‘Gulen Movement is a civil society movement, rather than a religious one’

Prof. Hakan Yavuz
Prof. Hakan Yavuz


Date posted: April 24, 2013

University of Utah professor of political science Hakan Yavuz, Ph.D, gave a lecture followed by a conversation on his latest book “Toward an Islamic Enlightenment: The Gulen Movement“. At the lecture hosted by Rumi Forum Washington D.C., Yavuz argued that the Gulen Movement should not be considered a religious movement, rather, a civil society movement. He underscored that he offers a comprehensive study of the movement in his book and, further in his presentation, focused on the motive alongside message of the book and the aspects of the movement he considered worthy of mentioning.

Yavuz, who has had a particular focus on Islamic movements in Turkey throughout his academic career, dedicated the greater part of his thesis to this phenomena. In 1990s, he did extensive research and examined the evolution of the Gulen Movement. He said there have been a number of institutions conceptualizing the movement but he was not satisfied with their work. His motive, therefore, for authoring this book is his belief that the movement is misunderstood and to explain the behaviors of the movement members. “What made me write this book is, first, the misunderstanding of the movement both in Turkey and outside. Second, somewhat, the inability of the movement members to explain what they are doing. Because the movement is very much action-oriented movement” Yavuz said.

Highlighting the fact that he wrote the book with a scholarly approach as an outsider, Yavuz said “The Gulen Movement is one of the recent interpretations of Islam. I would say, most powerful and most successful one that tries to reconcile with modernity in general, democracy, human rights and market economy.” He referred to the movement’s interpretation as “New Islam”. And speaking of the defining characteristics of this new understanding, namely, ‘New Islam” Yavuz said, “In it, the piety is not for the sake of piety. It is for the sake of improving social, political and economic condition of your society. So, here piety becomes a motivating force not just fulfilling your religious duties”. Additionally, he underscored that he regards the movement as a civil society movement rather than a religious organism. He went on to say Islam in the conceptual map of Gulen is a civil philosophy, which suggests Gulen wants to integrate Muslims into public debate. “For Gulen to build a consensus shouldn’t be left to one or two religious scholars. Islam provides a shared code of language and it offers a general sense of good life” he said.

Speaking of the movement’s objective the professor said, “Everybody is asking what the movement’s purpose is. I don’t think it is religious. Based on my studies I can suggest that its main objective is character formation, which is one of the reasons why education is significant in the movement.” In addition, as his analysis of the movement terminology indicates, he said, action precedes preaching in the methodology of the movement. “Action, activities and building institutions become much more important than preaching religion” said Yavuz. As for what the concept “dialogue” refers to in the movement, he commented that Gulen and the movement, by bridging different cultures and societies, stress bridging more than bonding.

Yavuz further brought up the inner dimensions of Islam in Gulen’s understanding. Referring to Gulen’s account of his own childhood and religious background which was largely shaped by his mother and grandmother, Yavuz claimed that Gulen feminized the notion of Islam. “Gulen believes sentimental and emotional aspects of Islam are essential in terms of action and activity” which is instilled by mothers as Yavuz argued.

Noting that his book includes parts critical of the movement, Yavuz listed his criticisms as; disappointingly low women involvement despite being better that other movements with regard to women issues, failing to be as transparent as expected and its increasing interest in politics following Ergenekon case from 2007 onwards.

Source: [in Turkish] Star. English translation is retrieved from HizmetMovement.Com, April 19, 2013


Related News

Albanian lawmakers reject Erdoğan’s call to close Turkish schools

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s call for the closure of Turkish schools in Albania unleashed a swirl of debate in the Albanian political and media landscape, leading to intensified pressure on the government to clarify its position and Education Minister Lindita Nikolla saying that the government has already shut down a number of schools regarded as unfit according to criteria set in a recent education reform.

Food and fun abound at Turkish Festival

Alamo Plaza was alive with music and food, Saturday, for the annual Turkish Festival. The free event celebrated different aspects of the Turkish culture including folk dance, the performing arts and authentic cuisine. This year’s theme was San Antonio Goes Turkish.

Muslims, Jews break fast after Yom Kippur

Even before Mustafa Safak arrived at Temple Chai on Wednesday for closing Yom Kippur services, the San Antonio Muslim read up on the traditions associated with the Jewish holiday. Members of Temple Chai attended events this summer marking Ramadan, Islam’s holy month, celebrated June 5 to July 5 this year. “Now they’re reciprocating,” Safak said.

Carino: Interfaith Thanksgiving service a good reminder

The annual gathering of Christians, Jews and Muslims took on added poignancy in light of today’s polarized climate.

GYV President Mustafa Yeşil answers questions about the Gulen movement

March 26, 2013 Hizmet does not expect anything from the political authorities. Our only expectations are that the EU process must be kept alive and democratization must be achieved; that rights and freedoms are improved; that the ongoing fight against military tutelage is completed; and that the new constitution materializes. We do not even want […]

Imam in the Middle

Gulen is nothing if not prolific. He has written more than 60 books, most of which are available in English. It’s likely that an equal number of books have been written about Gulen or the movement he inspired. The man and the movement are subjects of myriad dissertations and scholarly treatises.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Laughter-guaranteed terrorist organization indictment

Winds of friendship were enjoyed in different parts of Turkey during the month of Muharram

New Book – The House of Service: The Gülen Movement and Islam’s Third Way (New York: Oxford University Press)

Turkey’s counter-terrorism campaign [against Hizmet] discredited

Major Says No One In Erdoğan Assassination Attempt Trial Has Links To Gülen

Gülen’s lawyer denies allegation of plot against Erdoğan’s daughter, calls it ’immoral slander’

Canada’s Turkish community on edge as government crackdown continues

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News