Did PKK change its view of religious movements?

Dr. Yalcin Akdogan
Dr. Yalcin Akdogan


Date posted: January 3, 2011

Professor Yalcin Akdogan, the chief political advisor  of Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, wrote an article on the “Open View”,  the weekend edition of Turkish daily newspaper Star, titled “Did Ocalan change his view of religious movements?” Here is a translation of that article from Turkish:

In his latest meeting with his lawyers, Abdullah Ocalan, the leader of PKK terrorist organization, highlighted that he is not against disarmament in principal and he is the only person who could make it happen. He claimed a new role in the upcoming days; he, as always, made it sound like that solution is possible only through his own efforts. He strongly reacted against the statements made by Osman Baydemir in reference to closure of an era of armed battles was not because he disagreed with him but he thought that  Baydemir stole his role and mission of decision making. He was angry over losing an important card that could use.

Another striking point in his statements was where he comments on the Gulen Movement.  In regards to the meeting that took place between his lawyers and Huseyin Gulerce, a columnist at Zaman newspaper, he says “The government used some religious movements against us in the past. For instance, a conflict between PKK and Hizbullah was created. These sorts of problems can be resolved now.” This statement was interpreted as an olive branch extended to the Gulen Movement and a search for common grounds. Of course, we do not know what the subject of their meeting was or whom Gulerce was representing there. However, I believe that it would be a big mistake to think of this meeting as an official meeting between the PKK and the Gulen Movement.  I think neither Gulerce himself nor the members of the movement would be happy with such a perception. Ocalan’s lawyers had met with many writers, academics, and leaders of different movements before. I believe it would be quite wrong to see these meetings as a search for organizational ties as well as presenting them as such to the public.

In reference to the Gulen movement, Ocalan said “Its role is very important. I see this movement rather as a civic movement in Turkey and the Middle East. Like other civic movements, they can take part in democratization and enlightenment of the society without any political aspirations.” This approach actually seems quite different from his usual stand. That is, it is well known that PKK has always been intolerant towards any alternative “power” in the region.

PKK has seen them as a “threat” to its own existence and has tried to weaken their influence by all means. This is so whether it is a political party like Justice and Development Party which makes a political call, a spiritual movement like Gulen movement making a spiritual call or a NGO that makes a call for social change to people. PKK has been intolerant towards them all.

PKK has used everything in its power to suppress the emergence and thriving of any civic or political initiatives in the region. PKK has even killed some imams just because they did not take orders from PKK or spoke things that PKK did not approve. PKK’s intolerant understanding and oppressive approach contributed to the deepening, chronic Kurdish problem as much as the government’s policies to keep the status quo. On the Kurdish problem, no single person or organization with a different opinion or suggestion was granted the right to live. Any sort of formation was tried to be suppressed or terminated.

Ocalan in addition states that most of the problems will be overcome if the powers of the region can cooperate. “Everybody can work together in order to overcome the status quo in Turkey and to implement a road map for democracy. The common ground in these matters should be democracy.” says Ocalan. Indeed, these words of Ocalan should be analyzed well by both PKK supporters who have been terrorizing the region and the members of the BDP. It would be an important progress if such an ideology, which bombs party buildings and learning centers of the Gulen Movement and kills imams disagreeing with them, could come to terms with democracy and accept differences. PKK has been much irritated by the Gulen Movement’s activities that made it a strong player in the region. PKK sees any spiritual progress in the region as a threat to its existence and therefore tries to keep its grassroots as secular as possible. While PKK regards any religious activity favored by the people of the region as an obstacle to its organizational improvement, it takes it as a big threat when its own members start to come closer to such trends.

In disagreement to PKK, I do not believe that the Gulen Movement takes any organization or group as “enemy” or “competitor”. Social movements like this can only expand by adopting principles that do not create enemies, by being able to communicate with people of all levels, and open arms to everyone. Almost all ideologies around the globe has one common feature; creating an “enemy” or an “opposing” group. There is always an “opposing” movement or idea that prevents ideologies from reaching their goals. Therefore these opposite groups must be fought with and overcome. Fascist movements, for instance, see ethnic groups, immigrants and strangers as a problem and obstacle. The Gulen Movement cannot be classified as ideological structure. If a movement claims to address the hearts of people, they cannot be in a position to exclude, terminate, or target other groups. Because “winning the hearts”, first and foremost is an act geared towards dealing with “others” that are different than your own. Hence, religious movements are open to everyone from different levels of society by nature.

