So who’s finished exactly: the Gülen movement or the AKP?

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: August 19, 2015

Many writers and thinkers in Turkey, responding to President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan crew’s full-scale, state-backed attack on the Gülen movement, noted wisely, “You cannot wipe out that entire sociology.” These observations came in the face of the ruling Justice and Development Party’s (AKP) posturing, characterized by words of warning from Ankara to the movement along the lines of “You exist only because we exist,” or “Not even water for those folks.” But of course, then, as now, no warnings are heeded by true Erdoğanists. But still, for the sake of posterity, I’d like to engage in a small bit of analysis on this front.

It’s undeniable that the Erdoğanist regime has damaged the Gülen movement. After all, this government has had from its very inception deep alliances with many who harbor serious grudges towards the Gülen movement; not unlike the view of more pious citizens taken by some “White Turks.” In this way, forces within the state have worked over the years to derail the Gülen movement as much as possible, causing it a certain level of losses in the process. In the end though, rather than finishing off the Gülen movement for good, what has actually happened is more akin to how a tree grows more rapidly and healthily after it has been pruned.

It should be examined whether some people parting ways with the Hizmet movement is actually a loss because these people seemed close to Hizmet when they thought it was strong, assumed the movement was acting in cooperation with the government on all issues or when the movement was part of the state, but they never understood the core philosophy of Hizmet or adopted it. Hizmet underwent traumas during the coup processes of 1971, 1980 and Feb. 28, 1997. Following the first departures, it developed more, became more mature and had more depth. This is what will most probably happen following this process. Companies that undergo crises with self-criticism, reflection, assessment of their actions and strategies for adaptation to new circumstances, following a short-term dwindling, begin flourishing again.

This is the period that the Hizmet movement is going through right now. Certain deficiencies found among volunteers of the Gülen movement, such as seeming extremely close to the party in power, assigning more importance to the state than necessary, being overcome by hubris, distancing themselves from being human-centric, weakness in being justice-oriented and the weakening of spirituality are being re-evaluated over and over again as a new era is being prepared for, albeit with very little of it overtly in the public eye.

Hizmet’s past is the witness of how it renews itself and adapts to new conditions without losing its founder’s soul, basic philosophy and paradigm. In other words, Hizmet’s story is not finished, it just feels the pain of passing to a new and more exciting period. Yet, what is the situation on the AK Party front, which claimed to end the Hizmet movement? Though they asserted a thousand turgid claims and exploited the power of the state, they failed to submit evidence for any of the claims that they have made. They just raid the nurseries of children with heavily armed police officers to show off and continue to pick on Kimse Yok Mu, a charity organization, and on philanthropists.

No need for deep analysis, this is the dramatic portrait of an ending.

Source: Today's Zaman , August 19, 2015


Related News

Finally, an awakening… press freedom in Turkey

Yavuz Baydar “…notes with concern that most media are owned by and concentrated in large conglomerates with a wide range of business interests ; reiterates its call for the adoption of a new media law addressing, inter alia, the issues of independence, ownership and administrative control…” The excerpt is from the European Parliament Resolution on […]

One Year On, New Research Uncovers Turkey’s Coup Bid Staged By Erdoğan Himself

The report uncovered a critical information that the plot was actually kicked off on July 11 with secret orders given by generals who corroborated with Turkey’s autocratic President Erdogan’s defense and intelligence chiefs in disguising the plan as unconventional action plan. Only a handful men were let into the secret plot while many were led to believe a drill or an urgent response to a terror threat is underway.

Separate state and religion

Turkey needs to face the fact that experience gained over the course of almost a century has shown that the marriage of state and religion is detrimental to both. If Turkey is to ever consolidate a liberal and pluralist kind of democracy, state and religion need to be separated, and freedom for believers and nonbelievers alike has to be secured.

Turkish Charities accelerate Ramadan aid efforts worldwide

Kimse Yok Mu has raised its Turkey target for this Ramadan and will distribute 178,300 food packages and set up iftar tents in 22 provinces in a bid to feed an estimated 636,000 people. Outside of Turkey the foundation intends to distribute 110,000 food packages to families in need in 103 countries and offer iftar meals to 500,000 people around the world.

Turkish army profiled Tahşiyeciler as serving al-Qaeda

The 13 March 2009 report, prepared by Turkish General Staff Intelligence Unit Head, Lieutenant General Hakkı Pekin, reveals the Tahşiyeciler group’s ideology strongly aligned with al-Qaeda, viewing its leader Osama Bin Laden as Mahdi, the prophesied redeemer of Islam.

PKK terrorists set dorm on fire, one student injured

Terrorists from the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) have set fire to a dershane and its dorm that belong to the Hizmet movement in the eastern province of Muş, injuring at least one student.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Turkey’s president orders closure of 1,000 private schools linked to Gülen

Turkish anti-terrorism police carried out raids in six cities, detaining at least five people with alleged links to al-Qaida

Defamation- Pro-Erdoğan daily claims Gülen movement converted 500,000 to Christianity in Kazakhstan

Turkey’s Erdogan takes cue from Hitler, Stalin and Khomeini

Turkish finance minister declines to comment on ‘color lists’

The Gülen community and the AKP

Gülen files criminal complaint over illegal wiretapping

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News