Hizmet movement and military coups

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: April 19, 2012

İHSAN YILMAZ, Wednesday April 18, 2012

With the democratization of Turkey and the new mentality of the judiciary it has created, prosecutors can now tackle past coup attempts and successful coups, the most recent being the Feb. 28, 1997 coup process. I call it a “process” since the toppling of former Prime Minister Necmettin Erbakan’s government was not a result of a sudden abrupt direct military takeover. Instead it was a long period of psychological warfare. There was a consent manufacturing campaign coupled with direct coup threats.

A few days ago, the most prominent leader of the Feb 28 coup, retired General Çevik Bir, was arrested. This has resulted in a panic among the coup’s supporters. In order to hide what they did in the past, they argue that the Hizmet Movement also supported the coup and sided with the generals against the Erbakan government. This is a distortion. It is not the first time, nor will it be the last time these media personalities resort to such distortions as they know very well that sometimes these distortions may be swallowed by some sections of society.

The second item of the Feb. 28 National Security Council decision was the order that private schools of the so-called reactionary forces and religious communities must be taken over by the state. Anyone knowledgeable about this period of Turkish history knows the main target was the Hizmet schools. That is why Fethullah Gülen declared that if the schools are seen as danger he would advise their owners to hand the schools over to the state.

Moreover, the media elite’s well-known motto is to “never underestimate the power of denial.” Thus, while they powerfully deny that they were organically linked to the military junta they also blame the victims and targets of the coup as the real perpetrators of the coup. Even this single skillful act of distortion suggests their lack of innocence but let us leave the verdict on this issue to the courts and focus on their arguments.

First of all, it is well known and crystal clear that Hizmet was one of the primary targets of the Feb. 28 coup. The second item of the Feb. 28 National Security Council decision was the order that private schools of the so-called reactionary forces and religious communities must be taken over by the state. Anyone knowledgeable about this period of Turkish history knows the main target was the Hizmet schools. That is why Fethullah Gülen declared that if the schools are seen as danger he would advise their owners to hand the schools over to the state.

The idea was applauded by the Hürriyet daily’s editor in chief at the time Ertuğrul Özkök and he penned a column on the issue. In several interviews, Gülen was asked about the issue. In short, Hizmet was one of the targets of the coup and being an intelligent man, Gülen knew this well before the Feb. 28 process began. For instance, the Radikal daily’s İsmet Berkan accused Gülen of being “hyper-sensitive” about a coup threat in a June 1999 column. Berkan also writes that Gülen warned against a coup in a 1995 meeting with journalists but it did not come true. Unfortunately for democracy, instead of focusing on these warnings and the probability of a coup, Berkan asked how Gülen got such information. This shows the reflexes and loyalty of our media towards anti-democratic developments. Since 1993, when the journalist Uğur Mumcu was assassinated and then president Turgut Özal died, Gülen was aware of the coup threats and he did whatever he could do to prevent them. Politicians, including some Welfare Party (RP) members did not take him seriously and were manipulated by the coup-loving media. Thus, it is illogical to claim that Gülen has sided with the coup against the Erbakan government.

Gülen was actually trying to prevent the worst. When Necmettin Erbakan signed the Feb. 28 decision instead of resigning, and challenging the coup by having new elections, there was not much that could be done by the weak civilian actors vis-à-vis the almighty state.

It must not also be forgotten that in addition to the big media groups such as Doğan and Bilgin, major “civil” society organizations and trade unions such as Turkish Industry and Business Association (TUSİAD), Turkish Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges (TOBB), Confederation of Turkish Trade Unions (TÜRK-İŞ), Confederation of Progressive Trade Unions (DİSK), Turkish Confederation of Employers’ Unions (TİSK), Turkish Tradesmen’s and Artisans’ Confederation (TESK), etc. strongly supported the military and the 1997 coup.

Seeing that he was unable to prevent the coming coup, Gülen tried to contain the damage. Instead of challenging and provoking the military, he tried to argue that civilians may make mistakes and military officers might feel that they have a responsibility (he was simply referring to the de facto facts), but coups could be more damaging.

