Erdoğan is helping Hizmet community in three ways

Emre Uslu
Emre Uslu


Date posted: December 7, 2015

1. If President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had given an assurance to the world, saying, “The Hizmet movement never resorts to violence and it is an antidote to Islamist violence,” people would still have nurtured doubts and they still would have asked if they, like Islamists, would resort to violence under duress.

This was the globally accepted thesis: Islamist violence is a mechanism that has emerged as a reaction to dictatorial oppression. Political Islamists have turned it into a strategic instrument, but their violence is essentially a reaction to dictatorship. As Turkey had no dictatorship like those in Middle Eastern countries, Turkey-based religious communities and movements haven’t chosen violence as an instrument. If they, too, are exposed to oppression, they may choose violence as an instrument.

This thesis had been the dominant thesis in Western societies until recently. Erdoğan exposed the Hizmet movement to the oppression that typical Middle Eastern dictators impose on their rivals. At times, this oppression proved violent, such as in the death of a pregnant woman and her baby. Yet, Egypt’s dictator didn’t attempt to confiscate the property of the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) or that of the Ikhwan. Erdoğan surpassed him in that regard.

Despite these pressures, the Hizmet community has never resorted to violence. It hasn’t shown the slightest trace of violence. With this oppression and tyranny, Erdoğan has shown the world that while pro-violence organizations like the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) and al-Qaida were performing all kinds of violence and an Islamic government in Turkey was sending them weapons and ammunition, a religious community in Turkey, namely the Hizmet movement, risked everything and distanced itself from the government that backed the jihadist organizations. It is now suffering from pressure and persecution because of this. But they haven’t committed the slightest act of violence. A religious community that refrains from violence despite so much repression could serve as a model for non-violent Muslims all around the world. With his oppression, Erdoğan is boosting this perspective and helping the Hizmet community. People all around the world reason this way: If this community does not resort to violence to revolt against Erdoğan’s oppression, they will never resort to violence; we can work with them.

2. Erdoğan has ordered dozens of operations against the Hizmet community. Women, police officers, prosecutors and small business-owners were jailed. But not a single piece of evidence of illegality was found in hundreds of raids. The police couldn’t find a single box or purse of money or a single weapon. Yet the police operation against the sons of four ministers of the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) found boxes and safes full of money, plots, illegality, prostitution, influence-peddling, etc. If half of the operations conducted against the Hizmet community had been launched against the local leaders of the AKP, the whole country would smell like the Ümraniye district garbage dump. You couldn’t get anywhere near it because of the stench.

With these operations, Erdoğan has shown the grassroots of the Hizmet community and the small business owners who support the community that every single penny donated to the community has been spent properly. Not a single member of the community can be accused of embezzlement. None of them had a huge balance in their bank accounts. None of them had a shoebox full of dollars. Thus, Erdoğan helped to reinforce the trust of the Hizmet community’s supporters.

If these operations had not been launched, the people who support the community might have developed suspicions about how their donations are spent. Though AKP supporters siphoned funds from charities like Deniz Feneri (Lighthouse), the Hizmet community’s supporters do not have any doubts about misappropriation.

Thanks to these operations, Erdoğan has eliminated such doubts. Even if the Hizmet community had provided its donors with all the receipts for how their money was spent, people might still harbor suspicions. But Erdoğan used all the power of the police, the military and the National Intelligence Organization (MİT) against the community and no evidence of corruption could be found. This, in turn, has helped the grassroots develop an unshakable trust in the community. This is priceless help to the Hizmet community.

3. Though coming to power with only 34 percent of the vote, Erdoğan governed the country as easily as shooting fish in a barrel, despite the military’s resistance. He tackled monstrous problems with dexterity and managed to dispel the doubts about him without resorting to social polarization. Many secularists hadn’t believed that Erdoğan could be such an effective ruler.

Then, the AKP secured 47 percent of the national vote in 2007. It was able to govern the country successfully, despite the military issuing a memorandum and that the Constitutional Court might shut it down. It weathered the memorandum as well as a coup attempt. In the 2011 election, it secured 49 percent of the national vote. It governed the country smoothly until February 2012, even until the Gezi Park protests. It survived those protests with relatively little damage.

