Bediüzzaman on the Armenian issue

Bediuzzaman Said Nursi (d. 1960)
Bediuzzaman Said Nursi (d. 1960)


Date posted: November 3, 2013

Ahmet Kurucan

Rest in peace great Master!

A free society is built upon the freedom of individuals. Freedom implies that an individual harms neither himself nor others. Ultimately, freedom means not acting like a Pharoh; not being indifferent to the freedom of others.

…Maybe, liberty is when no one commands anyone, except the law of justice. Let everyone’s liberty be protected, and let everyone be as liberal as they wish in their lawful actions.”

…It is not freedom unless nobody can exercise power over others, other than by law. Everyone’s rights are preserved, and everybody is free to live within the boundaries of the law.

Freedom is a fruit of faith. That is, a person, who becomes a servant to the Lord of the Universe through his faith in Him, does not humiliate himself before others, and his faith and compassion do not let him violate other people’s rights. Indeed, a true servant of a king will not humiliate himself by oppressing a helpless person, just like he himself does not take oppression from another servant. Therefore, the stronger the faith in the heart, the brighter the light of freedom.”

Question: We accept that liberty and freedom is good. However, liberty of Greeks and Armenians looks repugnant, and it worries us.  What’s your opinion?”

Answer: First of all, liberty to them means not to oppress them and leave them alone.  This is in accordance with Islam. …………… …Ottomans’ granting liberty to non-Muslims is a key to the future of Asia at large and to the future of Islam; it is the foundation of Islamic unity.

Question: How could we be equal to non-Muslims?

Answer: Equality is not by virtue and honor, but before the law. A king and a peasant are equal before the law. How is it possible that Sharia orders “Do not knowingly step on ants,” thus prohibits torment, yet disregards human rights? Never!…

Question: Armenians are dhimmis.  How can dhimmis be equal to Muslims?

Answer: Let us not see ourselves in a magnifying mirror.  We are to be blamed on this issue.  We could not protect them as well as we should have; we failed to demonstrate the justice of Sharia. Because of the wrong practices of autocratic regime, we failed to protect their rights within the Sharia framework; later we wanted to correct it, albeit at a time when we had exhausted our strength. Now I’m seeing Armenians as dhimmi muâhid  (dhimmis that have agreement with the Muslim state).

Question: Armenians are treating us as enemies; they are cheating and betraying us.  How can we ally in friendship with them?

Answer: The reason for enmity –autocracy– is dead now. With the decline of autocracy friendship will flourish… Furthermore, our enemies and what kills us are ignorance, poverty, and hostility. If Armenians became enemies to us, they did it under the command of these three hatemongers.

Question:  How is it possible that Armenians are taking mayor and governor positions these days?

Answer: They do….just like they have become watchmakers, mechanics and broom makers. Constitutionalism is the rule of the people; government is the servant. If constitutionalism is practiced in the right manner, then they are not really the boss, but paid (civil) servants to society.  “Why should this world be a world of progress for everyone but a world of regression for us?  If so, I will talk to you no more….  I’m turning to the other way; I will be talking to the people of the future…

The children of this century, who suckle from the breasts of this age together with us, whose eyes look deep into the past, whose vision is as perfidious as themselves; let them think of the truths of this book as dreams. I know well that the claims of this book will become a reality in your generation.

Rest in peace great Master! Had we been able to comprehend even one tenth of these thoughts of yours surpassing beyond your age that you expressed almost a century ago, and if we acted upon them as they deserved, we could have realized the civilization that you described as a “charming angel” – light within, mercy on the outside; love within, brotherhood on the outside; compassion within, helping hands on the outside.

We are more than ever in a need of understanding you and the holy people who guide us on the trail you blazed. Nedim Hazar recently tweeted that “Understanding is too a matter of destiny.” Let God make us one of those who understand.

Note: Ahmet Kurucan in this column is quoting Bediüzzaman from his “Münâzarât” book, which is basically on freedoms.

[original text is in Turkish]

Source: Zaman Newspaper , October 3, 2013


Related News

CPJ report: Turkey world’s 10th most dangerous country for journalists

The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) on Wednesday released a special report for 2014 designating Turkey is the world’s 10 worst country for journalists, once again underlining the country’s deteriorating situation for freedom of expression and free media.

Gülen calls on int’l community to pressure Turkey over rights violations

Turkish-Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has made a call to the international community, asking them to warn Turkish authorities to take the necessary measures to restore the rule of law and protect fundamental human rights in the country.

Abrupt gov’t decision to revoke status of Kimse Yok Mu draws criticism

Turkey’s leading charity, Kimse Yok Mu (Is Anybody There), had its right to collect charitable donations abruptly rescinded on Tuesday, in what seems to be an arbitrary decision made during a Cabinet meeting, prompting harsh reactions from volunteers, lawmakers of the opposition parties and representatives of other civil society groups.

Academics sign statement saying ‘rule of law suspended’

Professor Ayhan Aktar, Professor Ersin Kalaycıoğlu and Professor Yasemin İnceoğlu, as well as 147 other academics, signed a statement saying that the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government cannot ignore corruption allegations by making up claims of a “parallel state” — which has no meaning in political science or law — and placing all responsibility of unlawful acts on the Hizmet movement, which was inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen.

Gülen appeals for steadfastness against gov’t ban on prep schools [in Turkey]

Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has asked his followers to be resolute and not yield to despair in the face of a government attempt to shut down private educational institutions [in Turkey] that assist students to prepare for high school and university admission examinations, which was interpreted as a major blow to the right to an education and to free enterprise in the EU-candidate country.

Gov’t bid to close Turkish schools draws ire

Many from various circles, including intellectuals and academics, have leveled harsh criticism against Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s government’s attempts to shut down Turkish schools abroad affiliated with the Hizmet movement, which is inspired by the teachings of Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Erdoğan distorts Gülen’s NYT op-ed, says it is about Bank Asya operation

Principal of Gülen-linked school, businessman abducted in Malaysia

17th TUSKON trade summit sees 25,000 B2B meetings

CHP leader says Erdoğan’s UN speech only served to promote Gülen movement

Parents seek TL 40,000 in damages for violation of students’ educational rights

A Prayer to the Volunteers of Kimse Yok Mu from the Islands of Comoros

Witch hunt and AKP’s legacy from Feb. 28

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News