Irrationality rules


Date posted: December 28, 2013

JOOST LAGENDIJK

It is almost impossible to keep up with the hallucinatory speed of all the twists and turns in the corruption scandal that has dominated the agenda in Turkey for 10 days now.

As I’m aware of the fact that this article will only be published two days after its writing, I will try to keep some distance from the avalanche of breaking news that is constantly and mercilessly sweeping down on everybody at home and abroad who is trying to make sense of what is happening in Turkey these days.

Having been in the Netherlands for Christmas, my observations are based on, among other things, the many questions I got from journalists and others interested in the dazzling developments in Turkey. Many of them, and this also applies to other Europeans, don’t know the details of the corruption allegations and most have, for instance, no clue what the Gülen movement is and how it relates to the Justice and Development Party (AKP). What they do know is how the Dutch government would — or according to them should — react if a similar crisis arose in the Netherlands. Their curiosity and, often, concern about the current state of affairs in Turkey is therefore based on the yawning gap between the way a comparable emergency would be handled in the Netherlands and the way the present sequence of events is being handled in Turkey.

Allegations of corruption or other financial wrongdoing are nothing new in politics. They pose a big challenge to every government that faces them and there is no standard method to limit the damage. Most of the time, ministers under suspicion are forced to resign, not because they are guilty but because they can’t function when under investigation. For that reason, the fact that Erdoğan assembled a new team of ministers last week was considered a normal, albeit belated, reaction to the allegations. This change of personnel’s potential to change the mood for the better was, however, fatally undermined by two other countermeasures of the ruling party: the witch-hunt for the police chiefs and prosecutors responsible for starting the investigations and the accusations leveled at so-called foreign and domestic “dark forces.”

Nobody outside of Turkey understands why a government that claims to be innocent and portrays itself as the victim of dirty conspiracies uses every legal — and according to many illegal — means at its disposal to stop further investigations and punish those who gathered the evidence or wrote the indictments. Instead of allowing the judiciary and the police to perform their duties and preparing a plausible reply, the Turkish government has been actively violating the separation of powers between the executive and the judiciary. That course of action has not only alarmed many in Turkey but has also led to strong reactions in the rest of Europe. It suggests that, apparently, the prosecutors have a point and can only be stopped by setting in motion a dramatic clash in the judiciary that is gravely harming Turkey’s efforts to become a state based on the rule of law.

What definitively put off most non-Turks were the repeated invocations of an “international plot” originating in the US or Israel, supported by collaborators within the country, aimed at stopping Turkey’s rise to global prominence. It seems the prime minister and his loyal entourage have come to the conclusion that blaming all kinds of obscure lobbies went down quite well after the start of the Gezi Park protests. So why not repeat this classic line of defense? My guess is that this time around the amount of incriminating evidence is so overwhelming that even those AKP voters who were willing to buy the prime minister’s arguments in June are now unconvinced.

I’m afraid it remains difficult for many Erdoğan supporters to understand how damaging these kinds of conspiracy theories are for Turkey’s image abroad. The overriding impression that many in the Netherlands and elsewhere get when listening to these kinds of wild and irrational theories is that at the moment Turkey is ruled by a government driven by anger and a desire for revenge, a government unwilling to play by the book and unable to reflect on its own mistakes.

Source: Today's Zaman , December 28, 2013


Related News

Türksat removes Zaman, 3 others from ad list

Türksat withdrew its ads from three other dailies as well: Bugün, Taraf and Radikal, all of which have published articles that criticized the government’s efforts to cover up an ongoing investigation into alleged corruption claims.

New Book – No Return from Democracy: A Survey of Interviews with Fethullah Gulen

It was rare, if not impossible, to find in ’80s and ’90s a Muslim cleric who spoke in favor of democracy, integration with the Western world, and universal human values. Fethullah Gülen was one of those. This book collates Gülen’s ahead-of-his-time comments on some of the debated issues as he phrased in interviews in the past few decades.

Kimse Yok Mu to provide meals to over 1 mln in Ramadan

The Kimse Yok Mu charity will hand out 288,300 food packages to people in need as well as host iftars (dinners to break the daily fast) serving 1,168,000 people throughout Turkey and 103 other countries during the holy month of Ramadan. The month of Ramadan, commonly known in Turkey as the sultan of all the […]

Inside the eye of Turkey’s political storm, in rural Pennsylvania

A moderate preacher rooted in the Sufi mystic tradition of Islam, Mr. Gulen is known for emphasizing interfaith dialogue. But Mr. Erdogan calls Mr. Gulen and his followers a “cancer” and a “terrorist organization” that is building a “parallel state.” The rancour is personal.

Erdogan’s Faux Coup may have been Turkey’s Reichstag Fire

Michael Rubin of the American Enterprise Institute just gave us a pat on the back confirming our original assessment of July 2016 that Erdogan had staged the July 2016 coup. Several career Turkish military officers make a persuasive case that Erdogan’s narrative is false and that the coup was essentially Turkey’s equivalent of the Reichstag fire.

Tape politics

Someone placed a bugging device to wiretap the prime minister in a room that was being placed under constant surveillance. What is easier than catching the perpetrators behind this? Who entered and left the room should have been recorded. This incident took place in 2011 but as of now, this still remains unresolved and the Hizmet movement is being blamed for it.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

EU lends support to mosque-cemevi project

Erdogan’s Turkey silencing dissent, abusing terrorism charges – HRW report

AK Party İstanbul head: Purge in state institutions began long before

One blow after another at anti-Hizmet docu’s premier

Erdogan’s corruption defense falls flat

School Children, Not Tools Of War: A Nigerian’s opinion on Gulen, Hizmet and Erdogan

African firms signal increased trade at TUSKON meeting

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News