Gulen Movement’s Global Appeal: Reflections from Chicago

Kadri Gursel
Kadri Gursel


Date posted: November 30, 2010

Kadri Gürsel

Yesterday, in the column I talked about the 12.000 “ashuras” in Chicago by the supporters of the Gulen Movement. Ashura, called Noah’s Pudding in English, is said to represent “living together in peace”. Chickpeas, bean, wheat, and some dried fruits are among the ingredients of Ashura that creates a mixed taste. But while doing this they manage to keep their identities.

In United States, it is easy to be Ashura as the founding values make it possible for a mixed taste to occur. Whereas in Turkey, the clash of the values make it hard for these tastes to share the same pot.

Let’s go back to those who served Ashura in the States. The assistant general manager of the Gulen Movement’s most powerful association Niagara Foundation Hakan Berberoglu said among the places they served Ashura, were colleges, churches, and even the FBI’s division in Chicago. He also said 3.500 of the 12.000 Ashuras were served there in the FBI building. It’s the FBI, (Federal Bureau of Investigation) USA’s federal police…

It’s not an everyday happening for someone to serve Ashura in the FBI building. Especially after the 9/11, a Muslim association must build really good relations and gain great deal of trust to be able to do this. Obviously Niagara Foundation managed it. The fact that FBI’s chief officer in Chicago Robert D. Grant gave a speech in the foundation approximately three years ago shows this trust. We all know that Gulen’s supporters would like to build good relations with the authority wherever they go. I respect this if they explain their Ashura serving to the FBI, as a fruit of this will. What I’m really into it is the impression Ashura left in the minds of the FBI officers.

There’s said to be 100.000 Muslims living in Chicago and if there’s any terrorists between them FBI’s one of the most critical missions is finding and neutralizing them. So we can assume that they have this “Muslim Terrorist image” somewhere in their mind.

And as Hakan Berberoglu puts it, Gulen’s supporters, no matter where it is in the USA, appear not only in front of FBI but also all the authorities, not as terrorists but as Muslims with good images who are in interaction with every walk of life. Their messages and actions are in accordance with this appearance. They talk about tolerance, peace and dialogue and the emphasis they place on education and commerce in their actions is easy to be seen. Moreover they are not anti-Americans. So their image being just the opposite of the “Muslim Terrorist” in FBI officers’ mind shouldn’t come as a surprise.

Therefore, we can assume that, this positive image appeared in the mind of FBI’s Chicago officers is reflected on the Washington D.C.’s big picture and this image is constituting an antidote against  USA’s global issue of “Islamic extremism”. This is the global domino effect started by just a glass of Ashura served in FBI’s Chicago Office.

It also shouldn’t come as a surprise that Gulen Movement is seen by some circles in USA as a rational answer within Islam to all the problems encountered because of the Islamic extremism from violence to all others.

At the Gulen Conference in Chicago this positive perception was expressed in various aspects. Speakers, mostly Americans, were the ones studying Gulen Movement for a long time.

I’m concluding the column by quoting the ones that i find interesting to give you an idea about the perception I’ve mentioned above;

“Carter Findley (Ohio University): In the 21st century, the Gulen Movement may manage to make the impact Gandhi made in the 20th century.

Jeremy Walton (New York State University): It is a post-modern socio-politic movement and after all they have no intention to impress the state.

Greg Barton (Monash University, Australia) Among all the international movements the Gulen Movement is the only one that is proggresivist. The others are Islamists and Islamic cause-centered.

Jon Pahl (Theologian, Temple University): Gulen’s pragmatic mystysism is serving the purpose of global peace.”

Source: Original article was published by Milliyet daily on November 29, 2010 http://www.milliyet.com.tr/gulen-hareketi-nin-kuresel-cazibesi/kadri-gursel/dunya/yazardetay/29.11.2010/1319792/default.htm

 


Related News

Texas Senate passes resolution commending Fethullah Gülen

ALİ H. ASLAN, WASHINGTON The senate of the US state of Texas on Tuesday passed a resolution commending respected Turkish scholar Fethullah Gülen for his contributions to the promotion of global peace and understanding. Senate Resolution No. 85, which was approved during Tuesday’s session chaired by Texas Lt. Governor David Dewhurst, said, “The Senate of […]

GYV organized peace conference at United Nation

Speaking at the conference, GYV Secretary-General Hüseyin Hurmalı said that the GYV has been working voluntarily both in the US and across the globe to establish peace and dialogue. “We have tried to eliminate prejudices and wrong ideas about Turkey, we know that it is important for Turkey to enter into a process of peace and development,” Hurmalı added.

Leaked emails reveal Erdoğan’s son-in-law’s team fabricated news against Gülen in US

An email included in Wikileaks’ Monday publication of the leaked emails of Berat Albayrak, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s son-in-law and Turkey’s minister of energy, shows that Albayrak fabricated news with pro-government people in the United States in order to defame the Gülen movement in the US media.

Fethullah Gülen: An Islamic sign of hope for an inclusive Europe

Thus Gülen and the initiatives inspired by his teaching challenge the tendency found among some Muslims groups to separatist withdrawal from the wider non-Muslim society. By contrast, they offer a basis for Muslim engagement with the wider society based upon a confident and richly textured Islamic vision.

Interview about Hizmet Movment at Maxwell School of Syracuse University

Tosca Bruno-Van Vijfeijken, Director of  Transnational NGO Initiative at Maxwell School of Syracuse University inteviewd Dr. Alp Aslandogan, President of the Alliance for Shared Values. This interview took place before Dr. Aslandogan’s lecture at Maxwell School on Hizmet Movement on September 22, 2015.

Report: White House denies remarks attributed to Obama about Gülen

White House has reportedly denied remarks attributed to US President Barack Obama about Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, describing them as “not accurate.” Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said on Thursday during a live TV interview that Obama received “the message” about his complaint of Gülen residing in the US.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

In redemption days hoping for better

New Constitution should have no barriers to mother tongue education

Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right

Gülen files criminal complaint over illegal wiretapping

Turkish doctors hailed for their assistance in CAR

Dutch minister gives Turkish deputy a lesson on freedoms

Senior AK Party member admits profiling of citizens in government, private sector

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News