Should the Hizmet movement form a political party?

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: February 10, 2012

Despite the image some have tried to create, we have been writing that the Justice and Development (AKP) and the Hizmet movement are two different entities. One of them is a political party and the other is a faith-based civil society actor. They have, of course, been on the same page with regard to many sensitive and crucial issues, such as the EU process, democratization, transparency, accountability and so on.

Ihsan YILMAZ, Friday 10 February 2012

However, the movement has always been at a critical distance to both daily political activities and to the AKP; its support has been in principle. Whenever the movement perceived that the AKP was either reluctant on or deviating from the path of democratization, the movement has criticized it. Yet, whenever the movement criticizes the AKP, the party’s staunch supporters and those who follow it blindly in the Turkish media challenge the movement and ask it to form a political party.

In the past, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan rightly challenged some military and civilian bureaucrats who were engaged in covert political activity against the government and who instead of resigning tried to block the government. Erdoğan used to ask them to form a political party or get involved in daily politics by becoming active members of a political party. The same logic is now being used against Hizmet. Many of those who do this are not aware of a proper democracy. They do not have to be professors of political science as even a brief perusal of the functioning of liberal democratic systems will show them that their understanding of democracy is faulty.

A bureaucrat must by default obey the lawful orders of his superiors and governing politicians. This is their job description and this is why they are paid by the Treasury. If they do not like the outlook of the governing party, they can resign and join a party. But you cannot expect journalists, thinkers, writers, critics, lobbying groups, business circles, civil society organizations, religious communities and individuals to agree with every action and all of the rhetoric of the ruling politicians. And, the politicians do not have any right to ask them to form a party and challenge them afterwards. Not everybody has to form a party, but they still have a right to criticize the government and to criticize it harshly.

Democracy does not mean only voting at the ballot box every four years and in between elections shutting up and waiting patiently or else forming your own party. If the ruling politicians are upset with the criticism and pressure, they can always say “enough is enough” to any group. The Republican People’s Party (CHP) and the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) now say this to Hizmet, and the AKP can do the same. But the AKP cannot say that I want your vote but do not want to hear your voice. Unfortunately, from some of the writings of the AKP’s slavish supporters and the whispers of some ministers, we see that that is the democratic understanding of some of the AKP elite. In this understanding, politics is confined and limited to political parties, while all else are passive observers.

Hizmet has been critical of the government on issues such as Turkey’s tolerant attitude toward a probable Iranian nuclear bomb, the government’s fruitless fights with Israel, the Mavi Marmara incident, the failure of the Kurdish opening, the reluctance in challenging the Ergenekon terrorist organization, the prime minister’s futile fight with journalists, the near end of the EU process, the AKP’s suspected indifference to a new constitution and the suspected “Ankara-ization” (being influenced by conservative anti-democratic statist forces).

These concerns have been voiced by Hizmet in the public sphere; the response of AKP-lovers has been to challenge Hizmet to form a political party. They do not want to see that a civil society entity may or may not want to form a party. After all, it is not a requirement. If every civil society organization forms a party, we will have no civil society. Political parties are inherent coalitions serving the needs of several different interest groups, civil society organizations, factions, movements and so on. You don’t think that on every single issue there are only two differing opinions in the US, one the Democrat view and the other the Republican view, do you? But these AKP-lovers seem to think so.

They also do not want to understand that Hizmet’s operational code is to build bridges and to address every mind-heart regardless of color, ideology, religion, status, etc. Hizmet forming a political party would amount to a suicidal mission. There will always be people who are sympathetic to Hizmet’s cause in every political party, and this is healthy as we need some cross-party or supra-party entities that would work like cement. Asking a bridge-builder to shatter the bridges he built and join political polarization may be bona fide but hazardous.

Source: Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist-271114-should-the-hizmet-movement-form-a-political-party.html


Related News

GYV praised for response to accusations about Hizmet movement

GYV Chairman Mustafa Yeşil said the foundation has received very positive reactions to its 11-article statement, adding that many people found the statement an “honorable” and “courteous” one. AK Party Adıyaman deputy Mehmet Metiner said by releasing Tuesday’s statement, the GYV has taken a very valuable step that “spoils the games of some evil circles that want to create hostility between the government and the Hizmet movement.”

Former US envoys to Ankara say Erdoğan doing great harm to democracy

“Whatever his achievements over the past decade, Turkey’s prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, is destroying his country’s parlous democracy. That is a profound problem for Turks and Turkey’s Western allies. Staying silent, out of fear that speaking out would harm some short-term interests, risks Turkey’s longer-term stability.”

Afghan minister: Afghanistan will continue to support Turkish schools

Samim said: “Afghanistan has been going through a very difficult period over the last 30 years. Everything has been overturned by the civil war, bringing the state to a near-collapse with internal conflicts. During this period, Turkey has always been with us. They [Turkish volunteers] came and opened Turkish schools. The first Hizmet [the faith-based Hizmet movement]-affiliated school was opened in the country 20 years ago.

Turkish entrepreneurs open eye hospital in Senegal

An eye hospital that was built and equipped by Turkish entrepreneurs in Senegal was opened with a ceremony on Wednesday attended by Senegalese Prime Minister Aminata Touré.

Setting the facts straight on the Gülen movement

25 April 2012 / JAMES C. HARRINGTON Much of what Dan Bilefsky and Şebnem Arsu’s recent article in the International Herald Tribune (“Shadow Force Grows in Turkey,” published on April 18 describes about Fethullah Gülen and Turkey’s recent history is accurate, but the authors cast a shadow of innuendo and loose conclusions, apparently more driven […]

5 children abandoned in front of prison as mother detained

A video shared on social media shows five children left alone in tears in front of a Prison in Ankara after their mother was detained while they were visiting their father in prison. In the video a child opens the door of a car in the prison parking lot, showing his brothers crying, and says in tears, “We are five brothers, left alone. We have a handicapped brother. I commend those people to God’s punishment.”

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Kimse Yok Mu conducts 500 cataract surgeries in Pakistan

Peace Islands Institute Annual Gala 2014

Local Muslims share Ramadan meal with each other and the community

Renowned Canadian professor lauds Honorable Gulen and Hizmet Movement

Foreign students express bewilderment over gov’t bid to close Turkish schools

Opposing the majority

[Hizmet’s] Prep schools and civilized debate

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News