Rule of law(lessness) in Turkey?

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (Photo: Today's Zaman, Mustafa Kirazlı)
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (Photo: Today's Zaman, Mustafa Kirazlı)


Date posted: November 21, 2013

M. EDİB YILMAZ

Ever since a draft law about shutting private prep schools was leaked to the press, I was somehow hoping that this idea had not originated with Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan himself but from one of his close aides, or perhaps a few of them.

It turned out that I was overly optimistic, for I did not want to believe that a prime minister who bravely fought the old, authoritarian establishment in the people’s name for years could have changed so much, adopting just the same behavior we were subjected to in the past. I had thought that those bitter experiences were only a distant memory. Unfortunately, I was wrong — terribly so.

On the night of Nov. 20, Erdoğan, speaking on a TV program, proved that he will not hesitate to undermine the rule of law he helped strengthen in the first seven years of his government. Despite the fact that such a significant change in education policy will negatively affect students and their families, both socially and economically, and the fact that it runs entirely against the fundamental freedom of enterprise, he demonstrated with strongly-worded statements that he will not yield to the demands of the people.

If we have enough time in this world, we will witness what his attitude, which alienates large communities of people, will bring to him and his Justice and Development Party (AK Party). My guess, in the most diplomatic words, is that he will wish he had continued to listen to the people as he had in previous years.

Fighting reason and friendly advice

According to his words of Nov. 20, thousands of private prep schools providing supplementary educational support will be forced to end business next year, if the draft law is maintained, and will be transformed, if possible, into private schools that follow the national education curriculum. The idea, said Erdoğan, is to allow everyone access to quality education without additional expense. I admit that his rhetoric sounds good, but from the outset I see a number of flaws in this plan.

These prep schools are operating in a free-market economy and have emerged from a need and demand from the people. In a country where 1.5 million students take a centralized exam each year to enter a decent university/faculty but only a tenth — at most — are able to do so, the competition for educational success is a reality. You simply cannot defeat this just by thinking otherwise. There must be a coherent education policy and huge investments in place.

Aside from a qualitative upgrade, there is an obvious need for quantitative development, that is — in the simplest possible terms — a greater number of universities. In the absence of at least 10 times more fully equipped, sufficiently staffed universities than it currently has, Turkey will continue as a country in which students race each other for precious places in the existing faculties. And as long as there is competition, there will be a need for private tuition. This is exactly what those prep schools supply at the end of the day: It is supply and demand, as simple as that.

That being said, let us imagine that the government somehow goes ahead with its plan to close the prep schools. Families will then start looking elsewhere for more educational support, because they have to. One-on-one private tuition seems to be a good option for them. But it is expensive: much more expensive than a prep school. A simple calculation shows that, on average, families will have to pay at least three times more for private tutoring than they now pay for education at prep schools. I don’t know about you, but this plan seems entirely counterproductive.

Therefore, I believe that this fight against common sense and all the friendly advice many intellectuals have offered is bound to fail. It is not going to work, because the proposal does not make any sense and it is against the law.

An open challenge to the government

However, pro-government media circles believe otherwise. They say that when the government runs to the people’s aid with the free-of-charge Community Education Centers (Halk Eğitim Merkezleri, as they are called in Turkish), people will have the necessary support for their children’s education needs. They don’t seem to understand the meaning of the words “more” or “better,” but I have an idea, a democratic one, unlike the prime minister’s idea, to put their argument to the test.

I propose that the government should go ahead and establish those free centers, thousands of them, everywhere in the country and allow them to compete with the existing prep schools that are charging students for their classes. If the people choose to send their kids to those centers instead of the prep schools, then there is no problem. A simple supply-and-demand mechanism will have worked and the government will have removed the prep schools. Furthermore, the rule of law in this country will not have received yet another blow.

But if people still prefer those private institutions, and I believe an overwhelming majority of them will, then those in power must be just another group of condescending statists enforcing their ambiguous agenda on the people. I expect to hear the government’s response.

Source: Today's Zaman , November 21, 2013


Related News

Will Gülen movement become a political party?

Esteemed Fethullah Gülen frequently underlines: “Forget getting a share of political power. We cannot accept control of the world even if it is presented to us on a gold tray because this would create disappointment among those actively supporting our cause. And people would think ‘They’ve also been deceived by the love of position and sense of interest. All these [voluntary] efforts were for the sake of getting a share in the political power’.”

Çağlayan: TUSKON Trade Bridge soon to be global brand

Economy Minister Zafer Çağlayan said Tuesday that the Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists’ (TUSKON) Turkey-World Trade Bridge summit, which opened its doors to visitors from around the world on Wednesday, is on its way to becoming a global brand as it gets better every year. Çağlayan said the event has been attracting larger crowds […]

RTÜK suspends 20 SHaber TV shows, harshest penalty of all times

Radio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK) has suspended 20 TV shows of the Samanyolu Haber TV news channel, its Editor in Chief Metin Yıkar announced via his Twitter account on Saturday. The RTÜK penalty came days after Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan vowed to finish off the Hizmet Movement and its affiliates, including the Samanyolu Haber TV.

Romania hosts 12th International Language and Culture Festival finals

The final leg of the 12th International Language and Culture Festival will be held in the Romanian capital of Bucharest on June 15-16. The event, formerly called the Turkish Olympiads, is organized by the International Turkish Association (TÜRKÇEDER).

Dismissed top editor of Zaman: We made a mistake by not objecting to the imprisonment of journalists

Journalist Abdulhamit Bilici, who was dismissed as editor-in-chief of Zaman said the Zaman daily should have kept its distance from the ruling AKP. He also said his media group made a mistake by not objecting to the imprisonment of journalists in the late 2000s.

Lambsdorff: Turkish press intimidated, under pressure

A senior member of the European Parliament (EP), German Liberal Alexander Graf Lambsdorff, said the Turkish press is intimidated and under pressure, and also strongly criticized the new Internet law.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

In controversial move Parliament votes to shut down prep schools

Turkish “religious advisors” are keeping an eye on Erdogan opponents in Belgium

Turks Fleeing Persecution Find Haven in South Africa

Financial Times: Turkey’s crackdown on dissent has gone too far

Fethullah Gulen’s Message on the 9/11 Terrorist Attacks

Toward a constitutional crisis [in Turkey]

Two volunteers of Gülen Movement reportedly abducted after released by Azerbaijani Court

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News