Islamists lost test with power, Arab and Turkish intellectuals agree


Date posted: February 17, 2014

İSTANBUL

Gathering in İstanbul at a meeting organized by Turkish Review and Hira magazine, Arab and Turkish intellectuals have discussed the role of the state in Muslim societies and agreed that Islamist politicians have lost their test with power, as they were transformed by the state instead of transforming the state.

Stating that Islamism differs in the Arab world and Turkey, the intellectuals participating in the “Turkish-Arab Intellectuals Forum” said the state should not be sanctified.

One Islamic scholar and columnist for the Zaman daily, Ali Bulaç, commented on the journey of Islamists in Turkey, saying those who came to power with the promise of changing the state became part of the state as they began to enjoy the benefits of state resources.

According to Bulaç, the mistake of Islamists in Turkey was to desire power for the sake of power. Another mistake was making religious communities dependent on the state, although they used to act independently prior to the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government.

Bulaç further argued that because of the corrupt rule of Islamists in Turkey, there has been hatred towards Islam among secular people in the country. He argued that the “old forces” that used to control Turkey are trying to take advantage of the current corruption debate in Turkey and eliminate all religious communities with the help of the AK Party.

“There are not any rules regarding the state,” said Dr. Ahmad Kalul from Tunisia, noting that the “ummah” is free to decide the nature of the state depending on the time and conditions.

According to Hasan Mekki from Sudan, who is president of the International University of Africa, relying on ideologies when it comes to governance goes against the interests of the community, since ideologies are not open to criticism and ask for complete obedience.

Associate professor İhsan Yılmaz from İstanbul’s Fatih University said it is not possible to talk about a “Turkey model, but a Turkey lesson” while emphasizing the importance of rewarding people not based on their faith, but on their merit.

Sociology professor Semir Budinar from Morocco said that there is a chance in front of the Arab world now, because when looking at Turkey, they used to see the state and society as a single entity. He says that starting with the row between Turkey’s Islamist government, the AK Party, and the Hizmet movement, people have become able to make a distinction between the state and society. According to him, the Hizmet movement has made a great contribution to the realization of dreams and ideals in the Muslim world.

Dr. Cemal Seferti from Syria, who wrote his PhD thesis on the Hizmet movement, said the success story of Turkey is a result of a “societal” success as a whole. “Hizmet’s contributions to this success should not be overlooked,” Seferti says, adding that as a civil society organization, Hizmet sets an example for Arab societies.

Kerim Balcı, editor in chief of Turkish Review, said the aim of the forum is to ask whether Muslims are able to remain Muslims when they come to power, referring to the recent corruption allegations made against some members of the AK Party government. According to him, after staying in power for some time, the current government began to do non-Islamic things.

For Balcı, who provided a detailed chronological account of events in Turkey in the last decade, there is no row between the Hizmet movement and the government. “There is the government’s effort to eliminate the Hizmet movement,” Balcı commented, noting that what is being witnessed now in Turkey is a sign that power has a poisoning effect on the rulers.

Commenting to Today’s Zaman, Cairo University academic Mohammed al-Sharqawi said the relations between people and the state should be reevaluated in the Muslim world. He said that when Islamists stay in power for a long time, they began to degrade in terms of democratic and Islamic values.

Dr. Jawad Anani, former deputy prime minister and foreign minister of Jordan and current president of the Jordan Economic and Social Council, told Today’s Zaman that the Muslim world generally looks at Turkey, Indonesia and Malaysia as hopeful examples of democracy, but he also added that India is overlooked as a country where democracy serves as the glue in a multicultural structure.

Further commenting to Today’s Zaman, Dr. Mekki said that for the first time in the Muslim world, Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has introduced a model of transforming society without conflict with the state. According to him, Gülen wanted to succeed through evolution rather than revolution.

In a similar analysis, Zaman columnist Abdülhamit Bilici told Arab intellectuals that in its 40-year history, the Hizmet movement has not been in favor of using politics to transform society.

Professor Muhammad Cekip from Morocco said the Hizmet movement was constructed on the basis of “humans with horizons.” Likewise, Professor Muhammad Babammi from Algeria said that the Hizmet movement is a phenomenon with a broad horizon that cannot be explained by the regular classifications of sociology.

Source: Todays Zaman , February 17, 2014


Related News

Hizmet movement and the Kurdish question

Ihsan YILMAZ  June 20, 2012 Hizmet movement (aka Gulen movement) roughly advocated two simultaneous approaches regarding Kurdish question. While the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) terrorism needs security measures as the PKK keeps attacking innocent civilians in the streets by suicide bombings and so on, the wider Kurdish issue needs cultural, socio-economic and political measures. Hizmet […]

Fethullah Gülen’s Lawyers: Gülen Movement Has No Link With Zarrab Case In US

The lawyers of US-based Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen said on Tuesday that the Gülen movement has no link to the case of Iranian-Turkish businessman Reza Zarrab in the US.

Refugees from Erdogan’s Turkey seek to make a new life in Germany

Murat spent six months in a Turkish prison, followed by a considerable time in hiding after his release. As soon as he could, he made good his escape to Germany. As a trained lawyer and legal adviser to an influential association, he had a good life in his home country, living with his family in an upmarket area.

Threats and fear used to intimidate business world

In one of the eastern provinces, members of a business association believed to be close to the Hizmet movement, a CSO, were visited by the managers of another association that the government seeks to promote. They were told that a police operation might be launched against their association and that they would face serious tax audits and commercial problems if they continued their membership in their current association.

Ahmet Şık’s book and Ergenekon’s media campaign (1)

Within Turkey’s ultranationalist camps, supporters of the Kemalist system have already extended their support to the Ergenekon network. So there is a sizable community in Turkey that believes whatever is said by a suspect in the Ergenekon case. Emre Uslu, Wednesday 28 December 2011 The Odatv trial has finally begun after months of waiting. The […]

Auto companies from 27 countries join TUSKON summit

Representatives of automotive manufacturing companies from 27 countries were in the city of Konya on Tuesday to participate in a trade and investment summit organized by the Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists (TUSKON).

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Turkey’s post-coup purges shake higher education

US Congressman: No Credibility In Charges By Turkey Against Gülen

Erdogan plotted purge before coup, say Brussels spies

Number of Kimse Yok Mu volunteers triple

MEP: International investigation into Turkey’s rule of law needed

81-year-old man sentenced to 10 years in jail over Gulen link

455 water wells opened in Pakistan thanks to Kimse Yok Mu

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News