The real issue is the National Security Council [in Turkey]

CAFER SOLGUN
CAFER SOLGUN


Date posted: December 10, 2013

CAFER SOLGUN

Today, I was going to write about “knowing yourself,” to continue where I left off in my last column. However, it seems that it’s no use to talk in philosophical language. We are living in a time when we need to express our opinions more precisely. At least a note should be left in history’s records.

A recent report by the Taraf daily indicating that the National Security Council (MGK) had formed a plan to destroy the Gülen movement has sparked discussions. This is only natural, considering that the current political administration is known for its adherence to religious values. This report is huge news because the government failed to oppose the military in the MGK meeting.

Government spokespeople, as well as columnists and writers who feel they have to defend the government and Erdoğan no matter what they do, immediately adopted a defensive stance. And they argued that the plan devised at the council meeting was never implemented. This could have been a reasonable argument or pretext if combined with the admission that they just weren’t very competent back then. What would make this excuse even more acceptable would be a sincere, public confession by the ruling party.

But they did not do this, because Taraf daily went on to prove that the plan has actually been implemented and that under this plan, people have been profiled. In addition, the prime minister, who apparently doesn’t like defensive statements or formal apologies, took action and filed a criminal complaint against the Taraf daily, accusing it of espionage and revealing state secrets. What’s more, the prime minister also called Taraf a traitor in public rallies. He also argued that a campaign was being waged against his party and said that if he revealed certain things about those behind the campaign, the earth would move.

This showed that we actually have another criterion for state secrets: If a document favors the government, then it is good, and media is free to report on it. But if not, then it is bad, and revealing it is considered treason.

These reports also proved that the MGK maintains significant influence over the legitimately elected government and Parliament. I think that the most important factors in the ongoing debate are the attempts to keep this council out of the discussion, instead of investigating its mission and activities. I do not think that the issue is limited to the drafting of plans to eliminate the Gülen movement. For instance, in the MGK meetings, what was said about the fundamental issues of democratization in our country, and what decisions were made in respect to these issues? Facing up to the decisions and minutes of the MGK meetings has become a prerequisite for the normalization for our democracy, which is a regime of openness and transparency. This discussion has taught us this once again.

I believe that the attempts to divert attention by raising accusations of treason have to do with other dimensions of this issue, and those dimensions are more important than we think.

Nobody has been able to achieve anything positive by making reference to blackmail and imposition so far. I am not sure whether or not Erdoğan and his advisers are aware of this, but the prime minister’s methods of dealing with critical national issues were in the past likened to those of Turgut Özal; however, now they are comparing his style to that of Tansu Çiller.

Somebody should remind Erdoğan, who says that his explanations would move the earth, that nothing would happen. And if you make a statement, then you have to be consistent and do whatever you promised to do or you will march toward the abyss waiting to receive you.

A Latin saying best explains this: “Abyssus abyssum invocate” (deep calleth unto deep, or one misstep leads to another). This suggests that if you do not learn lessons from your errors, then it becomes inevitable that you make more mistakes.

Source: Today's Zaman , December 10, 2013


Related News

Gülen’s attorney: Media speculation about extradition not true

The lawyer of Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen said in a statement on Monday that the speculation in the media regarding the extradition of his client is far from the truth and that the extradition request itself is unlawful.

Enes Kanter: “I’m getting death threats almost every day”

Appearing on “CBS This Morning” Monday, Kanter said the trouble began while he was in Indonesia: “I was sleeping around 2:30 or something and my manager knocked on my door. He said the Secret Service and the Indonesian army were looking for me because the Turkish government told them I was a dangerous man.

The Coup Attempt – Turkey’s Reichstag Fire

Once forces loyal to Turkish President Erdogan had put the attempted takeover down, he called the coup attempt “a gift from God” because it provided an excuse to crack down on competitors and opponents. Using enemies lists prepared well in advance, his purges have touched more than 100,000 and sparked widespread conspiracies among Turks that the July 15 coup was Turkey’s equivalent of the Reichstag fire.

The Hizmet Movement: Reflections from Sri Lanka

In Sri Lanka, the Hizmet Movement started the Learnium School as well as the Intercultural Dialogue Foundation. Initially, the funding for the school came from the Movement until it managed to support itself on its own income. Kimse Yok Mu was among the first to respond to the devastating tsunami that hit Sri Lanka. Large amounts of food and other requirements that the tsunami victims needed were supplied without any fanfare.

Police wait at hospital to detain cancer patient

An anonymous Twitter account aiming to share human rights violations in Turkey announced on Saturday that police in Ankara were waiting at a hospital to detain a woman who is undergoing chemotherapy.

Fethullah Gülen’s response to the ‘clash of civilizations’ thesis

RICHARD PENASKOVIC* If Mr. Huntington is a protagonist for Western civilization, then Mr. Gülen is his counterpart, serving as a spokesperson or champion for moderate Islam. The differences between them are like night and day. Mr. Gülen argues that by creating new enemy fronts, Huntington actually sows the seeds for a clash of civilizations on […]

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Russian expert: Kimse Yok Mu is in no way a terrorist organization

78 detained for raising money for post-coup purge victims

The witch-hunt reaches Turkey’s media

Libyan minister would like to see Turkish teachers, schools in his country

An Armenian from Turkey in Los Angeles (2)

Media’s test with politics: this is utterly disgraceful

Erdoğan gov’t signals change to allow re-trial of officers

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News