AK Party vs. Cemaat?

Ali Ünal
Ali Ünal


Date posted: December 3, 2013

Ali Ünal

Of the many seemingly true claims that have been put forward in regards to the discussions that have come about surrounding the Turkish government’s attempt to close down exam prep-courses, some arguments bear good intentions while others call the Hizmet Movement to “keep quiet” with arguments that lie far from the truth.

One such case is presenting the issue as though it were a fight between the AK Party and the “Cemaat”. Whereas, 25% of existing exam prep-courses are seen as belonging to the Hizmet Movement, a total of 75% of the courses are against this closure. Just as the majority of these courses approach the issue in terms of education and serving the people, the Hizmet Movement, too, is acting as an advocate for the existence of exam prep-courses because they view them as not a source of personal profit but rather as something quite significant for the today and tomorrow of the nation, of generations to come and of humanity as a whole. The Hizmet Movement will continue to grow and prosper even without these courses; furthermore, an understanding that views the act of having expectations pertaining to the Hereafter in return for their services as anti-sincere, let alone any worldly expectations, an understanding that is based on the principles of: “I am ready to burn in the flames of Hell so long as the faith of my nation is safe and sound,” and, “I have not spent even two minutes of my life for my own sake. I am ready to die over and over fifty times every day for the sake of each one of you to find the right path.” cannot and will not put on a struggle to benefit solely themselves.

Another argument that lies far from the truth is the advice given to the Hizmet Movement to stay clear of a “battle between brothers”. Yet, the issue is not a battle between two brother groups over certain merchandise or a certain approach. The issue is the attempt to “extinguish” a completely legal private enterprise, a right and a truth that a certain group views as essential, one that is established completely according to the laws and regulations, a civil service that is of necessity to both the nation and the generations to come.

Indeed, as Ali Bulaç has written, if the battles of Cemel, Sıffîn and Nehravan had not been, then the disaster in Kerbela might not have taken place either.

However, if one side is persistent in their attempt to “extinguish” and is taking the necessary steps to do so, then it is the duty of everyone else to stand up and support what is right and just. The Holy Qur’an gives permission for those whose rights have been violated to raise their voice in order to defend their rights (7:148); praises those believers who support one another against the injustice they have been exposed to (26:227); what’s more, it openly commands us to stand next to the righteous until justice has prevailed over the one who is continuing in their injustice (49:9). The important thing is to stay away from the attitude, words and behavior that may cause one to end up being in the wrong when they are actually defending what is right.

Even during the battles of Cemel and Sıffîn, those who stood in the middle and refused to support Caliph Ali (pbuh) so as not to be a “part of the fitna (provocation and disorder)” were just as mistaken as those who started the battle in the first place. In the face of later developments, some of these individuals even expressed their regret in not supporting Caliph Ali; there were individuals like İbn Umar (pbuh) who were poisoned by the hands of the judges of the new period; to make matters even more bitter, the children of some of these individuals had no other choice than to fight on the side of the more powerful ruler, even fighting against Hussain (pbuh) in Kerbela.

One other amusing claim is that this is actually an operation to bring about the end of Prime Minister Erdoğan. Supposing there was such an operation, then whoever is behind the decision and attempt to close down these courses are at least partners in this operation. Some individuals are dragging the issue into the political sphere by saying, “We have the elections coming up ahead of us. There is no alternative to the AK Party. This argument must come to an end.” Whereas, the AK Party is claiming that it does not need the votes of the “Camia”. What’s more, the issue is not even political. Besides, before 1946, there was no DP; before 1961, there was no AP; before 1983, there was no ANAP; and before 2002, there was no AK Party. The political sphere and the political future of Turkey are not dependent on any particular party. In that case, this issue must be evaluated in its own terms, without being dragged in different directions.

Published [in Turkish] on Zaman, December 2, 2013

Source: Today's Zaman , December 3, 2013


Related News

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Ethiopia has illegally transferred a school run by German investors to Turkey’s state-run Maarif Foundation, Turkish Minute reported, citing the manager of the school.

Turkish Olympiads close with perfect ceremony

A spectacular closing ceremony at İstanbul Atatürk Olimpiyat Stadium in front of 200,000 spectators for the 11th Turkish Language Olympiads has left bittersweet memories, signaling the end of a two-week festival full of poetry, dance, Turkish culture and music. Participants, who came from 130 countries, in this year’s competition wrapped up the two-week long finals […]

RTÜK suspends 20 SHaber TV shows, harshest penalty of all times

Radio and Television Supreme Council (RTÜK) has suspended 20 TV shows of the Samanyolu Haber TV news channel, its Editor in Chief Metin Yıkar announced via his Twitter account on Saturday. The RTÜK penalty came days after Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan vowed to finish off the Hizmet Movement and its affiliates, including the Samanyolu Haber TV.

‘Let my husband go to another country, just not Turkey’

Turkish citizen Turgay Karaman fears being deported back to Turkey, his wife Ayse Gul said today. “If his arrest has anything to do with political matters, and if the Malaysian authorities don’t want him here, they can send him to any other country but just not Turkey, because they will torture him there,” she told a press conference after the meeting.

Minister Şahin praises Journalists and Writers Foundation for courageous coverage

SEZAİ KALAYCI, NEW YORK Family and Social Policy Minister Fatma Şahin has praised the Journalists and Writers Foundation (GYV) for its members’ courageous coverage of important issues at a time when the country is taking steps for democratization. Şahin’s remarks came during a panel discussion on women’s issues held by the GYV and Peace Islands […]

Gülen has strongly rejected comparison to Iran’s Khomeini time and again

Justice Minister Bekir Bozdağ’s recently rehashed allegations that Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen planned to return from the US to Turkey in a way similar to Iran’s revolutionary leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini are decades-old discredited claims that have been refuted time and again by Gülen himself in his published statements.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Gov’t lifts confidentiality of MGK docs for publishing in partisan press

Once shut down by Taliban, now Afghan gov’t plans to hand over successful Turkish Schools to Turkish Gov’t

German intel expert says, based on CIA, BND reports, Erdoğan was behind failed coup

Dialogue Eurasia: Humanitarian Davos

Exit from a well 1,915 meters deep

What can Christians learn from a global Islamic movement?

Global Muslim networks: How far they have travelled

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News