If some of the sentences in his interviews are not picked and chosen but his interviews are analyzed in their entirety, it is seen that in very difficult and challenging times, he was still trying to make his case for democracy despite the coup-loving generals, media, business tycoons, trade union leaders, politicians, civil society institutions and terrible mistakes of the RP politicians. Actually, it is these mistakes that paved the way for the self-criticism of today’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) leaders and the emergence of the AKP. Today, everybody claims to be a champion of democracy and defender of freedoms but in those difficult days, with the exception of a few good men in the media and civil society, the majority of the power elite either openly supported the coup or they remained silent.

Source: Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist-277901-hizmet-movement-and-military-coups.html


Related News

President of Zambia Mr. Rupiah Banda thanks Turkish investors in education

President Banda said he had been to Turkey twice and was impressed with the country’s standards of education and that is why he had requested Turkish partners to come to Zambia and work with the Government in the pursuit of quality education. Mr. Rupiah Banda has advised the Ministry of Education to pay serious attention […]

Turkish school in Romania moves to new building

Spectrum Turkish School in Yas city of Romania moved to its new building on Tuesday with a ceremony. Turkish schools which have been operating in Romania for 21 years continue to develop. The school which has a capacity of 500 students gained new building.

‘Selam: Bahara Yolculuk’: a true story on the big screen

ALİ KOCA / ISTANBUL The 2013 Turkish movie “selam” (Greeting) told the stories of volunteers who embraced humanity outside Turkey’s borders; it was a movie that was appreciated not for its cinematic qualities, but for the sake of the beloved memories of those pioneers who went to territories they knew very little about to open […]

Gülen’s lawyer: Pro-government media ignores ruling of Supreme Court of Appeals

Nurullah Albayrak, the lawyer representing Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, said in a written statement on Monday that pro-government media outlets continue their false accusations about Gülen and members of the Gülen movement, pointing out that Gülen was acquitted in June 2008 of all allegations that had been leveled against him at that time.

GYV gathers politicians, diplomats at iftar dinner in Turkish capital

“Ramadan is a time of compassion and mercy. In these blessed days, when patience and tolerance prevail, we once more remember love, peace, modesty, cooperation and living for others,” Gülen’s message said.

Turkish schools

About 15 years ago, I attended an international academic conference in a state located within the former Soviet geography. These conferences give us the chance to make on-the-spot observations about changes around the world. There were two Turkish high schools in the city: a state school, run by the Turkish Republic under bilateral agreements, and a private school run by Turkish entrepreneurs inspired by the ideas of well-respected Turkish-Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen. I visited both and talked to students and teachers.

Latest News

That is Why the Turkish Government could Pay 1 Billion Euros

ECtHR rules Bulgaria violated rights of Turkish journalist who was deported despite seeking asylum

Fethullah Gülen’s Message of Condolences in the Wake of the Western European Floods

Pregnant woman kept in prison for 4 months over Gülen links despite regulations

Normalization of Abduction, Torture, and Death in Erdogan’s Turkey

Turkey’s Maarif Foundation illegally seized German-run school in Ethiopia, says manager

Failed 2016 coup was gov’t plot to purge Gülenists from state bodies, journalist claims

Grondahl: Turkish community strong in wake of threats from back home

Turkish-Kyrgyz educator’s abduction shows Ankara’s ruthless disregard for law: HRW

In Case You Missed It

Turkish medical group goes to Tanzania with largest medical personnel team

“ISIS — A terrorist group making false representation of Islam,” says Turkish Muslim scholar Fethullah Gülen

Discrimination by AKP government [against Hizmet movement]

Erdoğan’s harsh, xenophobic rhetoric damages fight against Islamophobia

Eid-al-Adha – Neighborhood Generosity

Cleric Accused Of Plotting Turkish Coup Attempt: ‘I Have Stood Against All Coups’

Secretary Tillerson: Evidence against Gulen provided by Turkey inadequate, while voluminous

Copyright 2021 Hizmet News