Shutting down prep schools against free enterprise, analysts say

A classroom in a prep school in eastern Turkish province of Kars. (Photo: Cihan, Abdülkadir Erzeneoğlu)
A classroom in a prep school in eastern Turkish province of Kars. (Photo: Cihan, Abdülkadir Erzeneoğlu)

Date posted: November 21, 2013


The government’s decision to close down prep schools, institutes known as dershanes that help Turkish students prepare for standardized high school and college entrance exams, is not a step in line with the freedom of enterprise in a democratic society, analysts have said.

“It’s not possible to make out of this behavior befitting a government that defends a market economy,” Seyfettin Gürsel, director of Bahçeşehir University’s Center for Economic and Social Research (BETAM), told Today’s Zaman.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan confirmed on Wednesday the government’s earlier announcement that it is working on legislation to shut down all existing prep schools, arguing that they operate as a parallel education system.

According to Gürsel, who described the government’s initiative to abolish the dershane system as “very wrong,” if there is a demand for a certain service, then it is natural that initiatives to meet the demand will also be there in a market economy. “If you really think prep schools are unnecessary, then you need to enact reforms that will eliminate demand for them,” Gürsel stated.

Although preparatory schools in Turkey have played an important role in the education system for the past 30 years or so, the government has announced that all prep schools will be shut down at the end of the next school year. Prep schools can serve instead, the government said, as private schools in the future.

Members of nongovernmental organizations headed by the Association of Democracy Inspectors gathered in İstanbul on Wednesday.

“As it is not possible to close down private hospitals in Turkey, prep schools should also be respected,” İbrahim Yayla, a member of the board of the association, said in a public statement delivered in Taksim Square. Noting that public schools cannot equitably provide quality education to all students, prep schools fill in for the deficiency of the state, he underlined.

The government’s plan to ban private tutoring institutions that train students for high school and university entrance exams has divided society and led to fear among some segments of the public that socioeconomic differences may further affect students’ academic achievement after the closure. Many parents who cannot afford to send their children to private schools will face difficulties if the government continues with its plan to transform prep schools into private schools.

In an article that appeared in the Yeni Şafak daily on Thursday, Atilla Yayla, a political scientist teaching at İstanbul University of Commerce, opposed the government’s move to close down prep schools, saying, “It is against freedom of enterprise to close down prep schools.”

In the article, titled “Why it’s wrong to close dershanes,” Yayla also underlined that such a step would be against the very foundations of a freedom-based political system. “In political and legal systems based on freedoms, individuals, either singly or in collaboration with others, can engage in economic activities,” he said.

According to figures from the Ministry of Education, there are 3,858 prep schools in Turkey and they are attended by 2,207,000 students. Out of the 739,000 students who are seniors in high school, and therefore preparing for the university entrance exam, 550,000 attend prep schools.

If the government goes ahead with its plan and prep schools are abolished, then private schools may also have additional financial difficulties. The government said 20 percent of all prep schools in Turkey have the financial means, while at the same time fulfilling requirements, to immediately start serving as a private school. But given that private schools currently in service already suffer from a lack of students — capacity-use in private schools being no more than 52 percent — should some of the prep schools also be transformed into private schools, demand is sure to fall much shorter than the supply side in education.

Opponents of the government’s plan have also noted that the prep schools are a consequence of the many inadequacies of Turkey’s schools and education system, and said that by offering tutoring at affordable prices, prep schools help low-income students enter university.

Cengiz Aktar, who heads Bahçeşehir University’s European Union affairs program, also believes it is not possible to abolish prep schools without first carrying out a complete overhaul of the Turkish education system. Maintaining that this is a decision taken without much deliberation, Aktar told Today’s Zaman that “this would serve to further deteriorate the quality of education in Turkey.”

European Parliament (EP) sources also voiced concern, saying that if Parliament passes the law that would close the dershanes in its current form, it could have repercussions in the European Commission’s next progress report on Turkey.

In a recent statement to Today’s Zaman, an EP source said, on the condition of anonymity, that it was difficult to grasp the debate and stressed that dershanes were a product of Turkey’s education system.

In his article, Yayla also cautioned that abolishing prep schools would serve to make the state even more bulky, to the detriment of civil society. “Closing prep schools would aggrandize the state and make statism grow,” said Yayla, maintaining that such a step would come to mean taking a stance against civil society, attempting to eliminate some elements of the civil society.

Ayhan Kaya, director of the European Institute at Bilgi University in İstanbul, does not expect that the education system would get any better when prep schools are abolished. “This is a decision made on political and ideological grounds,” Kaya told Today’s Zaman.

On Tuesday, the Anatolian Union of Prep Schools Platform released a joint statement expressing the sector’s concerns. The statement said prep schools are not the cause but a consequence of the problems in Turkey’s education system, while emphasizing that prep schools give low-income students an affordable opportunity to keep up with children of well-to-do families who attend private schools or have access to one-on-one private tuition. The closure of prep schools is a violation of free enterprise, the right to education, the right to work and the right to self-improvement, the statement said.

Source: Today's Zaman , November 21, 2013

Related News

Human Rights Watch: People being tortured, abducted in post-coup Turkey

People detained after the last year’s failed putsch have been subject to torture in police custody while several others were abducted outside detention facilities, according to a recent report by the Human Rights Watch. The New York-based watchdog documented human rights abuses occurred between March and August 2017 in its 43-page report, “In Custody: Police Torture and Abductions in Turkey.”

Ugandan FA Minister: Turkish schools paved the way for Turkey to reach out to Africa

Ugandan Foreign Affairs Minister Asuman Kiyingi said Turkish schools have paved the way for Turkey to reach out to Africa. “I would like to note that especially the Turkish schools underpin the outreach,” he said. The minister Kiyingi shared that they regard the local Turkish schools as the most significant investments Turkey has made in Uganda and that they offer an admirable service in moral education besides their academic achievements.

Police and inspectors raid Gülen-inspired schools in Çanakkale

In yet another government-orchestrated operation targeting the faith-based Gülen movement, popularly known as the Hizmet movement, police officers and inspectors from several ministries and institutions conducted raids at schools established by volunteers of the movement early on Wednesday in the northwestern city of Çanakkale.

Mothers, fathers crying and praying due to extensive victimization

Mothers cried out and made objections wherever state brutality was observed. This noble and peaceful attitude was not only displayed at the education institutions affiliated with the Hizmet movement.

Germany investigates possible anti-Gulen spies

German police have raided apartments of four men suspected of carrying out espionage on behalf of the Turkish government. The men, said to be clerics, are accused of spying on supporters of cleric Fethullah Gulen.

Gülen appeals for steadfastness against gov’t ban on prep schools [in Turkey]

Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has asked his followers to be resolute and not yield to despair in the face of a government attempt to shut down private educational institutions [in Turkey] that assist students to prepare for high school and university admission examinations, which was interpreted as a major blow to the right to an education and to free enterprise in the EU-candidate country.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

U.S.-based Turkish cleric says used as scapegoat in graft scandal

Turkey’s Coup Provides Reichstag Fire Moment for Authoritarian Erdogan

Ivory Coast authorities call on Kimse Yok Mu for more aid

Egyptian Professor: Turkish Schools to Guarantee Global Peace

The genesis of the hatred against Gulen and the Hizmet Movement

3 detained Turkish educators and their families handed over to Turkey by Gabon

Now, speaking Turco-Tweetish is more challenging

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News