The Gulen Movement: A Paradigm for the Engagement of Faith and Modernity

Rev. Bob Morris
Rev. Bob Morris


Date posted: February 15, 2012

In the midst of this time of crisis and opportunity, my question tonight is this: What is the future of religion in the new world order that is painfully emerging in our times?  How can religion support—and constructively critique—this new international order? I personally believe, very deeply, that God is raising up leaders in every religion who point the way to a possible future for humanity, and the Gulen movement is one among many examples of how this is happening.

The Rev. Robert Corin Morris, Sept. 23, 2008*

In our era, a new world continues to take shape, a world in which religions, cultures, and different political systems, can no longer ignore each other—a world in which the desire of one to dominate the other is ultimately destructive and futile. Over the last two hundred or more years the organs of a world-wide interweaving of civilizations have been developing, and the pace of this interweaving continues to speed up. I need not outline the ways in which various movements are reacting negatively to this in ways of violence, fear and xenophobia which may tempt us to despair of the future.

In the midst of this time of crisis and opportunity, my question tonight is this: What is the future of religion in the new world order that is painfully emerging in our times?  How can religion support—and constructively critique—this new international order? I personally believe, very deeply, that God is raising up leaders in every religion who point the way to a possible future for humanity, and the Gulen movement is one among many examples of how this is happening.

To understand the Gulen Movement we need to set in the wider context of the encounter of Islam with modernity.  Lamentably, our education here in the West gives short shrift to Islam itself, and even moreso the many constructive responses over the past two hundred years by Muslim leaders to its new encounter with Western civilization. We hear all too much about reactionary movements and all too little about forward-looking, innovative Muslim leaders who from the early 19th century onward sought to absorb the value of Western ideas without sacrificing a deep commitment to Islam. These modernizing thinkers were often opposed by Western colonialist powers fearful of indigenous Muslim movements, thus helping create the radical and violent backlash in some Muslim countries today.

Gulen’s proclaimed ideal is to promote peaceful coexistence, and dialog of civilizations on a global scale, and to foster a cultural and spiritual renaissance in the modern Muslim world, with Turkey and its distinctive form of Sufi-influenced Islam as a leading contributor.

The movement itself is not a tight, top-down organization, but rather a large flotilla of diverse organizations from schools to discussion groups, universities and employer’s associations, charities, student bodies, radio and TV stations and newspapers and lobbying groups, and interfaith initiatives like our own New Jersey Interfaith Dialog Center.

Gulen’s vision is parallel to that of the Renaissance philosophers in the West who founded humanism, a spiritual humanism which brought European Christians out of medieval fatalism into a new era of claiming human responsibilities and power, setting them toward the Enlightenment. But Gulen laments, along with some Western thinkers from Vaslev Havel to Pope John Paul II, that our “humanism” today defines itself in opposition to the spiritual roots of the West. He represents, along with other progressive Muslims, the emergence of a new Renaissance moment in Islamic civilization. But, he wants modernization, not mere Westernization, especially not the extreme secularization of Europe

In order to realize this spiritual humanity, Gulen calls humankind to the development of classical virtues and qualities. Love is at the center: “Love is the rose in our belief, a realm of the heart that never withers…Humanism is a doctrine of love and humanity.”Inherent in love must be respect for individual conscience and this requires freedom of thought. Since freedom of thought inevitably produces pluralism, ongoing dialogue within and between cultures and traditions is crucial to produce peace-making tolerance as an essential ingredient of civilization: “Interfaith dialogue…must…(give) precedence to common points, which far outnumber polemical ones.”

There can be no true pluralism when the moral wisdom of spiritual traditions is relegated to the margins of society and not allowed to be a vigorous part of dialogue about the common good. He argues science and faith are two different aspects of the truth, but that The question is “who controls science and technology and the purpose they are made to serve….No one has suffered harm from a gun in an angel’s hand.”

For a world in crisis, and a species whose greatest challenge is the moral wisdom to handle its dangerous tools and weapons before they cause irreparable damage to us and the planet, more “Gulens” — Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or any faith — are needed. And God is raising them up.

* Rev. Robert Corin Morris is Executive Director, Interweave Center, Summit, NJ. He delivered this speech on Gulen Movement (aka Hizmet Movement) at the Interfaith Dialog Center’s (now Peace Islands Institute) Annual Dialogue and Unity Dinner in NJ on September 23, 2008.


Related News

Sierra Foundation’s Dialog and Friendship Dinner Brings Together Many in Reno

This year’s Dialog and Friendship Dinner by Sierra Foundation repeated its tradition of bringing together many around a dinner table in Northern Nevada. The dinner has become a platform for bringing together diverse set of guests around the table and starting dialog and friendship among different cultures, faiths and communities.

German view of Hizmet Movement (1)

I remember the late, right-minded orientalist Annemarie Schimmel’s words saying, “The most attacked and least understood religion in the West is Islam.” Today, we come across a similar statement in a recently published scholarly report too. I’m referring to the report titled, “Überdehnt sich die Bewegung von Fethullah Gülen?” by Stiftung für Wissenschaftund Politik (SWP), which put the Hizmet Movement under a scholarly microscope.

Predictability in Erdoğan’s Turkey

The most significant damage beleaguered Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has inflicted on Turkey in a frantic effort to rescue himself, his children and close associates from legal troubles amid massive corruption, money laundering and illegal land-zoning deals was a blow to the “credibility” of Turkey and “predictability” in its political and economic environment.

Money trail in corruption case

The fact that the government practically stalled the investigation with a major reshuffle of the judiciary, police, watchdog agencies that track money, and finance and banking activities, while pushing emergency laws through Parliament to prevent further investigations and leaks, casts a shadow on how far the Erdoğan government had gone in these dirty deals.

Erdogan’s False Promises To Africa

The main issue Erdogan raises with his African counterparts is not improving economic and political relations, but the closure of the Gulen movement schools or their transfer to the Turkish Maarif Foundation, which was established solely for this purpose. Mr. Erdogan seems to be using official development assistances and “other financial tools” as carrots to convince African leaders.

GYV calls on President Gül to investigate interference with judiciary

Yeşil said the GYV is calling on Gül to take action to prevent these risks to the constitutional order, the separation of powers, checks and balances, the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law. He said: “The public expects him [Gül] to use his powers and authorities under the Constitution to investigate the interventions that sought to render the law dysfunctional, in terms of the graft and bribery investigations.

Latest News

This notable Pocono resident has been living here in exile since 1999

Logistics companies seized over Gülen links sold in fast-track auction

That is Why the Turkish Government could Pay 1 Billion Euros

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

In Case You Missed It

5,166 Turkish citizens sought asylum in Germany during January-November

Turkey’s fight against Gülen in the South Caucasus

Third suspicious disappearance in a week: Teacher dismissed in post-coup crackdown not seen for 14 days

Report claims government categorized schools linked to Hizmet

Turkey’s Gulen supporters flee to Greece – BBC World

An instructive crisis

German view of Hizmet Movement (2)

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News