The last of the ‘LASTmen’ and the new constitution

Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz
Dr. Ihsan Yilmaz


Date posted: March 14, 2012

Dr. Ihsan YILMAZ, 14 March 2012

One of the most hotly debated topics of the last Abant Platform was the Directorate of Religious Affairs. There are many sides to the issue. Those who do not care about religion call for the Directorate of Religious Affairs’ total abolishment. Some advocate maintaining the status quo. I understand the Kemalists who are happy with the 1982 Constitution and do not want any change to the Kemalist Constitution. However, some religious people’s staunch advocacy of the status quo requires explanation.

The Kemalists’ ideal model is encapsulated by the acronym LAST, which is similar to WASP (White Anglo Saxon Protestant). LAST stands for Laicist, Atatürkist, Sunni, Turk. Laicist does not mean a secular minded person, it refers to a person who is aggressively secularist and is not pleased with public manifestations of Islam even though he does not care much about other religions’ public visibility. To be a first class citizen one needs to be Sunni and an ethnic Turk. All others outside of these four parameters are not fully trusted by the Kemalists and their state. Non-Muslims, practicing Muslims, non-Atatürkists such as leftists and liberals, Alevis and Kurds have always been discriminated against by the Kemalist state whenever these identities become manifest in the public sphere.

The Directorate of Religious Affairs is a remarkable example of strange Kemalist laicism. While on the one hand the Kemalists argue that religion and state issues must be separated, on the other hand they want the state to fully control Islam. The Directorate of Religious Affairs was created on the same day the chief of the General Staff of the military was. This constitutional state institution employs more than 80,000 imams. In Turkey, religious congregations, brotherhoods and communities are not allowed to have “civilian” imams. Until very recently the text for the Friday sermons was written in Ankara, and all the imams in Turkey had to read the very same text. Research has shown that these texts often referred to “love of the country” more than they referred to “love of God.”

The Kemalists’ ideal model is encapsulated by the acronym LAST, which is similar to WASP (White Anglo Saxon Protestant). LAST stands for Laicist, Atatürkist, Sunni, Turk. Laicist does not mean a secular minded person, it refers to a person who is aggressively secularist and is not pleased with public manifestations of Islam even though he does not care much about other religions’ public visibility. Atatürkism is a softer version of Kemalism and as long as you love Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, deeply respect him and do not think he made mistakes, you are considered an Atatürkist. You do not have to be a proactive and ideologically minded Kemalist. To be a first class citizen one needs to be Sunni and an ethnic Turk. All others outside of these four parameters are not fully trusted by the Kemalists and their state. Non-Muslims, practicing Muslims, non-Atatürkists such as leftists and liberals, Alevis and Kurds have always been discriminated against by the Kemalist state whenever these identities become manifest in the public sphere. If you were a “LASTman” or hid your real identity you would be tolerated to a certain extent. The state has worked hard to socially engineer these perfect citizens.

Kemalists have tried to create a certain version of Turkish Islam that I will call “Lausannian Islam.” Lausanne refers to the Lausanne Treaty signed by Turkey and the victors of World War I. It is in a way the founding document of the modern Turkish state. By using this term I do not only underline the fact that the Kemalists tried to create a version of Islam within Turkey as defined by the Lausanne Treaty, I also want to imply that by deferring to the spirit of the Lausanne Treaty, this Turkish version of Islam jettisoned Islam’s transnational dimensions, ranging from an understanding of universal religious brotherhood of the Ummah to having a symbolic caliphate for all Muslims. Lausannian Islam did not care about interreligious dialogue until Fethullah Gülen and the Hizmet movement took the initiative in this area. Lausannian Islam envisaged a Muslim type that was statist, Turkish nationalist and Atatürkist. A good Lausannian Muslim is one who does not have any transnational cultural aspirations, who believes the state, not the ulema [Islamic scholars] or the Sufis, knows best about religion. A Lausannian Muslim practices his religion either privately in his home or in a mosque, but not in the public sphere.

The Directorate of Religious Affairs was an instrument used to create Lausannian Muslims. However, because the overwhelming majority of its staff is not Kemalist, they have resisted Kemalist desires to a great extent. The Directorate of Religious Affairs has of course evolved over time, but it has remained part of the state. It is better to have an independent and civilian Directorate of Religious Affairs. The Justice and Development Party (AK Party) rule will not last for 1,000 years, so imagine what could happen to the Directorate of Religious Affairs if the Republican People’s Party (CHP) comes to power.

I believe that we are all children of “Kemalistan” and we are all “Kemals” in one form or other. Our latent identities are Kemalist, even though our manifest identities may be liberal, leftist, religious or so on. Some practicing Muslims’ staunch defense of the current constitutional position of the Directorate of Religious Affairs reflects that the borders between these identities are fluid. In some rare cases religious Kemals even act and think like “LASTmen”, showing the success of the Kemalist indoctrination.

Source: Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist-274316-the-last-of-the-lastmen-and-the-new-constitution.html

 


Related News

Islamists lost test with power, Arab and Turkish intellectuals agree

Gathering in İstanbul at a meeting organized by Turkish Review and Hira magazine, Arab and Turkish intellectuals have discussed the role of the state in Muslim societies and agreed that Islamist politicians have lost their test with power, as they were transformed by the state instead of transforming the state.

Top court annuls controversial law on prep school closure

Turkey’s Constitutional Court has annulled a controversial law seeking to close down dershanes, or private preparatory schools, in a landmark ruling that will influence the lives and futures of millions of students, parents and teachers across the country.

Government as a black propaganda machine

In an effort to distract public opinion from the graft probe and the alleged involvement of the prime minister and his inner circle in corruption, Erdoğan has been conducting psychological warfare. Considering the Hizmet movement responsible as the force behind the investigation, Erdoğan declared the movement an enemy.

Police raid prominent journalists’ foundation GYV in Turkey

GYV’s members strongly protested the police measure. Underlining that the raid violated standard protocol, high-ranking GYV official Recep Usta expressed; “the protocol states that VGM technical teams can come to the building and conduct examinations; and should they find any violation, a period of a month is granted to us [to fix any issues].

Parallel state hunt makes McCarthyism look like child’s play

For the last year not a single day has passed without hearing these infamous words: parallel state. These were present in almost every speech made by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan. They have been in the headlines everyday in every single newspaper close to the government.

Interview with Henri Barkey on the Hizmet Movement

Henri Barkey, who has been one of the leading Turkey analysts in Washington, joined journalist Ruşen Çakır’s live broadcast via Periscope. He made interesting comments about the claims of the “parallel structure,” the situation of Fethullah Gülen in the US, and the appointment of trustees to the Zaman daily.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Diverging points between AKP and Hizmet movement: Kurdish question

Formerly Gülen-linked schools in Albania face growing gov’t pressure

Education in Mother Tongue: Eventual Solution to the Problem

Turkish FM calls on Gülen Movement for dialogue to find way out political crisis

Refugee helps refugees

A Catholic Priest’s Letter to Fethullah Gülen

Turks in US Ditto: Dialogue

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News