Hizmet, Erdoğan and the US

Ali Halit Aslan
Ali Halit Aslan


Date posted: January 14, 2014

ALİ H. ASLAN

Five months after his Justice and Development Party (AK Party) was established, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan paid a visit to Washington as the AK Party chairman in early 2002 to attend several meetings, both open and closed to reporters. He met leading Turkey and Middle East experts in the US.

I covered his visit for the Zaman daily. After a brief search through the archives, I found the headline of a news story I had written on a speech Erdoğan made at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) on Jan. 29: “Erdoğan: We will reinforce the Turkish-American alliance.”

Erdoğan’s visit to Washington, where he laid out a reasonable and reformist vision that was favorable to Americans — including neocons and the Israeli lobby — ahead of the general elections of 2002, was cast by his rivals as a move to get “approval” from the US. No one from the Zaman daily gave credence to such unseemly accusations. Erdoğan and his party’s legitimate foreign policy was never criticized. For most of us, Erdoğan was a gallant Anatolian “black” who had been imprisoned for reciting a poem. And, just like any “white,” he had the right to govern the country.

During his Washington visit, Erdoğan attended a friendly gathering at the house of Zahid Akman, who was a Kanal 7 representative at the time. Akman had invited me to this meeting as well. I asked the first question. “What’s going well in Turkey?”

“The AK Party,” he had snapped. He was right. His party would come to power and form a government on its own by the end of year. Many of the people who had attended that meeting were later appointed to senior positions in the government. Of course, we cannot question their loyalty to Turkey just because they lived or studied in the US.

Why did Erdoğan change his attitude?

Over time, Erdoğan, whom we knew as a humble leader who embraced everyone in the country and was at peace with the world, was replaced by someone who spits high-sounding, turgid and grandiose rhetoric at all foreign countries and nations, including the US. Thus, Erdoğan transitioned from a progressive leader who had cast off his National View (Milli Görüş) garb and sought to make Turkey a full member of the European Union to a marginal figure who blames Western-guided internal enemies for every major political crisis. Erdoğan’s oligarchic gang of advisers, who are building walls even between the prime minister and his own party, plays a large role in this as these ministers tend to portray every unfavorable development as the doing of Americans or Israelis.

The Hizmet movement has been getting more than its share of abuse from these stealthily implemented public defamatory campaigns, waged by Erdoğan and his cronies since the prosecutors launched a series of raids that implicated several senior Cabinet members and their relatives on Dec. 17, 2013. Pro-government newspapers, TV channels and social media platforms are being used to accuse Fethullah Gülen and his followers of collaborating with the US in a conspiracy against the Turkish government. Many AK Party deputies and leaders who had lived or studied in the US in the past are either participating in this abuse or keeping silent — which constitutes an indirect endorsement of the accusations — or are unable to do anything to change this mentality.

In the past, the Erdoğan government hailed the Hizmet movement’s friendly ties not only with the US, but also with numerous countries around the globe, as Turkey’s soft power. Today, however, the government resorts to irrational conspiracy theories in an effort to divert public attention from allegations of corruption. Just like the powers that be of the “old Turkey,” they are seeking to market themselves as the only patriots in the country. They may be able to deceive some naive people in the short run, but in the long haul, their credibility will take the worst damage. As a social movement that successfully promotes Turkey’s values in its schools in about 150 countries around the world, the Hizmet movement’s patriotism cannot be doubted. You can ask Turkish embassies if this movement has ever engaged in any activities that run counter to Turkey’s interests.

Why does Gülen live in the US?

Those who seek to defame the Hizmet movement — which is not receiving material benefits from any state, Turkey included — frequently ask why Gülen lives in the US. It’s an effort to portray the Hizmet movement as the cat’s paw of foreign powers. For Gülen, however, the US is nothing but a hermit’s cell where he leads a life of exile. He does not tour the US. He does not meet American government officials. Even when neocons tried to conspire against him and get his residence permit canceled, he had to go through the courts to resolve the matter.