However, when the AKP broke away from the Hizmet community and the community withdrew its support from the AKP, the AKP was no longer able to govern the country smoothly. The AKP secured virtually 50 percent of the national vote, but no one can say the country is stable. The AKP has made a mess out of every errand it embarked upon without the support of the community. The Syrian crisis is an example. The Kurdish settlement process is another. The Mavi Marmara initiative — a ship carrying humanitarian aid attempting to breach Israel’s blockade of Gaza — is another. There are multiple examples.

Although the AKP is enjoying its most powerful period and it has been controlling the media and the bureaucracy since 2013, it has been unable to govern the country or ensure stability. It makes one mistake after another.

This makes intellectuals reason as follows: Apparently, what drove the AKP forward was the Hizmet community’s wisdom. Since the community withdrew, the AKP has been finding hard to survive. It cannot provide stability in the country. Every day, something is broken. By waging a war with the community, Erdoğan has proved that it was the community’s wisdom that ensured stability in the country. Thus, any political movement that seeks to have a say in Turkey will want to cooperate with the community to take advantage of this. wisdom.

In this way, Erdoğan is playing into the hands of the community…

Source: Today's Zaman , December 06, 2015


Related News

One blow after another at anti-Hizmet docu’s premier

The Pennsylvania screening of the documentary “The Gulen,” targeting the Hizmet Movement and the Honorable Fethullah Gulen, was met with failure.

Fethullah Gulen and Gulen Movement discussed in New York

A special conversation on Fethullah Gulen and the Gulen Movementby Peace Islands Institute was held at NY Turkish Cultural Center on April 9. The professor of Political Science and Public Administration, analyst and columnist Prof. Dogu Ergil was the guest speaker of the event hosted by Peace Islands Institute President Zafer Akin. In his opening speech, […]

Open Letter to the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA)

While known as a devoted organization to aim providing insights, affirmations, and appreciation of Muslims in North America, which would hopefully replace prejudicial, arrogant, dialectical confrontation towards the Muslims in North America, with mutual respect and dialogical encounter, it is so sad to see ISNA supporting an initiative to demonize another Muslim society which aims to promote Islam and mutual understanding and tolerance between cultures all over the world.

Hizmet movement discussed in heart of African Union

30 May 2012 / KAMİL ERGİN , ADDIS ABABA An international symposium on the Hizmet movement (aka Gulen movement), which includes followers of Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen’s principles, and the concept of dialogue, held in Ethiopia last week, brought together a large number of academics and top state officials from close to 40 countries to […]

Court imposes punitive fine on author for libeling Gülen family

Mısıroğlu was found guilty of fabricating lies about Gülen’s father and grandfather in his book, “Manipulation Movements from Past to Present – 3.”
Gülen’s brothers Seyfullah and Salih Gülen and his uncle Seyfettin Gülen sued the author at the 2nd Criminal Court of First Instance, arguing that the claims in the book are baseless and defamatory. Fethullah Gülen’s lawyers have filed a second libel suit against Mısıroğlu at the İstanbul 12th Criminal Court of First Instance.

PM Erdoğan widens hostile stance to include more and more groups

Erdoğan has been trying to dodge the damaging impact of the corruption scandals by using Hizmet as a scapegoat. Gülen, an ardent supporter of transparency and accountability in government, was critical of Erdoğan government’s efforts to stall the corruption investigations. Speaking to the BBC on Monday, Gülen said that the massive corruption investigations that have shaken the government cannot be covered up no matter how hard the government tries to derail the probes — not even by blaming the scandal on what the prime minister has called the “parallel state,” a veiled reference to the Hizmet movement inspired by Gülen.

Latest News

This notable Pocono resident has been living here in exile since 1999

Logistics companies seized over Gülen links sold in fast-track auction

That is Why the Turkish Government could Pay 1 Billion Euros

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

In Case You Missed It

Great interest shown in Turkish school in Egypt

Turkey ‘looking for scapegoats’ by linking schools in Nigeria to failed coup

German court fines pro-Erdoğan daily for calling Hizmet movement ‘terrorist’

Malaysia detains Turkish academic second time at Turkey’s request

TUSKON says systematic campaign of defamation is under way

Erdoğan’s abstract enemies: parallel organization and superior mind

Ahmet Şık’s book and Ergenekon’s media campaign (3)

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News