Gülen offers more explanations of his views on continuing slander


Date posted: March 21, 2014

PENNSYLVANIA
Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, who has inspired a worldwide network active in education, charity and outreach called the Hizmet movement, has responded to manifestly ill-intentioned comments about an interview he gave to Today’s Zaman, saying that he cannot remain silent in the face of injustice.

“What have the members of the Hizmet movement done so far, other than defending themselves against assaults, responding to insults and placing emphasis upon the rule of law and noninterference in the judicial process?” he said.

Gülen accused the Erdoğan government of “trying to justify a political style that is getting more authoritarian by making references to Islamic notions.”

“In a democratic order, if you are not allowed to express your views, then even the minimal requirements of being a democracy are not fulfilled. Imposing a type of rule with reference to religious notions will have serious political and legal repercussions,” he said.

He also rejected claims that he is the Messiah. “I am not claiming to be the Messiah or Mahdi; I am just an ordinary man. As long as I live, I am a loyal subject of the Quran and the dust on the foot of Prophet Muhammad. If anybody attributes any other quality to me, I would reject it,” he explained.

Today’s Zaman posed additional questions to Mr. Gülen after pro-government papers, unable to offer any grounded criticism vis-à-vis the content of the interview, made unreasonable allegations.

Here are Mr. Gülen’s responses to comments about his published remarks.

‘Constructive response’ doesn’t mean silence in the face of injustice and unfair treatment

Some argue that the attitude of the Hizmet movement is not consistent with Bediüzzaman’s philosophy of “constructive response.”

In his works, Bediüzzaman also specifies the conditions and framework of this style and approach: acting consistently with the will of Allah, serving the interest of religion and faith, noninterference in the divine service, protecting the safety of the people and remaining patient. Constructive response does not mean silence and powerlessness against injustice. Bediüzzaman never remained silent in the face of illegality and unfair treatment just because the political authority was responsible for that treatment. He responded to blasphemous remarks and defended himself in the courtrooms. There are examples of this in his works. What have the members of the Hizmet movement done so far, other than defending themselves against assaults, responding to insults and placing emphasis upon the rule of law and noninterference in the judicial process? The media outlets affiliated with the Hizmet movement have not gone beyond reporting the corruption allegations that were taken to the judiciary and informing the people on these matters. Instead of responding to the corruption allegations and addressing the charges, they [pro-government media] make improper and unsubstantiated remarks and claims.

They either do not understand the movement or insult its members out of hatred

Some former members of the movement attributed some remarks to you. They claimed that you had told them you had spoken with Allah or declared yourself the Messiah or the “İmam of the universe.” What would you say about these allegations?

The issue of Messiah or Mahdi has been a matter of controversy in Islamic societies for a long time. Whether or not this is a scholarly issue is a whole different matter. Some scholars said this is a verified part of the Islamic faith, whereas some others argued Islam does not recognize the coming of the Messiah or Mahdi. But this issue has always been exploited and manipulated. Some circles have attributed similar remarks to Bediüzzaman in the past. They exploited his comments and views on the return of the Messiah or Mahdi, arguing that he considered himself the Mahdi or Messiah.

However, I am at all times mentoring students; so they would testify that I would consider such allegations and remarks blasphemous. They have heard me many times saying, “You know my father and mother; being an ordinary man and a subject of Allah is more than enough for me.” I have not seen anybody around me attributing such qualities to themselves. In addition, I always regarded such accusations as the most offensive curses directed at me. Those who make these allegations are not aware that they actually insult the people.

On this matter, I would follow in the footsteps of Mevlana. I am not claiming to be the Messiah or Mahdi; I am just an ordinary man. “As long as I live, I am a loyal subject of the Quran and the dust on the foot of Prophet Muhammad. If anybody attributes any other quality to me, I would reject it.”

As for the other allegation; I wonder how they can make such grave, delirious remarks. Those who raise these arguments are actually aware of my sensitivity. The Quran states: “It is not given to any human being that Allah should speak to him unless (it be) by Inspiration, or from behind a veil, or (that) He sends a Messenger to reveal what He wills by His Leave. Verily, He is Most High, Most Wise.” Even the most basic tenets and precepts of Islam set some boundaries. We have been trained in a cultural environment where we were taught to bow when hearing the name of Allah. I was born into such an environment, where you cannot possibly identify even a single person making such allegations.

The claims that I consider myself an Imam of the universe cannot be taken seriously. Even men of reason and conscience remain silent and unresponsive to such allegations. They are referring to a fabricated hierarchy of the Hizmet movement that never once entered my mind. What kind of mentality is this? They are fabricating things and insulting the intelligence of millions of people who consider themselves affiliated with this movement.

Those who refer to such a hierarchical structure and some higher positions in this movement do not understand Hizmet; or they are making deliberate insults because, as Bediüzzaman notes, the foundation of our movement is brotherhood. This is a relationship between biological father and son, or a sheikh and his follower. This is a genuine bond of brotherhood. Those who know me will confirm that I consider my students colleagues with whom I make deliberations and have discussions.

‘Furuat’ (nonessentials) is information for beginners in Islamic teaching

It is alleged that you consider the headscarf issue insignificant because you refer to it as “furuat” (nonessential). What would you say about this?

