Report claims government categorized schools linked to Hizmet

Snapshot of Taraf daily's front page on Sunday. (Photo: Today's Zaman)
Snapshot of Taraf daily's front page on Sunday. (Photo: Today's Zaman)


Date posted: December 1, 2013

The Turkish government classified, categorized and monitored a number of educational institutions in some way linked to Hizmet, a faith-based movement inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, until 2010, a Turkish daily reported on Sunday.

The reporting is part of a series of leaks the daily published in the past few days unveiling a National Security Council (MGK) document that asks the government of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan to finish off Gülen and curb his activities, both in Turkey and abroad. The document, endorsed in 2004, was signed by a number of officials, including Erdoğan, then-Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül and then-Justice Minister Cemil Çiçek.

Turkish Deputy Prime Minister Bülent Arınç has dismissed the document, saying that the government has never implemented the policy prescriptions it includes. Other ministers, as well as Erdoğan’s top aide, Yalçın Akdoğan, made assurances that the government has never taken any action in line with the document.

On Sunday, the Taraf daily published five documents which list private educational institutions, including both regular schools and prep schools, that are “suspected of having links to reactionary activities.” The report was a response to a government narrative that the 2004 MGK decision was “null and void” for the government and that the authorities never implemented its recommendations.

The documents show that inspectors linked to the Prime Ministry monitored and categorized the schools every month up until 2010, when the government abolished the Prime Ministry Implementation Monitoring and Coordination Council (BUTKK), a body that was set up to monitor “reactionary activities” after Feb. 28, 1997 post-modern coup.

The Feb. 28 military intervention, called a “postmodern coup” because it was carried out without the use of arms, occurred when military generals confronted a civilian coalition government at an MGK meeting on Feb. 28, 1997, which resulted in the forced resignation of the government led by a now-defunct religious-minded party. The period following Feb. 28 was characterized by mass human rights violations in Turkey, and conservative groups were put under immense pressure.

The 2004 MGK document demands the government, in coordination with Interior Ministry, Foreign Ministry, Education Ministry and National Intelligence Organization (MİT), monitor and curb Gülen’s activities. The document required the government to closely monitor private schools, student houses, foundations, associations, dorms, domestic and foreign activities and Abant conferences that are linked to the Hizmet movement.

The MGK is the top state body created by the 1960 military coup. It was seen as a shadow government while the military was in power. Furthermore, it ruled the country directly from 1980 to 1983 before transferring power to the civilian government.

The document has sparked outrage in Turkey, with opposition parties criticizing the government for lying to the Turkish people while intellectuals have slammed the government for endorsing an MGK decision that is seen as a plot against the country’s citizens.

Erdoğan has yet to make any remark on the document, which also bears his name. Many pro-government columnists claimed that the government had to sign the document in order to, as a matter of fact, protect the Hizmet movement from the wrath of the military, which had a strong role in politics.

On Friday, Taraf published a document, signed only two months after the MGK decision, in which then-Prime Ministry Undersecretary Ömer Dinçer orders that steps should be taken to monitor “reactionary activities” with regular reporting back to the Prime Ministry. Taraf provided the document as evidence that the national security document was in fact implemented during the Erdoğan’s government.

Dinçer, who was appointed as education minister in 2011, told reporters on Saturday that the 2004 MGK decision was not implemented and that the document Taraf published is a separate process, a remnant of the previous government, which was determined to fight against “reactionary religious activities.”

He said the MGK decision in 2004 was only a recommendation to the government and the government didn’t bring it to the agenda of the Cabinet and shelved the policy recommendation by the MGK. He noted that the document Taraf published, which bears Dinçer’s signature, is an extension of activities endorsed after the Feb. 28, 1997 coup.

Dinçer said the government headed by Prime Minister Mesut Yılmaz after Feb. 28, 1997, drafted an action plan to monitor and fight against religious groups, including Gülen and the Hizmet movement. To coordinate and implement this action plan, the government established BUTKK at the Prime Ministry.

Dinçer accused the Taraf daily of not being aware of bureaucratic processes, formal written correspondence or the Turkish legal system. This, Dinçer claimed, led Taraf to interpret his letters as part of the MGK decision endorsed in 2004 and confused these two “completely different and separate things.”

