What is behind the schools associated with Gülen?

Taha Akyol
Taha Akyol


Date posted: May 6, 2012

TAHA AKYOL, May/07/2012

What is behind the schools associated with the Fethullah Gülen movement (aka Hizmet movement)? Since the first school abroad was opened in Azerbaijan in 1991, what is the power that has caused them to be so widespread across the world in 30 (including domestic schools) years?

Can the “green belt” theory of imperialism or “moderate Islam project” be behind these schools? Maybe not, these schools and this movement did not exist during the Cold War era, when the “green belt” theory was most spoken of. When the Bush administration introduced the “moderate Islam” theory in 2001 against radical Islamists, these schools were already 20 years old, (and domestic schools started opening in 1982). Also, what political power can create such a movement and this many volunteering teachers without social grassroots?

Protestant cults

Sociologist Max Weber’s book “The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism” is an important reference book in sociology. It explains how Protestants were more successful than Catholics in Europe during the 19th century process of urbanization, industrialization, mass education and professionalization.

Catholics did not pay much attention to earthly matters, whereas Protestants believed they would obtain “God’s blessing” by being successful in the world. Catholics chose to become civil servants. Protestants had an “advanced commercial mentality united with intense piety.”

Protestant cults advised their members to stay away from earthly pleasures and directed them toward saving (capital accumulation) and trade. For those cult companies that performed with service enthusiasm and the life-discipline of piety, religious Protestant masses were available customers. Through this dynamism, Protestant countries overtook Catholic ones. The 19th century is also the era in which Protestant missionaries who opened colleges in many countries across the world overtook the Catholics.

Weber and Islam

According to Weber, because Islam is a “political religion” which does not value earthly matters and prioritizes jihad and pillage, it could not be suitable for the “spirit of capitalism.” Muslims were bound to underdevelopment in the era of capitalism.

Today, there is a wide entrepreneur segment named “Anatolian capital,” “conservative capital,” or “Anatolian tigers.” They excel in commercial achievements, opening schools and supporting schools. Weber’s theory of Islam is thus proved wrong, but his main theory that can be summarized as “religious-type working on earthly matters” has proved right.

The market and education in Turkey

In a peasant Turkey, these schools would not have been able to find many teachers to volunteer, and there were no Anatolian tigers to sponsor them either. Religious people with a peasant mentality would not be interested in such a movement either.

As Weber wrote, the market economy and professional educational factors are at an advanced level only in Turkey in the Islamic world. It is natural that as Turkey’s general level of education and entrepreneurial middle class has developed, the pious masses sympathized with this movement.

But, it is not expected that all the pious people share this understanding. At the same time, it is normal that those who desire a secular social life stay away from or  criticize this movement. In fact, modernity brings about ‘pluralism’. What is wrong is ‘aggressive attitude’, who ever shows it.

Starch secularist Prime Minister Gambetta in France in the 1880s fired teachers who attended Sunday mass because they were “anti-secular.” When he was asked why he strongly supported the missionaries in North Africa, he said they were spreading the French language. Similarly, these modern schools are spreading Turkish, let’s not forget.

[email protected]

*Taha Akyol is a columnist for daily Hürriyet in which this piece was published on May 3. It was translated into English by the Daily News staff.

Source: Hurriyet Daily News http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/what-is-behind-these-schools-associated-with-gulen–.aspx?pageID=238&nID=20100&NewsCatID=396


Related News

Fethullah Gülen and the role of nonviolence in a time of terror

Fethullah Gülen is unusual in adding a distinctly Islamic voice to the calls for a non-violent approach to conflict resolution. But how well do Gülen’s teachings on non-violence lead to peaceful transformation on the ground? Is his a static and passive approach bounded by dogma, or are we witnessing an innovative, active and self-aware spirit of transformation which really can lead to a new way of defining Islam in action?

Int’l language and culture festival ends with spectacular ceremony in Germany

A message from well-known Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen who inspired the Hizmet Movement was also recited at the ceremony. “At a time when rage, hatred and war prevail in different places of the world, some people see path to science, love and peace as far away. However, as it is said in a Japanese proverb ‘If you have a good friend with you, no way is far to you’, said the message. Gülen also expressed his special thanks to German people for hosting the festival.

Pakistani students compete to advance to final of Turkish Olympiads

A total of 278 Pakistani students studying at Turkish schools, which have been operating in Pakistan for 19 years, competed in Pakistani leg of Turkish Olympiads to be qualified to participate in the 13 th International Turkish Olympiads.

Libyan minister would like to see Turkish teachers, schools in his country

Libya’s minister of higher education said on Thursday he would welcome the establishment of Turkish schools in his country. Naim Ghariani, Libya’s minister of higher education, said his country would like to see the opening of Turkish schools and would welcome Turkish teachers and students. Encouraged by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, Turkish entrepreneurs have […]

Why should education in Pakistan be held hostage to the politics of other countries, however brotherly?

If Pakistan does indeed give in to pressure from the Turkish government, the move will be ironic, given the number of madressahs currently operating in the country with established links to political, religious or denominational movements that have a more than suspected record of terrorism, violence and spurious religious indoctrination.

Malian first lady commends local Turkish schools

Mali’s first lady Aminata Keita recently received a delegation from the local Horizon Turkish School, Mali Time to Help Foundation and Galaxy Dialogue and Cultural Center, at the presidential palace.

Latest News

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

Grondahl: Turkish community strong in wake of threats from back home

Turkish-Kyrgyz educator’s abduction shows Ankara’s ruthless disregard for law: HRW

Kenya: Investigate Deportation of Turkish National

In Case You Missed It

Journalist Gültaşlı: European institutions are ‘cherry-picking’ imprisoned journalists in Turkey

Turkish editor hits out at media coercion under Erdoğan

Who are these pro-Erdogan mobs who even beheaded a soldier?

A February 28 tactic from the PKK

Pro-gov’t columnist still threatening fellow journalists

Fethullah Gülen always supported settlement process, lawyer says

5 children abandoned in front of prison as mother detained

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News