Unproven speculations and legitimate questions

Date posted: April 14, 2013

Joost Lagendijk*

Last week I was able to witness through first-hand experience how difficult it is to explain the Gulen movement outside of Turkey and how easy it is to manipulate public opinion on this issue.

It seems the launch of Zaman Vandaag (Today’s Zaman) in the Netherlands last Tuesday triggered several critics to present their opposition to the paper and, more generally, to the movement it is affiliated with. Let me start with a positive point: Zaman Vandaag is a weekly in Dutch about things happening in the Netherlands and Flanders, the Dutch-speaking part of Belgium. As Mete Öztürk, the editor-in-chief, formulated it, the paper is an indication of the fact that Turks and other migrants who came to Europe 50 years ago as temporary guest workers are there to stay. Zaman Vandaag wants to stimulate its readers to participate in Dutch and Belgian society and aims at fighting stereotypes and prejudices. The paper wants to present a perspective that is often missing in other media, it wants to publish the unknown stories of new and old Europeans living side by side in today’s multicultural societies and it wishes to focus on positive developments that are in danger of remaining unnoticed. As I said at the presentation of the first copy, I sincerely hope the paper manages to reach out to a mixed audience of Dutch and Belgians with different roots through nuanced reports and comments that don’t shy away from the controversies and disputes that are part and parcel of culturally and religiously mixed societies.

Unfortunately, a shadow was cast over the launch of Zaman Vandaag by two incidents. A few days before the paper was presented, a well-known and respected TV program came up with a story about boarding schools in the Netherlands run by Gulen sympathizers. Questions were raised about the functioning of the schools and whether or not these 100 percent Turkish facilities were stimulating the integration of the students into Dutch society — legitimate questions that should be answered. The problem was that they were put in the framework of a one-sided presentation of the Gulen movement as a shady and controversial phenomenon. There were no clear or substantiated accusations, but the feeling you got after watching the program was one of suspicion about the goals of a powerful organization totally unfamiliar to most Dutch. It was the reason why the minister of social affairs who had promised to speak at the launch of the new paper declined at the very last moment. The program also started a new round of debate in the media on the Gulen movement in which some outspoken critics have a relatively easy task: They can come up with wild and trumped-up charges because hardly anybody in the Netherlands knows something about it, and the few that do are incapable of presenting a convincing counter story.

The day of the launch a second incident happened. One of the main newspapers published a big article claiming that the row over Yunus, the foster child of Turkish origin raised by a lesbian couple in the Netherlands, was started by Zaman and other Gulen-related institutions. The story looked weak from the start because it contained several mistakes and tried to connect all actors in this case to the Gulen movement, including a meeting organized by the Directorate of Religious Affairs and a series of programs broadcast by ATV, both without the presumed Gulen links.

Still, the article fueled the already-ongoing debate about the Gulen movement, strengthening the impression among many Dutch that something is fundamentally wrong with this unknown entity. Being on the defensive, many Turks who sympathize with the movement react angrily but make the mistake of lumping all the criticism together. That does not help because there is a huge difference between, on the one hand, biased conspiracy theorists who blame everything they don’t like on the Gulen movement and, on the other, those who, for whatever reason, are simply concerned about certain practices in schools or dormitories linked to the movement. The first should be confronted with the inconsistencies in their unproven speculations. The latter, however, deserves an honest answer based on full transparency.

SourceTodaysZaman, 14 April, 2013

Tags: Defamation of the Gulen movement, media, Europe

Joost Lagendijk (born 8 June 1957 in Roosendaal, Netherlands) served as the joint chairman of the Turkey-EU Parliamentarians delegation and now is a Senior Advisor at the Istanbul Policy Center of Sabancı University, Turkey. He is a former Green Left Member of the European Parliament (MEP). More about him…


Related News

Islamic scholar Gülen says Turkey’s graft scandal can’t be covered up

Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has said a recent graft scandal that has rocked Turkey for nearly five weeks cannot be covered up despite massive efforts by the authorities to weather it down and crush those who speak out on the matter.

Report claims government categorized schools linked to Hizmet

The Turkish government classified, categorized and monitored a number of educational institutions in some way linked to Hizmet, a faith-based movement inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, until 2010, a Turkish daily reported on Sunday. “After statements confirmed the document, not only did I feel shattered, I am left speechless,” Gülen said.

Lawyer of raided schools: Terror groups do not open schools, they raid them

The lawyer representing a number of schools that were raided in a government-initiated operation in Bilecik province on Saturday and Sunday based on their supposed affiliation with an alleged terrorist organization has said terrorist organizations do not open schools but instead raid them.

How It Feels to Be a Dissident in Turkey After the Failed Military Coup

LOUISE CALLAGHAN To plan a speedy political exile from Turkey today, you need two things: a world map and the Wikipedia page on “visa entry requirements for Turkish citizens.” If you get out a highlighter and start cross-referencing the two, you’ll quickly see the bottom half of the map is more accessible than the top. […]

Kosovo detains Gülen-linked teacher at Turkey’s request

A Turkish teacher named Uğur Toksoy was detained by Kosovo authorities just following a visit by Ankara Chief Prosecutor Yüksel Kocaman, over his alleged links to the Gülen movement on Friday.

Is Anybody Out There?

In Turkey today, relief organization Kimse Yokmu, affiliated with the Fethullah Gulen inspired Hizmet movement has become the target of repeated attacks by Turkey’s political neo-tyrants, the most prominent of whom is President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.

Latest News

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

Grondahl: Turkish community strong in wake of threats from back home

Turkish-Kyrgyz educator’s abduction shows Ankara’s ruthless disregard for law: HRW

Kenya: Investigate Deportation of Turkish National

In Case You Missed It

Securitizing the Hizmet / Gulen movement

Draft law on prep schools

Division at home, cooperation abroad

The First Private Kurdish TV Channel in Turkey

Academics, civil society call for freer, more diverse universities in new law

Gülen calls for peaceful coexistence, warns about deceit and oppression

German view of Hizmet Movement (1)

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News