Hate towards Hizmet Movement as a political strategy

Date posted: February 28, 2014

Yasemin Aydın & Fatih Ceran

One must be well versed in the political usage of hate to understand recent Turkish politics. It is very central to political debates, and it has almost become the organizing principle for the Justice and Development Party’s (AK Party) election campaign. To get a grasp of social and political manifestations of hate, let’s first take a look at the interplay between hate and the individual.

A strong primordial feeling, hate relies on two essentials: a fragile self-perception and an existential threat. The presence of hate may be an indication of narcissism or an extreme lack of confidence. Either way, this is a problematic self-perception.

In the case of narcissism, the self is seen with some kind of ontological supremacy based on individual distinctiveness. The collective manifestations of narcissism may be justified as follows: On an ethnic basis, it paves the way for racism; on a religious basis, it promotes radical interpretations of religions; on an ideological basis, it creates extremist understandings.

In the case of a lack of confidence, it is even easier to create a perception that one is threatened. The subject is weak, defenseless and living in a ruthless world. An extreme lack of confidence also creates fear, which is fertile ground for hate.

Hater as a reactionary

A hater is a person who has never-ending hostility for whoever or whatever presents a threat. The threats don’t have to be real or even realistic, mostly they are a perception that is amplified by the fragile self-image of the hater. The hater’s concept of their self is sharp and exclusive. It employs clear cut definitions; however, this concept is usually defined in contract with other identities. This reactionary characteristic prevents the hater from developing a proactive identity. A hater is a hydrophobic person doomed to live on an island.

For the hater, there is always “us” and “them.” Whoever fits into the definition of “them” is dangerous, and the one who presents the biggest perceived danger becomes the very object of hate. Consequently, an emergency justifies, even necessitates, extraordinary measures be taken.

Corruption investigations that started on Dec. 17 caused immense political risk and were perceived as an existential threat by the AK Party. The corruption allegations were targeting the party at its heart, in the sense that the political discourse of the AK Party is built around religious/moral values and a systematic web of corruption would hardly fit in. If proven true, the allegations would create a lot of frustration among the electoral base. And if the AK Party members are prosecuted, it could bring some serious jail time. So, popularly and legally, it was undesirable.

So the case should have been handled very rationally and with great mastery. The “ruling elite“ within the party decided that they needed to make lot of fuss, enabling them to smokescreen the corruption allegations and bring the ongoing investigations to a halt. Moreover, they would once again have the ability to play the “victim“ in the eyes of the voter.

The political tradition of the party is advantageous. It had never attached itself to any political theory or text. So internal contradictions would not seem so obvious in this ever-pragmatic tradition.

A big and dangerous “frustration” was needed. No such thing was available in the country, so they had to make one. In this vein, a socially influential civic movement, the Hizmet movement became a target. The Hizmet movement had already been criticizing the government on its harsh policies. It said the government was employing repressive attitudes vis-à-vis democratic demands. Reforms had already come to a halt, the EU accesses ion process was make-believe, the settlement of the Kurdish issue was going nowhere and, most importantly, no political will was being put behind the making of a new and civilian Constitution. Moreover, the Hizmet was insisting on remaining in the civilian realm and resisting efforts to be placed under political control. In the eyes of the authoritarian elite of the party, the Hizmet already deserved to be “punished.”

It was not going to be easy; the Hizmet movement has broad support from every walk of life in the country. A very popular civic movement, many groups are sympathetic to the cause of the Hizmet. So, the image of the Hizmet had to be turned upside down.

They presented the Hizmet movement as an insidious group seeking to take control through the state apparatus by creating its own parallel state. They wanted people to believe that the Hizmet was collaborating with the US and Israel to topple the AK Party government. This juxtaposition would hurt the image of the Hizmet movement in the eyes of conservatives who constitute the AK Party’s central voter body. The Hizmet’s “treason“ would be the AK Party’s heroism.

This picture was clearly far from the public perception of the Hizmet movement, so people spreading propaganda have been utilized radically. Politicians and huge media outlets (recently bought by businessmen close to the AK Party) joined forces to repeat the same accusations over and over.

The orchestration of this immense PR project was apparently being done by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan himself, who kept making harsher-than-ever accusations during his rallies.

Prime Minister Erdoğan was targeting the volunteers of a civic movement in his country with visible “hate speech.” Hate became the most prominent element of his election campaign. He was trying to generate the sentiment of hate through the media he was controlling, and he was also trying to translate it into a political program. A perfect plan, though void of morality, which is employed only when useful.

Erdoğan needed to keep his audience fresh, so in time he raised the level of his accusations. He started using increasingly harsher rhetoric and started calling Hizmet volunteers “traitors,” “those who live in caves” and “assassins.” At a Religious Affairs Directorate meeting, the prime minister defined what “real faith” is and called Fethullah Gülen, the Islamic scholar who inspired the movement, a “false prophet.” This hate speech, the AK Party calculated, would bring them an election victory.

The AK Party has manipulated “wounds” in the social memory. The people are buying into this rhetoric, which claims “everyone is against us.” This story that there has been a “judicial coup” against the government is believable, because the path to democracy in Turkey has been interrupted by military coups before.

