Pulitzer Prize equals five years in prison in Turkey

Emre Uslu
Emre Uslu


Date posted: December 14, 2013

EMRE USLU

The statement in the headline belongs to Bülent Arınç, deputy prime minister and spokesperson for the Turkish government. Moreover, he is responsible for the government’s media policy.

For Western readers, I should clarify that he was not joking when he said, “A journalist might win the Pulitzer Prize for his reporting, but he should face the consequence of five years in prison.”

The worst part is that Arınç is known for his tolerance of the media and journalism. I cannot imagine what Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan would demand if a journalist published confidential documents. Perhaps 10 years in prison?

For those who have not followed the debate, here is a summary. Journalist Mehmet Baransu of the liberal Taraf daily published a controversial document from a 2004 National Security Council (MGK) meeting which contained an action plan for the government against the religious movement inspired by Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen.

As a follow-up story, Taraf also published confidential documents showing that the government had actually enacted the MGK’s recommendations. For instance, after the MGK meeting, the government began to store the personal information of individuals connected to the Gülen movement. Taraf also published documents showing that the National Intelligence Organization (MİT) still keeps files on individuals based on which community they belong to, which faith group they are associated with and so on.

Immediately after the documents’ publication in Taraf, Erdoğan slammed the report, accusing those responsible of “treason.”

Following the prime minister’s accusation, prosecutors began investigating Baransu and Taraf. The Prime Ministry, MİT and the MGK also filed separate criminal complaints. Baransu now faces a total of 47 years in prison.

This case will be a litmus test for Turkish democracy, for two reasons. Yes, of course it is illegal to publish MGK documents in the press. However, the Constitution prohibits governments and the state bureaucracy from developing plans to destroy law-abiding civil society groups. The Constitution also prohibits the government from keeping files of personal data on lawful groups or Turkish citizens.

The Taraf documents clearly show that the government undersigned a document advising criminal action against a civilian group. Because the Constitution prohibits the Turkish government from preparing or conducting such activities, the documents published by Taraf should be considered evidence of a crime committed by the government. Thus, their publication is not illegal. What is illegal, however, is the government’s signing such a document against the Gülen movement.

Moreover, in terms of journalism’s democratic standards, there should be no restrictions on the documents that can be published. And journalists should test the limits of what is publishable. The American and European media showed great examples of this in the WikiLeaks case, the Abu Ghraib prison case in Iraq and the latest National Security Agency (NSA) wiretapping scandals.

The Turkish government, of course, knows all these examples. It was this government that improved the standards of Turkish democracy. But since 2007, unfortunately, Turkey is returning to its old position in which democratic rules are not in effect.

Arınç’s unfortunate statement is just one sign of the direction in which Turkey is heading. This is what he said: “Leaking the story may be described as ‘successful journalism’ by some, but this does not mean it is not a crime. It is a crime to publish confidential documents from the MGK. The title ‘journalist’ does not give one the privilege of exemption from what’s written in the law. Someone who makes himself or herself a candidate for the Pulitzer Prize for successful journalism should understand that they could face five years in prison because of the law and should do the job accordingly with courage. Nobody has the right to complain,” said Arınç in a speech in Parliament.

“If you say: ‘I did it by choice. I am aware of the consequences. This is journalism,’ you have to stand and face the consequences of the law. If you say, ‘I have done this for my country, and I will face all charges,’ then you will do such things,” Arınç added.

At the end of his remarks, Arınç said: “I am not threatening the journalist. I am just saying what is written in the law. They will not be afraid of my threats. I am a lawyer.”

If this is not a threat, then what is? Western democracies and the European Union should pay attention to this poisonous mentality against the free press in Turkey and do whatever they can to accept Turkey into the EU. Otherwise Turkish citizens will have to pay the price for “Turkish-style democracy.”

Source: Today's Zaman , December 14, 2013


Related News

Columnist sees Gülen ‘conspiracy’ in ruling against Israel

Presenting the Gülen movement as the architect of the court ruling may help the government deal with a possible backlash from families, the İHH — an outspoken supporter of the government’s Middle East policies — and a wider segment of its own voters who want Israeli officials to pay for the Mavi Marmara raid, in case a reconciliation deal with Israel goes into effect. Internationally, it may help the government deal with Israeli and Western criticism that it is not committed to reconciliation with Israel despite officially vowing that it is.

Gülen offers condolences for police officer, resident

Gülen said in a statement on Friday that Turkey’s “atmosphere is being spoiled with rancor and hatred” and that the country needs a nationwide return to common sense and security above all else.

The Hizmet movement and politics

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz, 28 March 2012, Wednesday There has recently been criticism directed against the Hizmet movement that it has been or is becoming a political movement. Its adversaries keep making these accusations, and nothing can be done to convince them. But for anyone sincerely interested in what the movement is actually up to, some […]

Fethullah Gülen lost his friend Prof. Toktamış Ateş, an academic, writer, and eminent democrat

HizmetNews.COM January 20, 2013 Turkish Professor Toktamış Ateş, also a columnist with the Bugün daily, passed away on Saturday January 19, 2013. Fethullah Gülen expressed his condolences in a statement he released the same day, describing Prof. Ateş an exemplary democrat in academia and media. Fethullah Gülen: I am deeply saddened to learn about the […]

Turkish daily Taraf accused of ‘spying’ and ‘terror acts’ for publishing state document

Daily Taraf, which published a document from a 2004 National Security Council (MGK) meeting about a state action plan against the activities of Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen’s movement, has been charged with “spying” and “terrorism,” in an investigation launched by the Istanbul Public Prosecutor.

Let Mr. Erdogan Fight His Own Battles

Mr. Erdogan is trying to drag the United States into the argument by threatening to demand Mr. Gulen’s extradition to Turkey. Some experts say there is no legal basis for an extradition request because there are no charges or legal cases against Mr. Gulen, who has permanent-resident status and has lived in rural Pennsylvania since 1997.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

International Workshop – Hizmet Movement between Political Islam and Civil Islam

Romanian Minister of Education gives Turkish Schools Teachers a Standing Ovation

Turkish school in Romania moves to new building

Terrorists not true Muslims, says scholar

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Nearly 2,500 turn up for International Language and Culture Festival in Thailand

Father jailed over Gülen links, 6-months-old paralyzed baby left in intensive care

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News