite circles, and who are allergic to the word ‘tariqat,’ or spiritual order, because of earlier conditioning.

It is a fact that these circles consider the community in question to be a ‘monster’—a monster who is all-powerful and able to do anything it wants. Imagine a ‘monster’ (which is a combination of) associations from other cultures: a monster organized in a Bolshevik central discipline, raised in a Catholic Jesuit elitism, equipped with a Protestant Calvinist mission, and kneaded in the secrecy of the Catholic Opus Dei or a secular Freemasonry. And whoever looks cross-eyed at this ‘monster’ or places an obstacle in its path is doomed to be immediately sent to Silivri Prison!

NO! The Fethullah Gülen community does not fit in that paranoia! Neither my observations over the last two decades, nor the messages released by the spiritual leader in Pennsylvania contain evidence to verify claims and accusations that this movement is a ‘stealthy monster’ or a ‘genie out of its bottle.’

As a matter of fact, the pioneers who have been generating these claims and accusations from time immemorial are well-known. The flames of this paranoia are being fanned by rigid and classic ‘secularists’ who have not taken the trouble to analyze the nature of religion-civil relationship in Muslim societies. Nor have they sought to understand the movement by analyzing Bediuzzaman Said Nursi, who is positioned in the movement’s origins.

On the contrary, the Gülen Movement is far from being a ‘monster.’ It has no counterpart in the Islamic world, it is unique to Turkey, and it shines brightly in the Islamic world. Its bright light shines from both its humanistic rhetoric that it has conveyed from the very beginning and its values that mesh well with a secular way of living despite its religious outlook.

Having said that, this does not mean that this community collectively, its varying formations, or its individual members are immune from criticism, and it can never mean as such! From my perspective, for instance, I am very much discomforted by its male-dominance and lack of women—for which one is hard-pressed to find any reasonable explanation—and its general and standard monotony revealed in their suits and the way they all wear mustaches, or even the low aesthetic taste or kitsch one can observe from the TV studios to the design of school buildings.

The Gülen Movement is far from being a ‘monster.’ It has no counterpart in the Islamic world, it is unique to Turkey, and it shines brightly in the Islamic world. Its bright light shines from both its humanistic rhetoric that it has conveyed from the very beginning and its values that mesh well with a secular way of living despite its religious outlook.

What is more important and fatal is the movement’s inability to provide a satisfactory answer for claims and accusations with respect to a ‘lack of transparency.’ This inability provides a fertile ground for the ‘monster’ fantasy of the above-mentioned circles. To put in a rather modern fashion, the Fethullah Gülen Movement is suffering from an ‘image problem.’

Gülen himself said recently as reported by Huseyin Gulerce (1) that ‘we should take a look at ourselves,’ as to why there is such a perception, thus imparting a lesson of wisdom and responsibility and implying a need for self-questioning and criticism within the camia. In other words, he reminded his followers once again of the principles and rules of the ‘path’ for the participants in the Movement who gather around the spiritual common denominator of his name, but who potentially carry the risk of diverting into different routes because of their ‘community’ (camia) qualities.

I am faithful that this reminder will be wholeheartedly welcomed by the Gülen camia.

Source: Hurriyet. Original article is in Turkish. English translation is retrieved from fgulen.com.

Click here to read Hadi Uluengin’s previous article.

(1) Click to read Huseyin Gulerce’s related article: We’ll kiss the hands of those who tell us our shortcomings


Related News

Civil Rights, the Hizmet Movement, and the Liberative Power of Education

Hizmet stands in contrast to other contemporary so-called “Islamist” movements which are primarily political in nature, seeking to pursue a reformist agenda by overtly “Islamizing” the governmental and legal structures of existing Muslim majority nation-states.

Defamation campaign against Hizmet condemned by CSOs from across country

A large-scale dark propaganda war is being conducted by some circles close to the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government against the Hizmet movement and Gülen, particularly since a corruption scandal erupted in December of 2013 in which three Cabinet ministers’ sons, many state bureaucrats and renowned businessmen accused of giving bribes in exchange for favors were implicated.

Gülen Movement: An Alternative to Fundamentalism

Helen Rose Ebaugh, an American professor specializing in the sociology of religion, sees the movement founded by the controversial Turkish preacher Fethullah Gülen as both an opportunity for the West and a serious alternative to religious extremism.

Fethullah Gulen sends his condolences to victims of Boston bombings

“I am deeply saddened by the tragic bomb attack at the Boston Marathon that cost the lives of innocent people and injured many more. I express my absolute condemnation of this senseless act of violence that accomplished nothing more than the infliction of unbearable pain on innocent people. I send my sincere condolences to the […]

Gülen book finds wide readership in northern Iraq

A book written by Kurdish journalist Rebwar Karim on Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen’s approach to the Kurdish question has been attracting a significant amount of attention in northern Iraq.

‘Mr. Gülen is to me simultaneously both incredibly modest and a visionary’

I’m inspired by the Hizmet Movement. I didn’t realize that until I came in contact with the Movement, but all of my life, education and service and dialog have been transformative to me. … This is the work that all of our hearts should be doing. So it remains a source of inspiration for me in my work.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Ongoing tussle: Students, parents protest closure of Pak-Turk School in Khairpur

Ex-FM Yakış defends Turkish schools as the torch bearer of Ottoman vision

Fethullah Gülen’s initiatives for peace to be discussed in Rotterdam

Police pressure businessmen who sued Erdoğan over Hizmet remarks

Terrorist organization seeks to fill void in Southeast after closure of prep schools

Education in Mother Tongue: Eventual Solution to the Problem

Fethullah Gulen Statement on ISIS

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News