It is wrong and harmful to present Gulen Movement or create a picture that will make the Movement look as if it gets along and tries to collaborate with, or in need of help from PKK. I believe that Gulen movement will not fall into such a trap. They can play a vital role and do a major service to do people just like other NGOs in the region. The activities that will contribute to region’s social and cultural development, strengthening of its spiritual texture, consolidation of solidarity and brotherhood in the region shouldn’t be harmed by such manipulations.

Unfortunately we see that Ocalan is disturbed by the emergence of social initiatives more so than the political ones. He has been threatening the NGOs in the region and trying to weaken them by huddling them together under the name of Democratic Society Convention for a long time. We see Ocalan threatening and challenging one day, and being moderate and tolerant the other day. These zigzags suggest that his moves are all tactical rather than being the results of some principals. Despite all facts, it is still desirable that there is no more tension, polarization, and conflicts between the groups in the region.  All players in the region are responsible for nurturing a democratic environment where different opinions and groups can coexist.

Source: Star Newspaper Dec 13, 2010 (Original news is in Turkish):


Related News

A warning from and for a troubled land – how easily a democracy can be dismantled

Recently a messenger came to Colorado with dark warnings from a troubled land: Abdulhamit Bilici, the former editor-in-chief of Zaman, Turkey’s go-to newspaper before President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s brutal crackdown. You don’t often meet people like Abdulhamit Bilici in the United States. You almost can’t believe that someone with his backstory sits before you.

PM made the wrong choice

Erdoğan put under the spotlight US Ambassador to Turkey Francis Ricciardone by stating: “Recently, very strangely, ambassadors have gotten involved in some provocative acts. I am calling on them from here to do your job. If you leave your area of duty, this could extend into our government’s area of jurisdiction. We do not have to keep you in our country.” These caustic sentences prove that the AK Party has decided to declare a war not only against the Hizmet movement but also to provoke tensions with the US. Since they have opted for a defensive attack strategy, this reaction does not surprise anyone.

Who is Behind the Pennsylvania Protests?

Fethullah Gulen had suggested that the protestors should be listened to and not be treated harshly. This was an expression to show that the people’s voice and requests at Gezi should not be rejected.

Erdoğan’s war against Hizmet: Step by step

Turkish prosecutors carried out a number of arrests and raids on the morning of 17th December 2013 as part of a series of on-going corruption investigations. PM Erdogan’s response has been to call this a coup attempt against his government orchestrated by a coalition of foreign and domestic enemies. Erdogan claims that the ‘domestic pawn’ of this plot is the Hizmet movement. His number one election campaign promise: to crush and annihilate the treacherous Hizmet movement.

Turkish Olympiad students visit top level gov’t officials in Ankara

İPEK ÜZÜM, ANKARA Students coming from all round the world to participate in the 11th International Turkish Olympiad, a festival that celebrates the Turkish language and which this year brought together 2,000 students from 140 countries, visited the Ankara Governor and the ministers of energy and EU affairs in Ankara on Tuesday. A group of […]

Turkey’s Unethical Interference in American (Muslim) Civic Society is Dangerous

The Erdogan government jails its citizens without due process, severely curtails freedom of speech by jailing journalists, and ignores the plight of vulnerable minorities. They are the least credible messengers to warn Americans about their civic duty. The Turkish Consulate’s attempt to use McCarthyite tactics to spread fear and unduly influence American civic life is simply abhorrent and deserves condemnation.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

An early prediction about the next elections

Investigation into journalist over MGK, MİT revelations blow to free press

More Divisions, More Democracy

Fethullah Gülen’s Statement on the Shooting in Las Vegas, Nevada

Turkish schools in Somalia won 22 medals in 2 years

‘Pak Turk Businessmen Association actively working to enhance trade with Turkey’

Corruption scandal will consolidate Turkish democracy

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News