Hizmet and self-criticism

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: August 11, 2014

Ihsan Yilmaz

Fethullah Gülen stated a few days ago that he made a mistake by supporting the Justice and Development Party (AKP) during the 2010 referendum campaign. Even though, as of today, I do not think that supporting the constitutional amendment package was wrong in itself, it seems that this package has paved the way for the AKP’s growing semi-despotism.

As I have underlined here repeatedly, with the Ergenekon trials, the AKP eliminated its first major fear of a military coup, and, with the 2010 referendum, it eliminated the second major fear of its closure by the Constitutional Court. Thus, now, it feels free to do away with democracy and rule of law. Yet, no one could predict this in 2010 since Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan very skillfully hid his real intentions. This is not Gülen’s fault. Out of humility, he is criticizing himself. But I think, on the basis of his adherence to the principles human rights, democracy, pluralism and basic freedoms, he would support the same package even today.

I think the Hizmet media and many Hizmet volunteers, including myself, made their major mistake concerning the AKP during the 2011 general elections, when they very openly, publicly, enthusiastically and strongly supported the AKP, helping the party get 50 percent of the votes. As regular readers of this column will remember, in addition to the results of the Ergenekon trials and 2010 referendum, this election result, in my view, is the third major factor contributing to Erdoğan’s intoxication and transformation into a semi-despot.

It is easy to speak now, but considering the circumstances surrounding the 2011 elections, this mistake could not be easily diagnosed. Center-right parties sabotaged themselves by siding with the military generals during the crisis that erupted during the presidential election in 2007, and I remember hearing that Gülen was upset with them for leaving Erdoğan without any viable alternatives. He had actually foreseen that Erdoğan would one day become spoiled and naughty because of the lack of alternatives. Remember that, in the 2011 elections, only three serious contenders existed: the AKP, the People’s Republican Party (CHP) and the Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), and both the CHP and the MHP had nominated Ergenekon suspects for parliamentary seats. It was only natural for many Hizmet volunteers and the Hizmet media to fear the probability that Ergenekon and the military’s coup tendencies would return.

Moreover, the AKP was the only big party to support the EU accession process, democratization, basic freedoms, human rights and pluralism in 2011. Even though I and several others at this newspaper started seeing the major deficiencies of the AKP and started criticizing them around 2008 and 2009, the pluses of the AKP still outweighed the minuses until 2012.

Nevertheless, these Hizmet volunteers and the Hizmet media could have restrained their pro-AKP enthusiasm a little more and, instead of fully supporting it, they could have been more balanced, objective and neutral towards all political parties. It was a mistake not to see the deficiencies of the AKP, its lack of enthusiasm for the EU and democratization and its corrupt practices that were criticized by the opposition. If the AKP had received 45 instead of 50 percent in 2011, it would have still come to power, but it would probably have been less spoiled by overindulgence.

It was a very serious mistake not to denounce Erdogan when he repeatedly used and abused the illegally obtained records of the private life of opposition leader Deniz Baykal and several MHP candidates in his election rallies. It was a huge and unforgivable mistake not to earnestly investigate AKP corruption in the Deniz Feneri case. I am very ashamed that I naively tended to believe what pro-government columnist Fehmi Koru wrote about this case at the time. He made us believe that this was a foreign plot against the AKP. I am deeply ashamed.

We did not believe the white-Turk and pro-Ergenekon media at the time since, in the past, they had published innumerable fabricated stories critical of the AKP, practicing Muslims, the Hizmet and so on. My colleagues and I were so busy with the fight for democratization and the Ergenekon trials that we did not spend much time to hear, analyze and investigate what the opposition was claiming about the AKP’s corruption, anti-democratic practices, wrongdoings in the KCK and Ergenekon trials and so on. All of us, including the Hizmet, are now paying the price.

It is now a little late, but I feel sorry for not being more curious, more investigative, more balanced, more outspoken, less impartial and less naïve.

Source: Today's Zaman , August 8, 2014


Related News

Turkish PM: State of emergency will continue until Gülen movement completely wiped out

Turkish Prime Minister Binali Yıldırım said in Ankara on Thursday that the state of emergency which was declared following a failed coup attempt in July of last year will continue until the faith-based Gülen movement, which the government accuses of being behind the coup attempt, is completely wiped out from state institutions.

A Year Ago Today: Teacher Gökhan Açıkkollu died of torture on his 13th day in police custody

Gökhan Açıkkollu, a history teacher suffering from diabetes, died of torture in police custody as part of a post-coup investigation into Turkey’s Gülen group. According to his father, Ayhan Açıkkollu, Gökhan was a diabetics patient while human rights defenders hinted at torture and maltreatment.

Message of tolerance, peace expressed at GYV’s fast-breaking dinner

A message of tolerance, dialogue and coexistence for people of different faiths and ethnic backgrounds was dominant at a fast-breaking dinner organized by the Journalists and Writers Foundation (GYV) on Thursday. “We have capital no other than love, no intention other than serving humanity,” Mustafa Yeşil, head of the GYV, said at the fast-breaking dinner, […]

Turkey’s Brain Drain and the Disappearing Academic Freedom

Hasan was the luckiest because he was not in Turkey during the coup. He was studying abroad on July 15th and learned the coup through the Internet. He was supposed to go back to Turkey but he decided not to do so because of the news on the immense purging in mostly the government and some private institutions. Few days after the coup he learned that he was dismissed from his position at a state university.

Pro-gov’t media knows no limits in ’parallel’ claims

Ever since President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan launched a battle against the faith-based Hizmet movement after a corruption probe went public on Dec. 17, 2013, almost no day has passed without pro-government media outlets’ bringing forward allegations about the “parallel structure or state” and associating any negative development in the country with this so-called structure.

Some states use religion for wars, says Catholic Bishop in İstanbul

Speaking at the Dialogue Symposium held in İstanbul on Friday, the spiritual leader of the Latin Catholic Community, Louis Pelatre said some states abuse religion for wars although all religions prohibit killing and war. “We have to fight against prejudices in order to prevent the use of religion in wars,” said Pelatre as he commended the interfaith dialogue efforts of Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Pakistan Today Editorial: The Turkish connection and Turkish schools

Buhari’s wife hails culture

‘A very good representative of the best in Islam, Hizmet contributes to the non-Muslim world’s understanding of Islam’

TUSKON awarded damages, to build orphanage in Uganda

4th International Panel for Sharing Coexistence Experience in Korea

Fountain’s Yeşilova: We believe human life and the universe are each a book to read

Teaching Peace in Schools

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News