He said the written correspondence about the action plan to “fight against reactionaryism” cannot be presented as an action plan against the Hizmet movement.

Deputy Prime Minister Bekir Bozdağ voiced similar remarks and said Dinçer’s correspondence is different from the 2004 MGK decision. He said the correspondence is part of routine work of the BUTKK, which “we abolished in 2010.”

In a response to Dinçer and Bozdağ, Taraf published five detailed documents that recorded the inspectors monitoring schools and prep schools linked to the Hizmet movement. The reason for the monitoring was given as “links between the educational institutions and reactionary groups.”

Justice and Development Party (AK Party) Deputy Chairman Mehmet Ali Şahin, who was a MGK member in 2004 but couldn’t attend the meeting because of a trip to Athens, said the decision was in fact signed to protect the Hizmet movement. He said he would also have signed the document, pointing to the military tutelage system that was dominant in Turkey.

In a first public comment on the issue, Gülen described himself as “speechless” and expressed his disappointment about the MGK decision in 2004.

Gülen stated that if the government had not undertaken steps to close the prep schools, a move strongly decried by the Hizmet movement, he would have given the government the “benefit of the doubt” and considered the document something “circumstantial.”

“What was required for the benefit of the doubt was this: We don’t know the conditions of the time. We weren’t acquainted with the matter so that we could know its background and assess it with its philosophy. This is how I would have looked at it if it had not had a continuation,” Gülen said in statements released on his website, herkul.org, on Sunday.

“But after statements confirmed the document, not only did I feel shattered, I am left speechless,” he added.

Meanwhile, Felicity Party Chairman Mustafa Kamalak said on Saturday that it doesn’t make sense to discuss the authenticity of the document and described the document as “unacceptable.”

He said the government’s plan to shut down the prep schools is reminiscent of the Feb. 28 coup process and is the opposite of the “national will.”

Source: Today's Zaman , December 1, 2013


Related News

Peace ambassador students conquer hearts at European Parliament

The Gala of the 13th International Language and Culture Olympics’ Brussels closing leg was hosted by the European Parliament, featuring 200 students from Turkish schools across the globe.

How the fallout from Turkey’s coup attempt has been felt in South Africa

In the late evening of Friday, July 15, word spread across the world that a coup was under way in Turkey. The president was missing, the military announced it had taken control of the country, and a few hours later, in the early hours Saturday morning, the coup was over.

GYV summit highlights link between education, sustainable development

GYV President Mustafa Yeşil, in his opening remarks to the UN high-level meeting, said sustainable development can only be achieved through a good education program. Yeşil said Turkish schools inspired by Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen that have been opened in many countries around the world have achieved the level of success they have enjoyed due to sectoral support.

Q&A: Turkish Imam Fethullah Gulen

Fethullah Gulen, the U.S.-based imam who Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has accused of masterminding Friday’s failed coup, answered questions from The Wall Street Journal’s Jay Solomon via email on Sunday:

British Foreign Secretary praises Turkish schools in Afghanistan

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül: “As you know, during the Taliban regime, girls were not allowed to attend school. Turkey has opened schools to educate these lost girls. I visited the opening of this school in Kabul, and 1,500 students will receive an education at that school,” Gül said to Beckett, referring to a February visit to the Afghan Girls High School.

Ethiopian PM: It is an honor to work with TUSKON

The two-day forum produced two important agreements. On the first day, TUSKON signed a commercial partnership deal with the Ethiopia Chamber of Commerce and on the second day, the confederation signed a bilateral commercial agreement that promises to provide advantages to TUSKON members in trade not only with Ethiopia, but also with the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA), which has 22 member countries.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Liberian Government: Turkish school to remain open

The Community has infiltrated the European Court of Human Rights as well!

Systematic Efforts by the Erdoğan Regime to Portray Hizmet as a Violent Organisation

Post-coup purge will affect Turkey’s education sector for decades

Abundant accusations [against Hizmet], little evidence

Divided republic of RTE

AfSV Statement on the Turkish government’s detainment of Kutbettin Gülen

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News