Erdoğan media’s accusations against Gülen and Hizmet

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: January 3, 2014

İHSAN YILMAZ

This piece is based on an academic paper that I published in 2007.

The accusations leveled against Fethullah Gülen and the Hizmet movement reminded me of this paper of mine. In a section of the paper, I compare accusations against Gülen and Mevlana Jalaluddin Rumi, a towering spiritual figure of the 13th century. The accusations are almost the same. While I discuss the neonationalist, ultraconservative, radical Islamist, Kemalist and ultraleftist accusations against Gülen in my paper, today, almost all of the same lies are now repeated almost verbatim by the TV channels and newspapers under the control of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

Gülen’s antagonists repeat accusations that the papacy has bought a community or movement in Turkey in a bid to produce an adulterated and altered Islam. They reacted negatively to Gülen’s visit to Vatican City to meet with the pope, which they consider a humiliation. They allege that “some groups” are the secret agents of the papacy in Turkey. They also repeatedly claim that some secret agreements between “a group,” the Papacy and the Orthodox Church have been reached to reopen the Halki Seminary, and, when the conditions are right, that Greeks (Rum) will immigrate to Turkey. They also strongly argue that the Muslims who advocate dialogue with Christians and Europeans are either naïve, ignorant or, far worse, traitors. They even imply that Gülen is not a Muslim at all but a secret cardinal of the Catholic Church. Some others claim that Gülen is a man of the Korea-based cult of Sun Myung Moon. An ultra-nationalist has argued that “CIA agents such as Graham Fuller and Paul Henze are disciples [murid] of Gülen.”

Similar to that of contemporary times, the social and political conjuncture was very turbulent when Rumi emerged on the scene. It was a period in which many conflicts and disorders were happening one after the other. The Seljuk state was significantly weakened and deteriorating, frozen by the inability to cope with internal conflicts, divisions and mismanagement. During this period Rumi emerged as a powerful activist and scholar. He not only talked about but also worked to create an atmosphere of dialogue and tolerance through his lyrics, poetry and, of course, followers. Through tolerance and compassion, he conveyed his message, which clarifies the relation of human beings to their Creator, and one’s relation to others and fellow beings. Dialogue, humanity, love, compassion and tolerance as well as respect for, openness to and acceptance of others in their otherness are the fundamentals of Rumi’s thought and practice. He also drew his listeners’ attention to the mother of all evils — ignorance — and underlined that education and dialogue are the only remedies. When he passed away in 1273, Muslims, Christians, Jews, Arabs, Persians, Turks and Romans honored him at his funeral, and men of five faiths followed his bier. The flood of people at the funeral was a sign that Rumi was well understood even in his lifetime, and that he was a sound foundation for different communities.

Rumi also practiced activism in his spiritual guidance to rulers, including the invading Mongols. He was part of the urban elite in the cosmopolitan capital city of Konya. Rumi gained much love and respect from sultans, viziers and kings. These men of high position were very eager to see him. However, Rumi seldom accepted their invitations. Rumi tried to narrow the gap between ulama Islam (scholarly Islam) and folk Islam. He was also involved in the political struggles of his time in one way or another. He was in contact with the rulers. Rumi was not a politician but a spiritual guide who was perfectly aware of the realities of the mundane world, an essential quality for an influential spiritual guide.

Even though he did not deal with everyday politics, he faced and is still facing political accusations, including the claim that he sought political power. Rumi’s respect for all religious traditions was not always popular in his day, and often provoked criticism from the more dogmatic. Rumi was accused of being too soft on the Mongols. While some criticized his openness to the other, others claimed that he was a traitor, a spy and not even a Muslim.

Source: Today's Zaman , January 3, 2014


Related News

Bank Asya’s corporate governance rating increases

Bank Asya, a leading Turkish financial institution, announced on Sunday that their corporate governance rating had increased in June over its score from last year.

To embrace the spirit of acceptance and tolerance

The world has judged the two attacks in Paris and Brussels, which claimed a number of lives and damaged property, as associated with Islamic-inspired terrorism. The attacks also delivered the psychological message that acts of terror and hatred can occur even in the most prosperous and highly secured countries that respect diversity and human rights. […]

Turkish-American community grapples with Turkey coup’s aftermath

Dr. Gokcek said he is not optimistic. He is fearful about the growing tensions in the country and coup sympathizers who might be stigmatized as traitors. On a basic level, Gokcek said, he has been able to sit down and eat with other Turkish-Americans with whom he might not always agree. “Some of those friends, I might not be able to now,” he said.

Gulen sees rise of ‘totalitarianism’ under Erdogan’s rule

Turkey’s leaders are taking the country on a path towards totalitarianism, US-based preacher and arch-enemy of President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Fethullah Gulen, wrote in an article published Tuesday.

The Famous Soccer Player Hiding in Plain Sight in a California Bakery

Most customers do not recognize the fit, well-dressed man walking around Tuts Bakery and Cafe, picking up used cups and dirty dishes. Why would they? And what would he be doing here? Hakan Sukur, 46, is one of Turkey’s most famous athletes, its most celebrated soccer player, a World Cup hero and a veteran of several of Europe’s top leagues. So how did Sukur end up here?

Kurdish paper Rudaw’s interview with Fethullah Gulen

The Gülen movement’s stance toward the Kurdish issue has become ever more questioned since the Turkish government’s recent targeting of the Hizmet movement. A close analysis, however, suggests a complex picture.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Int’l scholars discuss ijtihad, qiyas at İstanbul symposium

Atyrau student wins silver in Brazil research competition

Germany takes Gülenists off watch list, conducts counterespionage against Ankara – report

Academic freedom at universities under growing threat

Who are these pro-Erdogan mobs who even beheaded a soldier?

Donate your qurban, bring joy to families in need

Turkey’s accused – Tragic stories of the purged

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News