Who is Behind the Pennsylvania Protests?

Aydoğan Vatandaş
Aydoğan Vatandaş


Date posted: February 18, 2014

 

AYDOGAN VATANDAS

The most important message the Gezi protests gave was the message that the Erdogan’s government lost its credibility in the eyes of some sections of the society.

Although some of the members of the government took this message, Erdogan himself, interpreted this protest as an coup attempt against himself and turned it into a matter of existence. While he called the protestors as “looters” he also called them as pawns of foreign powers who doesn’t want Turkey to grow.

When we look at Erdogan’s speeches since December 17, it is clear to see that he already passed a level of suspicion about Cemaat (aka Hizmet) and accuses Hizmet for every development that troubles him including the Gezi protests.

Still, such a position should not have been the cause of such a paranoid thinking that the Hizmet was behind the protests. Such protests happen all over the world and governments try to wreck such protests using their intelligence agencies and psychological warfare tools and black propaganda is amongst them. For example, there has been a resemblance between the protests in Brazil and Turkey. The protestors’ initial legitimate requests has later been abused by some provocative groups and protestors’ legitimate requests has been sabotaged by such groups.

The same thing happened in Turkey. The innocent protests that have started as an environmental cause have later been sabotaged with the involvement of illegal organizations in an attempt to illegitimatize the protests against the government. Some of the arguments that have been used to illegitimatize the protests were that “protestors consumed alcohol inside a mosque” and that “protestors attacked a women wearing hijab”.

(…)

I consider a few protests that took place in Pennsylvania in the same category. As known, Fethullah Gulen had suggested that the protestors should be listened to and not be treated harshly. This was an expression to show that the people’s voice and requests at Gezi should not be rejected. At the same time, Oray Egin’s comments, who supported the protestors in Pennsylvania only at an ‘intellectual level’, (he found these protests as timeless, pointless, nonintellectual, and the greatest secular fiasco of the history of protests) indicate that there is no relationship between the protests in Gezi and Pennsylvania.

Even when the reports of the USA based newspaper called Posta212, which reflected the spirit of the Gezi protests, are studied carefully it is clear to see that the Pennsylvania protestors doesn’t meet with Gezi protestors in the same perspective.

That is, it is obvious that the motivations of the Pennsylvania protestors are not parallel to the ones at Gezi as claimed and involves discrepancies.

The common opinion of the Turkish American society is that the Erdogan’s government is behind the Pennsylvania protests. The goal behind this attempt is to prevent the journalists who write in the pro-Hizmet media from providing intellectual support to the Gezi protests. It may also have been to give Hizmet followers to create the impression that the Gezi protests are also against the Hizmet movement. However, it seems like this is not the only goal behind the Pennsylvania protests. “Timing is meaningful”.

May be a coincidence but whenever there was a call to motivate people to protest [in Pennsylvania] those were the times when Erdogan’s anger was at its peak. There is a famous saying American’s use: “if it looks quacks like a duck then it is a duck”.

If Erdogan’s AK Party government is managing such protests in a country like America and it gets caught by the FBI the severe consequences this might bring must be considered.

Original article written by Aydogan Vatandas on Samanyoluhaber.com on 02/17/2014 and translated into English by Ugur Tezcan.

Source: TurkeyObserved.com , February 18, 2014


Related News

‘Nigeria Moving Towards Peaceful, Happy Future’

Notwithstanding the series of conflicts in various parts of the country, there is a high hope that Nigeria is heading towards peace and a brighter future, Initiator of Hizmet Movement and foremost Turkey-based scholar, M. Fethullah Gulen, has declared. He disclosed this in a message to the Ufuk Dialogue’s 5th Dialogue and Peace Awards Ceremony, […]

A Different Kind of Coup? Why You Should Care About A “Reclusive” Turkish Imam in Pennsylvania

We should consider not only what people say about Fethullah Gülen, but what he says himself. Decades of speeches and publications make this possible and reveal certain attributes. For example, Gülen advocates a form of Sufi humanism. He seeks collaborative relationships across religious, cultural, and national borders. He is concerned about the poor and marginalized around the world.

AK Party’s power poisoning

The AK Party is still committed to making its identity dominant and transforming the state; its attempt to eliminate the Hizmet movement from the bureaucracy and the judiciary without relying on any legal evidence is a good sign of this.

Swoboda accuses Erdoğan of using Hizmet movement as a pretext

Socialist leader Hannes Swoboda asked “You were still supporting the Hizmet movement a year ago. Now you use the movement as an excuse for halting reforms. Why do you see them as a danger to Turkey now?”
Sources said Swoboda made it very clear that the EU was very concerned about the state of the rule of law in Turkey. “We are very concerned about the rule of law and the separation of powers, especially the independence of the judiciary,” he stressed.

Introducing the Gulen Movement: Prophet’s Path in the Twenty-first Century

Muzaffar K. Awan, M.D. The Prophet’s path being practiced and demonstrated by Hizmet global movement is certainly one of the best ways to minimize and eliminate ignorance through worldwide education, to narrowing the gap between the rich and poor again through education and charitable works. The wealth of the earth will have to be eventually […]

‘Hizmet is the attempt to celebrate all of humanity’

Hizmet Movement is unique because it doesn’t try to carry out what we call cultural and religious particularism. That would be the idea that your group is the best, that you have the only form of truth, that all other groups are impure, incorrect and that they are not worthy of time, or that they’re not worthy of learning something from them. Hizmet, in fact, says the opposite. Members reach out to learn from other peoples, they actively invite people from different cultural backgrounds, people from different religious backgrounds to come and teach them, to teach them things.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

An Exiled Cleric Denies Playing a Leading Role in Coup Attempt

Gülen’s teachings discussed this time in New York

Morocco and Turkish schools

Turkey Faces Its Iran 1979 Moment

Erdogan’s Changing Aspirations for Somalia

“Time to Help” launched in England

We would like to increase the number of Turkish schools

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News