Gülen discounts neither past nor modernity


Date posted: October 9, 2010

A conference titled “Mapping the Gülen Movement,” which took place in Amsterdam on Thursday, witnessed a detailed examination by academics and experts of various aspects of the Gülen movement.

Organized by the Dialoog Academie in the Netherlands, the international “Mapping the Gülen Movement” conference was held at the famous Felix Meritix Congress Center in Amsterdam. The conference was attended by many social scientists and academics from various universities, with one of the speakers well-known Turkish professor Doğu Ergil, who noted in his presentation that the Gülen Movement was a civil movement that called for maximum participation and support from its members. “Just as he has never discounted the past, Fethullah Gülen has also never been someone to discount or exclude modernity itself. Unlike the politicization of Islam, or political Islam, the Gülen movement has always embraced a view that does not shut out Western society and that does not clash with modernity,” he said. Touching on Turkey’s particular situation, Ergil also noted that the Gülen movement had never been at odds with the various elected governments of Turkey and that it helped contribute to finding solutions to long-term national problems by casting wide social nets and using peaceful methods to generate answers. Ergil explained: “This method, which begins by initiating change within itself first then aiming to spread this change to society, is, unlike the Kemalist method that aims for a ‘top-down’ sort of revolution, a movement that begins to develop within society itself. In harmony with social ethics, the law, social contracts and universal law, this movement is involved in some very important work.”

Speaking at an Amsterdam conference, Professor Doğu Ergil noted that the Gülen movement has never been at odds with any of the elected governments of Turkey and that as a movement it did not discount the past. As for Professor Thomas Michel from Georgetown University, he noted that the secret to the success of the movement lies in the sincerity of its volunteers.

Gulen ConferenceProfessor Thomas Michel of Georgetown University touched on the religious aspects of the Gülen movement, noting in particular Gülen’s propensity for references to Mevlana and the influence Sufism has had on him, with the importance placed on divine service and sincerity. Noting that it is not the bigness or smallness of any particular work that is important but rather the sincerity with which a person sets out to do that bit of work, Michel went on, “If good works are the body, their spirit is the sincerity with which they are approached.” With this, Michel connected the success of the Gülen movement to the sincerity backing the movement and its members. He underscored the vital aspect played by sincerity in all acts, regardless of size, and noted that once sincerity was present, the act itself gained value and importance. Also pointing to the importance of the act of service within this large movement of volunteers, Michel noted: “A teacher teaching physics in Kyrgyzstan and a businessman involved with charity in İzmir are both worshipping in fact.

Fethullah Gülen keeps the concept of worship quite wide. He notes that serving the people is serving the greater good, and he connects self-rescue to the rescue of others.”

‘I was curious, so I researched it’
Professor Helen Rose Ebaugh from the University of Houston noted for her part that when she first found out about the Gülen movement, she was curious about where the “water for this windmill was coming from.” She explained that she decided to research it herself, going on: “I went to İstanbul, Bursa and Mudunya, and I looked into the flow of money. I stayed as a guest at the homes of some businessmen in İstanbul. In Islam, the left hand is not supposed to know what the right hand has given. But what I really wanted to learn was who was giving what exactly. After our pleasant teatime chat, I asked my question, and numbers started to be explained to me. Everyone noted that they were giving away 10 percent of their earnings.

Just think about this network and strength. These are believable people. But in Turkey, I have never seen the state give over monetary support to all this. As for Azerbaijan, the state gives over some buildings and plots of land for schools.”

The Story published on Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/news-223853-100-gulen-discounts-neither-past-nor-modernity-concludes-conference.html


Related News

Is Hizmet being subjected to genocide? (2)

In a recently leaked voice recording, which was not denied by those involved in it, Erdoğan’s son, Bilal, tells his father that an operation should be launched against the Hizmet movement. All these incidents indicate that the ruling party has used and will use laws in accordance with Erdoğan’s plans. Thus, a group cannot be destroyed solely with mass killings. It can be destroyed also with unfair and unlawful practices by passing specific laws, as we saw in many cases in the past.

60-year old man covers 309 km in 17 days to protest son’s arrest on coup charges

A 60-year-old Turkish man whose son has been kept in İstanbul Silivri Prison for over 10 months on coup charges, has walked a total of 309 km in 17 days as part of a “March of Justice.” Veysel Kılıç’s son was Air Force Academy student and arrested after July 15 coup attempt. Kılıç had been holding vigil since August 2016 in front of İstanbul Çağlayan Courthouse to protest his son’s arrest.

Modern authoritarianism

Freedom House publishes each year a report focusing on the levels of freedom in all countries compiled with complete methodological research. Its reports are accepted as reliable and are used by many political scientists in their work.

Prep school students dominate LYS university entrance exam

FEM, Körfez and Maltepe dershanes associated with faith-based Hizmet Movement (also known as Gülen Movement) dominated top spots in this year’s exams. Ö. Furkan Parmak, who received the highest score in the TM (Turkish-Math)-1, TM-2 and TM-3 categories in the LYS exam, studied for the exam at the Maltepe prep school in Ankara.

An Eye-Opening Trek Into Turkish Society

WALTER RATLIFF* In Gaziantep, Turkey, the children at a local orphanage were recently asked to write about what they wished for most in life. The exercise was designed to help them think about their goals for the future. However, one child took the answer in a different direction: “I wish my parents could come back […]

Before the Lights are Out…

You know how the poet that says, “Bleeding a thin line, my chest/Watched in wonder, amazed!” This was the exact situation I found myself in. It was a sorrowful moment, one that weighs you down, when the tears that have welled up in your eyes push themselves down your cheeks… It was as full of […]

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Turkey, The great purge – Four lives upturned by Erdogan’s ‘cleansing.’ Episode 2 – Mehmet

Washington Post: Biden needs to give Turkey’s Erdogan some tough advice

‘Erdoğan fights to eliminate Hizmet movement’

AK Party provincial board member resigns after insults

GYV discusses respect for sacred values at UN panel

Turkish Scholar Fethullah Gulen Speaks about PKK

The more we learn, the more we are the same

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News