The Hizmet movement was portrayed as the Leviathan; it was big, monstrous and against the popular will. Erdoğan thought people would not remember that the Hizmet movement was a champion and supporter of steps toward democratization. How could a movement like that be making plots against the popular will?

Attacking the Hizmet would bring the AK Party significant political gain. First of all, because it has visible influence in every walk of life, a twisted image of the Hizmet would show how serious a threat it is. This would facilitate organizing the conservative camp behind Prime Minister Erdoğan, showing them they have to unite against this “powerful” traitor that is collaborating with external enemies. In this way, the AK Party would be able to divert public attention, an urgent matter for them, and justify its oppressive policies.

Despite the fact that there has been no evidence to support Erdoğan’s accusations, it hasn’t taken long for AK Party politicians to believe in this piece of fiction. Some of them would blindly follow their leader without thinking critically, and some are seeking political careers within the status quo. Some others have probably just fallen victim to the pro-AK Party media’s systematic smear campaigns.

This, again, fits perfectly with the political rhetoric of Erdoğan, who had already divided the country into “us” vs. “them” by calling whoever consumes alcohol a “drunkard” and whoever opposes his political views via street protests a “looter.” It was obvious that to mobilize his supporters, the prime minister needed objects to hate on. The Hizmet movement was an irresistible one, resisting politicization and insisting on independence.

Much-needed legal paralysis

The decision makers in the AK Party realized that they would go down in shame if they didn’t stop the corruption investigations. So they needed to legally paralyze the investigations. For this, the best way would be by threatening the judiciary — which Erdoğan did in his street rallies. “Oh, prosecutor,” he said, “I am not done with you yet.” He also wished to keep them and police officers in constant motion so that they wouldn’t be able make further investigations. More than 8,000 police officers have been reassigned, mostly to places irrelevant to their expertise. The Hizmet was portrayed as a state within a state, or a parallel state. Supposedly, the AK Party would just say that it was trying to get rid of this monster, this parallel state. There were heavy accusations made by the AK Party; the sentiments of the masses were being manipulated against the Hizmet, but there was no evidence. So the AK Party has not been able to open a court case against the Hizmet movement. Courts do not make decisions based on rhetoric; evidence is what they need.

Turkey will have three elections in one-and-a-half years — local, general and presidential elections. For an electoral victory, the AK Party needs to do two things: smokescreen the systematic corruption both legally and popularly, and keep the tension in society high. The fuel to keep the tension high can only come from extreme skepticism and the sentiment of hate.

This is why the AK Party organized its election campaign around hate speech in a calculated fashion.

Source: Todays Zaman , February 28, 2014

Related News

Turkish FM calls on Gülen Movement for dialogue to find way out political crisis

Delivering constructive messages to move away from political crisis over the graft probe, Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu has invited the Fetullah Gülen movement to engage in “dialogue and a strategic look toward the horizon.”

American reporters got an intriguing glimpse into the political mind-set in Turkey

Turkish leaders said they were astonished that they had so far been unsuccessful in persuading the United States Justice Department to even ask a federal judge to extradite Fethullah Gulen. The Turkish government said it had provided the United States with extensive proof against Mr. Gulen, who has denied involvement. But Turkish officials refused in several interviews to publicize a single piece of that evidence.

Police raid successful Gülen-inspired schools, kindergarten in eastern Turkey

As one of the numerous raids against the schools affiliated with Gülen movement, popularly known as Hizmet Movement, two schools and a kindergarten were raided by police along with inspectors on Friday morning.

Mueller Probes Flynn’s Role in Alleged Plan to Deliver Gulen to Turkey

Special Counsel Robert Mueller is investigating an alleged plan involving former White House national security adviser Mike Flynn to forcibly remove a Muslim cleric living in the U.S. and deliver him to Turkey in return for millions of dollars, according to people familiar with the investigation.

Is PM looking for someone he can pass the blame to?

Gulen’s words were clearly a conditional curse or a committing of his affair to God in total submission in the face of horrendous lies. “If your accusations are true, may God destroy us. But if your accusations are wrong, then may God destroy you,” he had said. Amen.

Turkey’s Brain Drain and the Disappearing Academic Freedom

Hasan was the luckiest because he was not in Turkey during the coup. He was studying abroad on July 15th and learned the coup through the Internet. He was supposed to go back to Turkey but he decided not to do so because of the news on the immense purging in mostly the government and some private institutions. Few days after the coup he learned that he was dismissed from his position at a state university.

Latest News

This notable Pocono resident has been living here in exile since 1999

Logistics companies seized over Gülen links sold in fast-track auction

That is Why the Turkish Government could Pay 1 Billion Euros

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

In Case You Missed It

Turks in America condemn unlawful government action during the corruption probe

Arrested vet diagnosed with cancer, not allowed for treatment at hospital

Response to aspersion on Hizmet

PM’s son: Dad, let’s initiate an operation against Hizmet’s senior members

Abant Platform: perspectives on Turkey

Turkish gov’t issues detention warrants for 121 women on Int’l Women’s Day

A Turkish citizen spreads a message of love and coexistence from the US

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News