What is the problem between the AK Party and Hizmet?

İHSAN DAĞI
İHSAN DAĞI


Date posted: December 1, 2013

İHSAN DAĞI

Since the government demands unconditional loyalty and the subordination of social forces, the economic, political and intellectual independence of the Hizmet movement from the government seems to be the problem.

The state in Turkey remains the central agent capable of and willing to suppress social and economic actors. In the absence of checks and balances within the system, that results in the monopolization of power in the hands of the few, and it is inevitable that even elected rulers become authoritarian.

Neither civil society nor business groups is capable of restraining a state that defies the rule of law. On the contrary, they are expected to be subservient to the omnipotent state.

If any civil society network or business group claims autonomy from the state and rejects being subordinated to the state, they will be “punished” for their acts of “disloyalty.” Punishment may take different forms. For the Hizmet movement, it is closing down the prep schools, for business groups like Boydak Holding, it is unexpected tax inspections to be followed by heavy fines. By so doing, the state tries to teach civil society who is the boss: It is the state in abstraction, but in practice, it is the few in power who think they are the embodiment of the state.

Having defeated the Kemalists who used to claim that they were the state, the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) today displays a similar self-identification with the state. The Kemalists identified the state with the regime they established; the AK Party now identifies the state with its leader, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

The Kemalists regarded every ideology, every social group, every foreign government as a threat to the regime; the AK Party today views everything and everyone as conspiring against Erdoğan. This is not a healthy state of mind, yet it is the deep-rooted culture of those in power who think they are the state.

For the AK Party and the conservatives, it is an amazing journey to have gone from total exclusion by the state of the Kemalists to self-identification with the state and ownership of it within 10 years.

So the AK Party is now acting as the state has always acted in this land.

From the time of the Ottoman Empire to the Turkish Republic, the state (i.e., the owners of the state) has never felt secure vis-à-vis its own people. So it watched its own people very carefully because it was the people who would eventually claim power, and it was the people who would stand up for their rights. Therefore, they had to be taken under control by either coercion or co-optation. This has been the way to overcome the sense of insecurity that prevails among the rulers. So the “ideal subject” for the Ottomans and “ideal citizen” for the republic was the person who was dependent on the state for his/her survival, welfare, wellbeing and honor.

Thus the state never tolerated the emergence of independent social and economic forces. This has also been the state tradition since the Ottoman Empire. Both the empire and the republic fought against autonomous social and economic forces that are regarded as being against the monopolization of power by the state elite. People who did not depend on the good will of the state or refused to be part of the state patronage were not trusted. Subordination of the people to the state was essential for its owners.

People were either co-opted by the state or treated as a threat. This is the state tradition in Turkey that has not changed from the times of the Ottoman Empire to the Turkish Republic.

I think this is the background to keep in mind to understand the recent attempt by the government to undermine the Hizmet movement by closing down prep schools. For over a decade, the movement supported the ruling AK Party but maintained its autonomy from the government. As a social movement it does not need the state, its patronage or favor to survive.

Since the government demands unconditional loyalty and the subordination of social forces, the economic, political and intellectual independence of the Hizmet movement from the government seems to be the problem.

Source: Today's Zaman , December 1, 2013


Related News

Jailed Zaman editor says we are journalists, not terrorists

Former Zaman daily Ankara Representative Mustafa Ünal, who is standing trial after 414 days in pretrial detention, said on Monday that he and other colleagues in the same case are journalists, not terrorists.

Gulen-linked body condemns attempted Turkey coup

For more than 40 years, Fethullah Gulen and Hizmet participants have advocated for, and demonstrated their commitment to, peace and democracy. We have consistently denounced military interventions in domestic politics. These are core values of Hizmet participants. We condemn any military intervention in domestic politics of Turkey.

Turkish woman returned to prison immediately after giving birth

Yasemin Baltacı, who was arrested over her alleged links to the Gülen movement just two weeks before the end of her pregnancy, was reportedly returned to Manisa Prison immediately after giving birth in a hospital in Tarsus on Saturday.

Baseless allegations damage publicly traded firms

The ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government has tried to scapegoat the Hizmet movement via conspiracy theories to evade attention stemming from the corruption allegations. A number of news stories broke soon after Ala’s claims, reporting that Bank Asya’s accounts were being scrutinized for misconduct.

The Pigeon, The Finger, and Hizmet’s ‘Inevitable Ambiguity’

Hizmet combines characteristics that we are not used to seeing combined in such a way: faith-inspired (in motivation) yet faith-neutral (in so many activities), informed by Qur’anic principles yet inclusive and non-missionary, predominantly Muslim but proactively engaging with wider society and responding constructively to modern and post-modern ideas and lifestyles.

Turkey’s accused – Tragic stories of the purged

Turkey’s hunt for traitors after the failed July 15 coup has upended communities around the country and strained the rule of law. Arrests initially focused on military and security personnel. In the months since, tens of thousands of others, mainly teachers, have been caught in the crackdown.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Gulen Charter Schools: Ignorance and Lies Beyond Reality

Hizmet contribution to global peace discussed in Addis Ababa

Fethullah Gülen issued the following statement on Turkey’s extradition request

Gülen’s Dialogue on Education: A Caravanserai of Ideas

Film “Love is a Verb” portraying Hizmet Movement met with audience in NY

Dialogue Platform’s Statement on Developments in Turkey

Are the Turkish Leader Erdogan’s Claims of Terrorist Coup Plotting to Be Believed?

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News