Turkey’s Brain Drain and the Disappearing Academic Freedom


Date posted: September 7, 2016

Hakan Saglam

The name you read above is not my real name: it is a pseudonym. The names I will mention below are not authentic, either. Unfortunately, there are various good reasons for that. First, the content is about Turkey and the author’s parents live in Turkey. He does not want his parents to experience the same difficulties (e.g. detainment) as few others, such as famous former soccer player Hakan Sukur and journalist Bulent Korucu’s  parents, had to go through. This method was most recently implemented for the journalist Can Dundar whose wife couldn’t exit the country because she is married to someone who created some “troubles” for President Erdogan. Another reason is not to cause any further harm to those whose stories I share below. They had it enough recently.

I can’t do much but help their voices be heard by the world who often hear the rhetoric of those in power. This article may just decrease my deeply felt shame I experience because of what is going on in my country. I am an academic but I try to serve as a journalist this time since many true journalists are now in jail in Turkey.

These three stories are about three academics, who are the victims of the immense waves of purge led by the government in Turkey. None of these academics had a clue about the coup attempted on July 15th. They still do not know who are responsible. Even the government can’t provide a consistent and convincing story about how it happened despite they speak in very certain terms that it is Fethullah Gulen who has orchestrated the coup. They may be curious if it was an authentic coup attempt that failed or if it was set up for a failure from the beginning. There are lots of unknowns but there is one thing that is clear to them: it turned out to be a real coup that ruined their lives even though they had nothing to do with it.

Hasan was the luckiest among the three because he was not in Turkey during the coup. He was studying abroad on July 15th and learned the coup through the Internet. He was supposed to go back to Turkey but he decided not to do so because of the news on the immense purging in mostly the government and some private institutions. Few days after the coup he learned that he was dismissed from his position at a state university. Police raided his home. They could not find anything but books, which are considered to be “solid evidence” nowadays if authored by Gulen. His young child and wife have been in Turkey during this horrifying period. His wife also lost her job. She is now living with her parents without a job or an income. Hasan hesitates to apply for an asylum because if he does, he has to stay for three years and his family can’t join him. If he does not, he will then become illegal. Hasan holds a PhD but now he is trying to learn new skills that he never needed such as fixing smartphones. This is how he is hoping to survive. All I have done seems to have gotten lost, he said. “I have start from scratch.”

Yusuf’s story is even more difficult because he was in Turkey during the coup and lost his job at another state university. He is now living in his hometown in his parent’s farm. His PhD does not do any good to him at this point. He can’t look for jobs in other countries because his passport is not valid anymore. He has no income; nor his wife because she was also dismissed from her job. Even more difficult is that his daughters are suffering from serious health issues and they need to see their doctor regularly. He is not sure how to care for them without a regular stream of income. All he can do is to wait for his turn because he could have already been detained like 20,000 others. He is still lucky, as this has not happen so far.

Selim is another scholar who has lost his job at a private university in Turkey that is now closed after the coup. Shortly after the coup attempt, Turkish government decided to shut down a handful of universities leaving the academics unemployed. Like others, Selim lost his job and possibly his entire career since other universities won’t dare to employ him. No one and no institution have the courage to do so. His several books published in Turkey is not enough for him to survive and the publishing house may cancel its agreement with him to look nice to the government. This is how you prove “your side” in Turkey. 

No scholar in Turkey feels any freedom or courage to express even a tiny little concern nowadays unless they have first proven themselves to be pro-Erdogan. Some are simply just sorry about what is going on, and some others feel content about not being targeted yet. Some have escaped from the country illegally like some Syrians have done. Brain drain is the current reality in Turkey and what is more terrifying is the fact that those who did not lose their jobs can’t express their thoughts, either. Even before the coup attempt, some academics lost their positions just because they stated their concerns about the way the army had intervened in southeastern Turkey because of troubles created by the separatist PKK. 

The names of Selim, Hasan, and Yusuf are not real but their stories are. Pretense and hypocrisy are easier and more rewarding; moreover, it seems like this will continue to be de facto reality on the ground for a long while unless the UN or global public opinion realizes it and does something against it.


Related News

German Politician: Turkey like Nazi Germany after Reichstag

FDP leader Christian Lindner said he saw parallels between Erdogan’s behavior and the aftermath of the Reichstag fire in 1933 portrayed by the Nazis as a Communist plot against the government and used by Adolf Hitler to justify massively curtailing civil liberties. “We are experiencing a coup d’etat from above like in 1933 after the Reichstag fire. He is building an authoritarian regime tailored solely to himself,” Lindner said.

Gulen movement becoming victim of its own legend

I don’t know whether they are aware of it, but a danger that needs to be taken very seriously awaits the Gulen movement. In the eyes of the Turkish society, which is believing of conspiracy theories, the Gulen movement is mythicized beyond its real dimensions. The power and influence of the Gulen movement is being so exaggerated that if no precautions are taken, this imagined power will one day destroy it.

Turkey after the purge: Journalists and judges pay the price

Immediately after the failed coup, the administration published lists of people that Erdogan claimed had participated in the coup. The lists included people from all professions, and journalists were no exception. Turkey now has the highest number of imprisoned journalists in the world, with three times the number jailed as Iran and China.

Gov’t closes schools instead of resolving education problems

The Ministry of Education and the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government have been focusing on closing down private prep schools for university preparation (dershanes) and Turkish schools abroad instead of spending its energy on resolving critical problems in the Turkish education system, experts say.

Erdoğan’s Henchman: Oppression Targeting Gülen Movement To Be More Severe After Zarrab Case

Turkish autocratic President Erdoğan’s former speechwriter and current Justice and Development Party (AKP) deputy Aydın Ünal wrote on Tuesday that the witch hunt against the alleged followers of the Gülen movement in Turkey will eventually become severe as a result of the Zarrab case in the US.

Rebecca Harms: Working in Gülen-linked educational institutions not a crime

Speaking during the general assembly of the European Parliament (EP) on Thursday, Harms said working in institutions such as schools or universities with links to the Gülen movement is not a crime and that, similarly, being critical of the government and being a critical journalist are not crimes.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

The Gulen Movement Is Not a Cult — It’s One of the Most Encouraging Faces of Islam Today

Turkish Deputy PM rules out ‘ill will’ against Gülen community, unveils prep school draft details

Kimse Yok Mu soup kitchen to serve weekly hot meal in Somalia

Gülen seeks to dismiss US lawsuit, says it is ‘pure political theater’

Kimse Yok Mu chair Cingöz: Everyone feels some type of oppression in Turkey

Mischief-makers and the Hizmet movement

No country is safe for Gülen sympathizers, Erdoğan says

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News