Is Hizmet making a feint at Turkish Government?

Akif Beki
Akif Beki


Date posted: August 27, 2013

Akif Beki

Journalists and Writers Foundation gave a bulk response to the rumors regarding Hizmet-Government dispute. I did not sense an attempt of making a feint at the government in the text, if we don’t count a few unnecessary sentences.

Thinking that folks may want to hear my comments on the topic, I was unable to abstain from chipping in.

An explanation consisting of 11 statements in response to the rumors that offend the movement came out in an uncensored form, and lists arguments to refute them.

They have laid on the table every rumor mentioned about the dispute such as the movement being behind the Gezi protests, the movement staffing in the police departments, the government’s shutting down of the college prep centers as a means of retaliation to the movement, discharge of the staff close to the movement from the key positions in the government, the movement running for a secret partnership in the political power, and the movement acting as a state within a state.

I found two things noteworthy.

First, their clear rejection of “the movement’s police” and “the movement’s judiciary” that left no place for misinterpretation. A state may have police force and judiciary, and in democracies, institutions rule and administer the state by the hands of the chosen. They have written down their commitment to this hierarchical reality in a manner that leaves no place for doubt.

Second, they position the Hizmet movement as a non-governmental initiative, draw natural boundaries between the movement and politics; and place themselves in their main areas of activity.

But then, why was it deemed necessary to bring up and refute the bygone conspiracy claims like “MİT (National Intelligence Organization) crisis?” “Why revive this past crisis,” you may ask?

Where were they till now?

I would say that their silence might have been interpreted as confession. Because the crisis, to some extent, grew out of it. Even though it is late, they finally show that they have not pocketed the perception of being a hidden locus of power and entering the struggle for power with AK Party. This is good. Don’t tamper it any further.

Aside from the reason of the timing, I found the statement extraordinarily revealing.

The Hizmet Movement clearly declared itself on ominous topics.

Making its position clear is favorable by all means, and it aligns with its “positive action” principle.

Didn’t all the harm stem from the perception of clandestine activities?

Isn’t hiding the face [intention], not making the position clear, and not playing openly are the negative actions that are also the signs of hypocrisy anyway?

This is the way of preventing a crisis.

It is a statement that includes [answers to] all the major claims; serious or unserious, reasonable or unreasonable, all kinds of claims have been addressed, even at the expense of violating the principle of “Depiction of the untrue muddies naive minds.” But then how can you cover up rumors, which are so loud and public?

Therefore, saying that “They are late in putting an end to the crisis” is a more proper objection. But, better late than never.

The statement has a single flaw: it was not necessary to put an exaggerated emphasis on the claim that the movement was behind the Gezi protests.

I did not sense an attempt of making a feint at the government in the text, if we don’t count a few unnecessary sentences.

Disclaimer: The original article is in Turkish. Slight deviations from the original meaning may have occurred due to the difficulties in translating phrases and idioms. PII volunteers translated the article.


Related News

PM threatens business, media and civic groups amid corruption woes

In several veiled references to the Hizmet movement, inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen who has been critical of the government for trying to derail the corruption investigation, the prime minister claimed that the operation was orchestrated by “gangs” and a “parallel state.”

TUSKON: Media raids discourage foreign investors

Foreign investors will not come to a country where the media faces intense pressure, Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists (TUSKON) President Rızanur Meral said, speaking in front of the Zaman daily offices in İstanbul on Tuesday.

GYV President Yeşil decodes the Gülen movement

MUSTAFA EDİB YILMAZ Mustafa Yeşil, the chairman of the Journalists and Writers Foundation’s (GYV) executive board, a Turkish NGO undertaking projects that emphasize mutual understanding and tolerance to establish global peace, described the movement named after the GYV’s honorary president, Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, as being faith based, pacifist, pluralist, colorful and pro-democratic. Gülen […]

Flynn stopped military plan against ISIS that Turkey opposed – after being paid as its agent

One of the Trump administration’s first decisions about the fight against the Islamic State, ISIS, was made by Michael Flynn weeks before he was fired – and it conformed to the wishes of Turkey, whose interests, unbeknownst to anyone in Washington, he’d been paid more than $500,000 to represent.

The Muslim Martin Luther? Fethullah Gulen Attempts an Islamic Reformation

Erdogan is clearly intent on marginalizing the Gulenist movement, even at the expense of the rule of law in Turkey. Turkey would clearly be harmed if Gulenist teachings on tolerance and individual rights were successfully quieted. But the loss for Islamic culture would be an even greater tragedy.

Terrorism: Why Obama, Others Ignored Turkish President Erdogan

Turkish President Erdogan on Tuesday called on world leaders to fight against US based Islamic scholar Fethullah Gulen over what he (Erdogan) described as an act of terrorism orchestrated by Gulen against Turkey. Addressing Presidents and Prime Ministers of civilised regimes of the world at the 68th UN General Assembly, Erdogan demonstrated before his colleagues very high level of incapacitation and inability to stick to simple ratified conventions to which Turkey is signatory.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Democracy on the rocks in Turkey

Turkish schools abroad victims of AKP-Gulen conflict

Gov’t steps up campaign against Hizmet via terrorism accusations

Joint mosque-cemevi project will contribute to peace in Turkey

Gülen’s teachings to be taught at Belarus universities

Witch hunt spreads to courthouse

Lawrence Seidman on Fethullah Gulen and Hizmet Movement

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News