Globalization and the Hizmet movement

Ziya Meral
Ziya Meral


Date posted: February 27, 2012

Ziya Meral*, Sunday February 26, 2012

Ongoing discussions in the popular media and scaremongering conspiracy theories about the Hizmet — also known as the Gülen movement — reflect two major intellectual failures.

The first of these is the common hermeneutic fallacy of not being aware and critical of the assumptions one starts with when interpreting reality. Thanks to 80 years of state-fuelled paranoia about anything to do with religion and civil society, the reality of an Islam-inspired civil society movement is automatically perceived as being a threat to our nation. Even the most banal and normal facts are seen as further proof for conspiracy theories.

The second major intellectual failure is the inability to realize the Hizmet movement is no more than a simple, local, faith-based movement with a particular geo-political aim. With substantial activities in more than 100 countries, the Hizmet movement cannot be understood solely as an ongoing, man-made crisis of religion versus laïcité in Turkey. This points to one of the most important but never analyzed aspects of the Hizmet; its globalizing power. Thus far, the global reality of the movement has only been discussed, once again, vis-á-vis Turkey. International efforts by the movement were either seen in terms of the Turkish “flag carrier” role played by the movement all around the world, or as attempts by the organization to establish itself in influential international centers in order to strengthen its power in Turkey.

These conversations only see the globalization of the movement as the movement reaching out to the world from and for Turkey. What has not been analyzed properly is what effects breaking out of the limited Turkish context has on the movement itself and, in return, for Turkish society as a whole.

As individuals inspired by Gülen have traveled around the world forming entrepreneurial business and educational networks, they have not only taken the Turkish flag and the teachings of Gülen to the four corners of the globe, but the experience of the world gained in this process have profoundly shaped them.

It was in fact easy to speak about tolerance and respect for others when the movement was largely limited to the narrow social and political horizons of Turkey and Central Asian societies with similar demographic realities. But moving to Africa, Asia, Europe and America enabled the movement to see what it actually means to engage with people from other religions, languages and distinctly different cultures. The movement experienced life in countries that are not rigid nation states but genuine democracies that have multi-cultural religious, ethnic and political structures. These experiences have altered movement members’ social and political visions, in line with 21st century trends.

Just like everyone who travels abroad, members of the movement have indeed developed a renewed pride in their country and culture of origin. However, unlike nationalist and other faith-based movements limited to Turkey, they have been able to develop a much more balanced and cosmopolitan basis for their patriotism, thanks to the theological framework of the movement. In this process, many of them have come to see that in fact there is no global conspiracy against Turkey or Islam; that the world is actually enchanted with Turkish culture and that there is so much Turks and Muslims can do to contribute to the wellbeing of this old planet.

Given that the vast majority of teachers working in schools and businessmen working and investing around the world eventually return to or maintain strong ties with Turkey, they are now bringing back their global experiences to both those who follow Gülen’s teachings in Turkey and the general public through their influential media, business and education outlets.

Previously, the main gatekeepers of the Turkish experience of the world were academics who attended conferences or short-term studies abroad, columnists who found a basis for their delusions of self grandeur by staying in nice hotels in faraway lands and businessmen with heavy laptop bags and limited language skills copying the trade ideas set by a handful of visionary companies.

The Gülen movement, however, erodes the boundaries of elitism. Cohorts of Turkish society, who were previously not able to experience the world, are going beyond shallow short term trips and living in and deeply engaging with the world. They are also willingly bringing the world back to large sections of society, unlike the old elite who jealously limited their experiences to the small socio-economic and cultural circles they moved in.

In the final analysis, while paranoia about the “secret” aim of the movement to turn Turkey into an Islamic nation goes unchallenged as a “plain” truth, in reality, the Gülen movement is fast becoming one of the most influential vehicles of globalization in Turkey, carrying it into the deepest corners of Turkish social fabric.

*Ziya Meral is a London-based Turkish researcher and academic.

Source: Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/newsDetail_getNewsById.action?load=detay&newsId=272577&link=272577

 


Related News

AK Party’s Deputy Günay joins intra-party opposition to prep school ban

Another deputy from the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) has criticized a recent government plan to shut down prep schools, saying that these institutions are not the cause of problems in the education system but a consequence of the current system. Günay’s remarks come one day after the AK Party referred Kütahya deputy İdris Bal to the party’s disciplinary board for expulsion after he opposed the government’s plan to close prep schools.

Guinean MFA: Our People Fond of Turkish Schools

The Guinean Minister of Foreign Affairs Lounceny Fall met with his Turkish counterpart Ahmet Davutoglu in Istanbul on April 5, as a part of his official visits in Turkey. Following the bilateral meeting, the two ministers held a joint press conference. Highlighting the mission that the Turkish schools assumed in promoting relations between Guinea and […]

Perinçek: I have Erdoğan’s support in fighting Gülen movement

Doğu Perinçek, the Workers’ Party (İP) leader who was given a life sentence in 2013 as part of a trial concerning the Ergenekon terrorist organization, has said he has been “fighting a battle” against the faith-based Gülen movement since the 1970s and that now President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is supporting him and the İP in the fight.

Hizmet movement in the spotlight at MESA 2012

The 54th annual meeting of the Middle Eastern Studies Association (MESA), held in Denver in November 2012, included a panel discussion on “Faith-Based Conservative Activism in Turkey: Fethullah Gulen as a Social Movement.” The panel attracted research studies on the Hizmet movement and its various educational and social activities, conducted at various geographical locations.

Ambassadors back Gulen schools in Asia

Kemal Ilter, Ankara Turkey’s ambassadors in Central Asia and the Caucasus have written a report in which they state that Fethullah Gulen’s schools in those countries, had been playing a positive role in Turkey’s relations with those governments. In order to give a new impetus to Turkey’s relations with Central Asian and Caucasian countries the […]

Al Gore’s daughter fasted for the first time for Peace Islands Institute’s iftar dinner

Iftar dinner (breaking of fast), which was held in Columbia University, brought together numerous prominent members of the community. The event, organized by Peace Islands Institute (PII), New York Interfaith Center and Columbia University Religious Studies Department, hosted former US Vice President Al Gore’s daughter Karenna Gore and one of the Indonesia’s prominent religious figures, Imam Semsi Ali.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Persecution of the Gülen Movement in Turkey

HRW report: No evidence to accuse Gülen movement of terrorism

Turkish schools in Azerbaijan join SOCAR-financed int’l education complex

Prominent columnist Bağdat slams persecution of Hizmet

Turkey’s first intercultural dialogue center built on trust, offers quality services

German state minister: Persecuted Turks can apply for asylum in Germany

Erdogan is transforming Turkey into a totalitarian prison

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News