Gülen media, pro-government media, is it the same thing?


Date posted: February 18, 2014

BARÇIN YİNANÇ

“Alo Fatih…” could become a campaign motto for the opposition Nationalist Movement Party (MHP). Alo is the word we use when we pick up the phone. “Alo Fatih…” refers to a telephone conversation between Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Fatih Saraç, a high level official of Habertürk TV channel. Erdoğan calls Saraç from Morocco during the Gezi protests last June, requesting that he stops broadcasting MHP leader Devlet Bahçeli’s speech. In a second recording, Saraç phones a Habertürk TV editor and gives the necessary instructions. In a third one he calls Bilal Erdoğan, the prime minister’s son, offering his apologies adding, “I get really sad when my big brother [in reference to PM] gets sad.”

In one of his parliamentary addresses, Bahçeli made fun of this situation saying, “Alo Fatih, the MHP will come biiig in these elections.”

Really? Perhaps. There are speculations that the AKP is anxious about losing some of its conservative nationalist voters to the MHP. But whether or not voter behavior changes due to these scandals remains to be seen.

I’ll give you an example. My garage man, a person who is quite familiar with politics and a fervent supporter of the MHP, was unaware of “Alo Fatih.” So don’t be surprised if discussions about scandals unfolding each day remain limited to a relatively small group. Actually they are taking place among journalists.

The regular reader of the Daily News is probably aware of telephone recordings about some notorious businessmen complaining about being forced to contribute to a “pool,” an initiative for the unregistered funding of the pro-government media group Sabah-ATV. It seems that this is the fee that these businessmen, who are building contractors, have to pay in order to be awarded giant government tenders.

A columnist, who was a former press advisor to the PM, penned an article last week justifying all these scandalous situations. “Helping the Cemaat [the Fethullah Gülen movement] is philanthropy, donating to Turkish Olympics [the language competitions organized by the Cemaat] is sponsorship, making large contributions to [Gülen] schools is benevolence … Yet helping a foundation close to the government is bribery … joint purchase of a media outlet that supports the government is corruption,” he wrote, continuing as follows: “It is good to pursue construction licenses for Hizmet schools, but a sin to do so for a dorm of a foundation. It is legitimate to be encouraged for the financing of Cemaat media outlets but it is evil to be encouraged to enter the media business.”

This is a highly problematic line of thinking.

In the first instance, if the Cemaat has done something illegal, such as bribing an official to acquire construction license for its schools or illegally coercing businessmen to financially contribute to its activities, is it possible for this country’s citizens to condemn it. If the Cemaat is involved in illegal activities, then it is up to the state or government to reveal them and bring the Cemaat to justice.

But if the Cemaat uses, let’s say, “brotherhood pressure” to force business circles into generous donations while staying within the borders of legality, it is the problem of these businessmen, not the taxpayer’s problem.

In the case of the government, it is a whole different story. The huge construction projects such as the controversial third airport that are awarded to big businessmen will be conducted with this country’s taxpayers’ money. In other words, my money is being used as a carrot to “indirectly coerce” businessmen to be the owner of a media outlet that will publish for… the public good? Of course not, for the government’s good!

Turkey’s elites keep talking about this or that recording, but as I said above it might be misleading to think that this is what large crowds talk about every day, every hour. They have an idea of the large picture, but the majority is not familiar with the details of each unfolding scandal. We need to be aware of that.

Source: Hurriyet Daily , February 18, 2014


Related News

“They won’t believe,” he said

AHMET KURUCAN “They won’t believe,” he said. “They won’t believe that we work for peace and the salvation of humanity. They won’t believe that we endeavor to create an island of peace where all of humanity can live in brotherhood. They won’t believe that you do not have expectations for this world or the next. […]

Accused by Erdogan of plotting a coup, Hizmet movement fears for freedom in Turkey

The Hizmet is based on the idea of a “modern Islam compatible with democracy” that has been disseminated by Fethullah Gülen since the 1960’s. Gülen, now 75 years old, is a former imam, writer, thinker and teacher. He has been living in the US in volunteer exile since 1999, when he left Turkey due to successive military coups. Even from afar, Gülen keeps influencing thousands of Turks and Muslims around the world.

I came to Nigeria with just a piece of luggage –Turkish International Colleges foundation coordinator

When Behlul Basaran arrived Nigeria in 2000 from Turkey, he was armed with a single piece of luggage, an enthusiastic spirit and hope. Inside his luggage was his letter of scholarship for a university education from the Hizmet Movement, which had started building a relationship and foundation for quality education with Nigeria.

Turkish minister’s leaked emails show pro-gov’t figure has eye on Gülen-linked dormitory

Leaked emails of Turkey’s energy minister and son-in-law of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, Berat Albayrak, have revealed plans by a pro-government figure to assume ownership of a dormitory in Kayseri province that used to be operated by the Gülen movement but was closed down by the Justice and Development Party (AKP) government.

War on Gulen Movement undermines Turkish diplomacy

Bent on dismantling the “parallel state,” Ankara has embarked on a reckless campaign that threatens to undermine Turkey’s foreign relations. After corruption probes targeted Cabinet members in December 2013, it came as no surprise when the AKP government dismissed and reassigned thousands of police officers, prosecutors and judges in the course of a fierce war on the movement of cleric Fethullah Gulen.

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Arzu Nur Özkan, a former teacher, has been in Bünyan Prison in Kayseri province for the last four months for alleged links to the Gülen movement despite being six months pregnant. Özkan is experiencing complications related to her pregnancy and is frequently put in quarantine cells because of her hospital visits.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Turkey’s Erdogan vows to cut off revenues of Gulen-linked businesses

Gülen: Associating Hizmet with violent Kobani protests great slander

Turkish Gov’t Seizes 965 Gülen Movement Affiliated Firms With $11.3 Billion Worth

Water well for 10 thousand Pakistani with the money from cattle milk

South Africa to host 14th International Festival of Language and Culture

Kimse Yok Mu delegation visited the President of Somalia

Turkish American Society of Ohio Seeks to Foster Friendship and Understanding Between Cultures

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News