The obligations regarding faith and acts in Islam are divided into two groups: “usul” (essentials) and “furu” (nonessentials). Those regarding faith and belief are called usul and those regarding acts and prayers furu. Compared to the usul, nonessentials are considered of secondary importance. For this reason, the headscarf is of secondary importance because it is considered part of furuat under Islam. It should be recalled that considering the headscarf part of furuat is a general approach held by Islamic scholars. Some journalists may not be able to discern this detail in their reports and interviews. But the clerics and Islamic scholars should know this matter better, because a person cannot be regarded a scholar if he fails to make a distinction between usul and furu. This is not an advanced matter. From the perspective of classical Islamic teaching, it is basic information for beginners. I do not think that those who exploit this matter and raise this discussion on whether headscarf is part of furuat in Islam are unaware of its meaning in Islamic literature. This campaign has always been raised deliberately. Moreover, I made specific reference to furuat; but the papers published this as teferruat (details). This implies that the headscarf issue is insignificant.

I should also note that wearing the headscarf is not obligatory under Islam just because it is part of furuat. Wearing the headscarf is a must for women. There are many other tenets and obligations that are part of furuat. If I were a person who didn’t pay attention to the headscarf issue and who didn’t consider wearing the headscarf a must under Islam, I would not have asked the prime minister in a letter I addressed to him in 2006 to resolve this matter immediately. Those who are curious about this may find this letter and analyze its content.

 Those who urge us not to cause turmoil should also hear what is being said in the political rallies

Some theologians argue that the movement rioted against a legitimate government; what would you say to this?

Obeying rulers does not mean that we should remain silent and indifferent to the wrongful acts of the government and not pay attention to what is right. The obligation to promote the good and discourage people from doing wrong applies to all. The sphere of politics is not an essential part of religion. It does not refer to the faith or belief part of the religion. Holding different views in such a sphere is pretty natural. Even members of the Hizmet movement may hold different opinions on different matters. In a democratic order, if you are not allowed to express your views, then even the minimal requirements of being a democracy are not fulfilled. Imposing a type of governance with religious references will have serious political and legal repercussions.

They are trying to justify a political style that is getting more authoritarian by making references to Islamic notions; unfortunately, matters that would not be significant other than discussions on different approaches and exploitations and manipulations were taken to a different stage. In the end, they declare a state of war or social mobilization. They now even rely on methods of destruction and an organized attempt by which they declare members of Hizmet movement as infidels.

Should not those who urge us not to cause turmoil make similar remarks and suggestions to those who are in power and those who make grave insults? Otherwise, remarks by those who are unable to make even a single suggestion will mean nothing but attempts to destroy the Hizmet movement, which is nowadays a popular thing to do.

Source: Todays Zaman , March 21, 2014


Related News

Turks Fleeing To Greece Find Mostly Warm Welcome, Despite History

Now, at least 1,000 Turkish citizens are seeking refuge in Greece, according to the refugee support nonprofit SolidarityNOW. It’s hard to pin down an exact number because not many have applied for asylum, says Antonis Spathis, a human rights lawyer in Thessaloniki. The Greek Asylum Service told NPR that 186 Turkish citizens applied for asylum in 2016 and noted there has been a “significant” increase in 2017.

Interview: Professor Greg Barton, counter terrorism expert with Deakin University

Tony Jones speaks with Greg Barton and asks him what is the likely scenario for security in Turkey following President Erdogan’s announcement of a three month state of emergency.

Fethullah Gulen’s new book “The Struggle for Renewal” sold 200,000 in 20 days

Fethullah Gulen’s new book [written in Turkish] “The Struggle of Renewal,”* the last of Broken Pot series published by Nil Publications, sold 200.000 in 20 days in Turkey. Gulen’s books are guiding ones, which address to and suggest solutions for the needs of society”. Yilmaz Simsek, NT Stores director of Book Category, said the book […]

The latest step by AKP-Gov’t witch-hunt against Hizmet Movement

In Turkey, the increasing pressure over the freedom of press, property rights and authoritarianism have reached an alarming level. A recent report on the rule of law and respect for human rights inTurkey declared that Turkish government had been perpetrating systematic human rights violations since December 2013.

Medialog calls for law against hate speech and crime [in Turkey]

In a two-day conference on hate speech and hate crime organized by Medialog (a platform under Journalist and Writers Foundation) in İstanbul, leading journalists and academics urged the government to draft a law against defamation, blasphemy and discrimination while protecting the freedom of expression.

Gülen’s lawyer: Doctored tapes part of plans to finish off Hizmet movement

Nurullah Albayrak, the lawyer of Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, released several recorded phone conversations of his client on Wednesday, saying they were illegally wiretapped in violation of individuals’ privacy and that some politicians are using them as an instrument in their shady plan to finish off the Hizmet movement.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Turkish scholar Fethullah Gulen awarded in South Korea

Woman detained along with 40-day-old baby while visiting jailed husband

Bangladeshi professor published his second book on Fethullah Gulen

An NBA Center Faces Imprisonment And Possible Execution In Turkey

Fethullah Gülen’s Statement of Condolences and Condemnation for Manhattan Terrorist Attack

Iranian gold stars in Turkish corruption scandal

Deputy PM says image of gov’t-Hizmet fight ugly

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News