Those who defame Gülen as being disloyal to Turkey either don’t know him or have ulterior motives. His love for Turkey is legendary. As a matter of fact, his extended separation from his homeland is the result of his love for Turkey. He is concerned that his return could spark provocations that would lead to the country’s destabilization. For this reason, he has borne his longing for his homeland for 15 years. Jamie Tarabay, who visited Gülen to interview him for The Atlantic, told the US’ National Public Radio last week that he was living a “modest” life. Yet a pro-government paper has described his home as a “manor house.” This is a good example of what provocateurs in Turkey will do to defame and discredit this ailing man.

The supporters and followers of the Hizmet movement never pursue tensions or conflicts in international relations. In this context, they don’t want Turkish-US relations to suffer serious problems. Indeed, pursuing political ambitions through acrimonious discourse may harm Turkey’s regional and global profile. Actually, this principle guides the traditional foreign policy of the Turkish Republic, excluding occasional fits of populist rage by politicians. So what is wrong with Turkey’s sole global civil movement seeking to establish constructive relations with all the countries around the world, including Turkey?

The fanatic supporters of the AK Party slanderously call Gülen and the Hizmet movement the “manservants of the US.” Would they start to behave with some fairness if they took a look at what Erdoğan and his colleagues have said and done in the past, and what their past connections were? Or have their consciences become completely blotted out by rage and hatred? Do the Hizmet movement’s supporters, who are guided by love for Turkey and humanity, deserve this treatment?

Source: Todays Zaman , January 14, 2014


Related News

Liberal Turkish Journalists Champion Freedom of Expression, to a Degree

It’s precisely opposition journalists who have been criticized by colleagues who until recently worked for the newspapers of U.S.-based Fethullah Gulen. These colleagues accuse the opposition journalists of betraying freedom of expression. One of them is Sevgi Akarcesme who was editor-in-chief of the Turkish English-language daily Today’s Zaman. There is a great deal of truth in Akarcesme’s claims. But who today would dare defend journalists identified with Gulen?

American academic: Hizmet Movement serves for entire humanity

Speaking at a cenference in the southern province of Antalya, Soltes shared his observations about the Hizmet Movement. “I saw this on every people I met: I see that everybody, who is inspired by Gülen’s thoughts, help people with no thought of personal gain,” said Soltes adding that Hizmet Movement serves for entire humanity in the world.

Turkish Olympiad most effective promotion for Turkey, says FM

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu has praised the 11th International Turkish Olympiad, a festival that celebrates the Turkish language, as the “most effective” instrument for promoting Turkey, while receiving students visiting Turkey as part of the Olympiad.   Davutoğlu said he has been a fan of the Turkish Olympiads for a long time, noting that […]

Toward a security state

Hizmet movement resembles Western civil society groups and organizations in terms of creating public discussion platforms and performing education and unity-related activities. In addition, what makes the movement more important is that it does not depend on the state in order to survive and sustain its effectiveness.

Muslim Networks and Movements in Western Europe: Gülen Movement

The Gülen movement refers to a cluster of religious, educational and social organizations founded and inspired by Fethullah Gülen, a Turkish Islamic scholar, author and speaker now in his late 60s. The movement strives to give faithful Muslims the secular education they need to thrive in the modern world. At the same time, it also […]

US calls Turkey to uphold fundamental freedoms after Zeynalov’s deportation

When asked about Zeynalov being deported by the Turkish government, US State Department Spokesperson Jen Psaki said, “We are looking into these unsettling reports. As we have said, we have been and continue to be strong advocates for freedom of expression around the world, and we believe that democracies are strengthened by the diverse voices of their people. We look to Turkey as a democracy and ally to uphold the fundamental freedoms of expression, assembly, and association.”

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Turkey Continues Its Witch Hunt Against Gülen Followers

Ministry of Education denies authorizing raid on Gülen-inspired schools

Former Turkish President Gül denies having any relationship with the Gülen movement or Fethullah Gülen but history tells…

Henri Barkey: Why Is Turkey Accusing Me of Plotting a Coup?

What would Carl Schmitt say about Turkish politics today?

Financial Times publishes Fethullah Gulen’s Op-Ed

Lawyer of arrested officers detained for Gülen movement propaganda

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News