‘Inception,’ the Gülen community and the PKK

Kurtuluş Tayiz
Kurtuluş Tayiz


Date posted: November 18, 2011

Kurtuluş Tayiz

I have been following anti-Fethullah Gülen broadcasts in the Kurdish media for some time now. Television stations, newspapers and Internet sites known for their closeness to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) have incessantly been spreading hostility amongst its readers against Gülen.

It wouldn’t be so difficult to understand if most of these publications remained within the acceptable limits of criticism (regardless of how harsh or how much that criticism might be). But the PKK has virtually put the Kurdish question aside to wage a war on the Gülen community. The PKK leaders have declared the Gülen community the “biggest enemy of the Kurdish people.” Individuals and organizations said to be close to the community have been included on the PKK’s list of targets.

In an interview PKK leader Murat Karayılan gave to the Fırat news agency about the Gülen community on Nov. 5 it is interesting to see the extent of this phenomenon. Karayılan claimed that he had a file on Fethullah Gülen and wanted to share these documents with television stations and newspapers in Turkey. The name of the file is the “Green Ergenekon.” The PKK has never felt the need to form or share any files to date about the real Ergenekon (the one that is responsible for thousands of unsolved murders perpetrated in the ‘90s, for disappearances in custody and villages that were forcefully evacuated) until today. To the contrary, it has had to “distance” itself from the probe into Ergenekon because Kandil [the PKK headquarters in northern Iraq] is “antagonistic” to the investigation. The enmity toward Gülen in the Kurdish media reminds me of Feb. 28, [1997, the date of an unarmed military intervention that forced the government to resign at the time] media and the Turkey of the ‘90s. Videos featuring Gülen that were obtained by intelligence units were always the top story every evening on news stations. The PKK is acting as though it has taken on the anti-Gülenism of the former owners of the state or the military bureaucracy. The jargon they use is familiar, highly reminiscent of the language used by the Feb. 28 media, Odatv broadcasts and the Workers’ Party (İP). In fact they virtually use the exact same words and concepts on this issue. Of course, what I am really curious about is the evolution of the hostility against Gülen from its roots in the deep state and the status quo to the Kurdish movement. I believe that this extent of anti-Gülenism has been brought to the Kurdish movement from outside. I have followed the Kurdish issue for years, but I am clueless as to how the Gülen movement could suddenly have become the arch enemy of the PKK. It is possible that the Kurdish movement and the Gülen movement will come face to face during the Kurdish movement’s process of becoming politicized and becoming more active in the cities. But it can’t be the factor that has pushed the Kurdish question into the background.

This brings to mind Christopher Nolan’s “Inception,” starring Leonardo DiCaprio. It is the story about a thief and a spy who infiltrates people’s dreams and steals their deepest secrets, and how this intertwines with the spy’s own life. This is not the whole story and the best part comes later: The concept of creation or inception, of an idea instead of stealing an idea. The thief and his team invade the dream of a young heir to a company that is the rival of their client and implant the idea of a classical father and son conflict. This way, the young heir is convinced, will eliminate his father’s company for his “freedom.” The hostility in the Kurdish movement towards Gülen and his community is reminiscent of such an inception that follows the “planting of an idea.” Once you plant the seed of an idea, it is inevitable it will grow and sprout, especially when the ground is this fertile and suitable.

If I may say so, hostility toward Gülen began to change hands with the start of the Ergenekon investigation. The deep state, the status quo and the right wing and left wing structures that are the extensions of these (the deep state and the status quo), gangs or pro-coup groups have for the past five years been creating enmity against Gülen continuously among the Kurdish movement. The Kurdish front has been influenced by this to such an extent that it is now really hostile toward the Gülen community. Small-scale research can show that most of the anti-Gülen news items in the Kurdish media can be traced back to the aforementioned entities.

Broadcasts by the PKK’s European media outlets are the most noteworthy. It is virtually an exact replica of the Feb. 28 media. These broadcasts create the impression that there is a group within the PKK that especially fans enmity against Gülen.

Let’s finish this in a way Kurdish politicians like to hear: “Leave the Kurds to the Kurds.” Yes, maybe you are right, but I cannot help but remind you of this: Your hostility against Gülen in reality isn’t yours, but someone else’s.

*Kurtuluş Tayiz is a columnist for Taraf. This article was first published in Taraf on Nov. 18, 2011. kurtulustayiz@gmail.com

Source: Today’s Zaman, 18 November 2011, Friday, http://www.todayszaman.com/news-263274-inception-the-gulen-community-and-the-pkk-by-kurtulus-tayiz*.html


Related News

Minister: Turkish gov’t racks up $5 bln in confiscation of Gülen-linked properties

The value of immovable properties including dormitories, real estates and schools that the government has confiscated as part of its clampdown against Gülen movement so far, totals around TL 15 billion or $4.9 billion, according to Environment and Urban Planning Minister Mehmet Özhaseki.

81-year-old man sentenced to 10 years in jail over Gulen link

Mustafa Türk, an 81-year-old Turkish who has been under arrest over a year, was sentenced to 10 years in jail on charges of membership to a terrorist organization.

Gülen’s lawyer dismisses wiretapping claims

In his statement, Gülen’s lawyer Albayrak said the allegations which appeared in some newspapers is totally baseless and targets Gülen in an unfair way and demands punishment for the individuals who were involved such accusations

Erdoğan’s war against Hizmet: Step by step

Turkish prosecutors carried out a number of arrests and raids on the morning of 17th December 2013 as part of a series of on-going corruption investigations. PM Erdogan’s response has been to call this a coup attempt against his government orchestrated by a coalition of foreign and domestic enemies. Erdogan claims that the ‘domestic pawn’ of this plot is the Hizmet movement. His number one election campaign promise: to crush and annihilate the treacherous Hizmet movement.

Sakarya court orders stay of execution on closure of Fatih Koleji

The Sakarya Administrative Court on Friday issued a stay of execution on the closure decision for Fatih Koleji, a Hizmet-affiliated school that has been running in the Beyköy district of Düzce province, saying that the school is allowed to continue to operate in the 2014-2015 education period.

Turkey’s political weather forecast

A statement from the Higher Board of Judges and Prosecutors (HSYK) said a decree from Prime Minister Tayyip Erdoğan’s Justice and Development Party (AKParti) government was against the Turkish Constitution. The Board was mentioning the government’s Dec. 21 decree, asking prosecutors to inform local administrative authorities about their investigations, which was supposed to be confidential

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Fethullah Gülen’s message to the International symposium “Ijtihad and Qiyas: The richness of Islam”

Liberia: Turkish School to Remain Open

TUSKON to gather 2,000 businessmen from all over world in İstanbul

Failed coup in Turkey hits Albany’s Turkish Cultural Center

Erdoğan’s war against Hizmet: Step by step

Pro-Erdoğan journalist: Gülen followers should be kept in detention camps, given food tickets

Turks in America condemn unlawful government action during the corruption probe

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News