On Hizmet: Why do I not criticize it?

Ali Bulaç
Ali Bulaç


Date posted: July 12, 2014

Ali Bulaç

Hizmet has obviously come to the fore on Turkey’s agenda. It has been accused of plotting against the government in the name of external powers, building a parallel state within the state, leaking documents, taping and distributing videos in illegal -and immoral at the same time- ways and then blackmailing people with them.

The allegations are -without a doubt- unacceptable actions given their contents. Yet, none of them has been proved so far with convincing evidences or documents. The honorable Fethullah Gulen in particular and the Hizmet authorities rejected them all. Hizmet believes a termination plan on Hizmet, which was drafted back in 2004, is now in action. Hizmet has been defending itself via media or various platforms. If false evidences or documents are not fabricated, the only basis of those against Hizmet is the opposition and outcry of the pro-Hizmet media.

I did my best in order that this fight comes to a cease and does not lead to disunity among Muslims. If the academics, writers and opinion leaders that I believed to have the foresight had suppressed the dissension and use the referee method, an Islamic method, the situation may not have become this big. Nevertheless, my hope is that our country’s Muslims recover this crisis with the least damage possible.
As the saying goes, “Blessing comes out of sorrow.” Every one should draw a lesson from this tragic situation. I believe the AKP people will learn their lessons. And Hizmet too will definitely ponder the experience it has been through.

Some readers have questioned why I have criticized AKP but not Hizmet and whether Hizmet is as pure as the driven snow. Here’s my answer:

1) No civil action is free from mistakes and wrongs. To err is human! Only the prophets, who are infallible, are free from making mistakes.

2) Based on this basic principle, Hizmet too surely has mistakes and wrongs. It will go ahead successfully if it reflects on them and draws lessons, today and tomorrow.

3) We can raise two aspects of Hizmet open to criticism. First one is its religious view and its perspectives on Islam and service. And the second one is its social and political attitude. But as it’s about politics, Hizmet’s religious stance is debatable but not by politicians or incompetent columnists.

4) I raised my views and criticisms on Hizmet previously in my book “Religion, City and Community: Fethullah Gulen Experience.” My views are the same. But why I do not criticize it today is because of two reasons: a) I believe that a nationally backed, international operation is at work in Turkey and the Middle East. This operation aims to eliminate Islam’s presence from public space and push it to private and marginal space by force. It has adopted an active role in AKP’s headquarter. It has started its operation with Hizmet and, in no time, the community found itself in the middle of it. It encompasses other religious groups, communities and AKP too. In short, the international powers have gave up on the moderate Islam and been executing a coup against religiously sensitive people via national states. The same has been going on in the Gulf, Egypt and Turkey. b) Accusing Hizmet Movement with the words “You did such and such mistakes” just when it’s about to be slaughtered will be to help the butchers presenting victims to national or global gods. Just like accusing AKP of its past mistakes and calling it to account during the trial in 2007 meant to support its closure. It is the same thing. Covert criticism is fine. It may and should be done publicly too when it’s time. c) It is my moral duty to support Hizmet. This newspaper has enabled me to express my views. I feel obliged to do this. I would do the same if it were AK Party, National View or Risale-i Nur, Suleymanci, Ismail Aga, Iskenderpasa and Menzil groups. I have been by their side through their hard times too. I wouldn’t like to see neither Hizmet nor AKP suffer. A tragic situation, an obvious injustice is in question. We will continue our discussion later.

Published [in Turkish] on Zaman, 07 July 2014, Monday

Source: HizmetMovement.com , July 12, 2013


Related News

UN slams Thailand, Myanmar over deportation of Turk

The United Nations expressed grave concern on Saturday over the deportation by Myanmar and Thailand of a Turkish national over alleged connections to a July 2016 coup attempt against Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Muhammet is at least the sixth person to be deported from Southeast Asia over alleged connections to Gulen’s movement, the UN said.

“They won’t believe,” he said

AHMET KURUCAN “They won’t believe,” he said. “They won’t believe that we work for peace and the salvation of humanity. They won’t believe that we endeavor to create an island of peace where all of humanity can live in brotherhood. They won’t believe that you do not have expectations for this world or the next. […]

UK Parliament: No evidence that Gülen, movement behind coup attempt

Contrary to accusations made by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the Turkish government, the Foreign Affairs Committee of the UK Parliament has concluded that Fethullah Gülen and the movement he inspired as a whole were not behind a failed coup attempt in Turkey on July 15.

What should we expect from 2015?

As you may know, the Justice and Development Party (AKP) and President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan have been able to postpone the Kurdish settlement process they started in 2009 until after the 2015 elections.

“Abraham’s Table Gatherings” in Turkey hosts Assyrian community

“Abraham’s Table Gatherings” by Intercultural Dialogue Platform (KADIP) continues with the participation of diverse faith, religion, culture and ethnicity leaders. The guests of the series in May were representatives from the Orthodox Assyrian community. Through the gatherings, KADIP under the umbrella of Journalists and Writers Foundation intends to get together, every month, with another culture […]

‘Fethullah Gulen Might Return to Turkey on This Condition’

Will Fethullah Gulen, who currently resides in the US, return to Turkey? One active figure of the Hizmet movement, Cemal Usak, who serves as the Vice President of the Journalists and Writers Foundation, answered this highly speculated question. Vice President of the Journalists and Writers Foundation (JWF), Cemal Usak, stated that Gulen may return to […]

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Kimse Yok Mu repeatedly prevented from offering aid in Palestine

Turkish Gov’t media targets exiled journalists, their lives at risk

Mali Minister of Education visits ‘Kimse Yok Mu’

Hate speech and its impact on the movement (1)

JWF organized a side-event at UN in Geneva

Is Gülen Movement A Religious Community (cemaat) or A Social Community (camia)?

Gülen worries fake news could associate new terror attacks, assassinations in Turkey with him

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News