Erdoğan and AK Party deputies split over hate speech against Hizmet


Date posted: March 15, 2014

ANKARA

Apparently, not every Justice and Development Party (AK Party) member and minister is on board with Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s hateful and insulting rhetoric against the Hizmet movement and Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen and his followers.

Speaking on a TV program last week, Erdoğan complained that AK Party deputies are keeping a low profile in the row with the movement and Gülen, and not adopting a harsh stance or using the same insulting language as the prime minister — epithets like evil, assassins, traitors, viruses, mafia and parallel structure. Erdoğan claimed that deputies and some ministers have refrained from voicing fierce criticism against both Gülen and the movement because they don’t want to offend certain segments of society, adding that he expected AK Party deputies and ministers to tow the line and push his message.

During the same program, Erdoğan reprehended journalist Mustafa Karaalioğlu for not calling the movement “the organization” when he asked Erdoğan a question on the issue. “Why are you afraid of calling them ‘the organization’? Do not use ‘cemaat’ [movement] again in your definition of them.” Stunned by Erdoğan’s outburst, Karaalioğlu then used the word “formation” instead of cemaat, but this term also failed to satisfy Erdoğan, who interrupted Karaalioğlu and insisted he use the word “organization,” adding, “Cemaat is reserved for those who work for the benefit of the country.”

The intentions behind Erdoğan’s aggressive stance against the Hizmet movement are being questioned, with many analysts claiming his rhetoric is part of a wider strategy of stifling a graft investigation that went public on Dec. 17 when police conducted an operation against prominent businesspeople, officials and the sons of several ministers suspected of bribery and corruption. Veteran journalist Nazlı Ilıcak has said that Erdoğan aims to deflect attention from the corruption scandal with his insulting discourse, while AK Party deputies and the party’s rank and file are more careful with their words, suggesting that many party members aren’t buying into the “parallel state” and “traitor” rhetoric deployed by Erdoğan and members of his inner circle.

Ilıcak, noting that her friends have told her of a negative atmosphere within the ruling party, said AK Party deputies are uneasy about and disturbed by Erdoğan’s hate speech against the cemaat and Gülen. Pointing to the local elections, she said, “Most of the deputies and several ministers disagree with accusations by Erdoğan against the faith-based movement — like anyone who has a conscience — but they are eying the result of the municipal elections to be held on March 30. They have some concerns regarding re-election, so some of them are remaining silent despite the fact that they disagree with Erdoğan’s insulting language. There are also some segments within the AK Party that have considered themselves deeply loyal to the movement for years, since the AK Party did not exist 12 years ago, unlike the cemaat. If the poll goes poorly for the AK Party and its votes fall visibly, then dissidents’ voices will be heard loud and clear against Erdoğan’s smear campaign against the Hizmet movement.”

Former Culture and Tourism Minister Ertuğrul Günay, who resigned in late December 2013 after the government failed to come up with a satisfying response to the graft allegations and moved to protect the ministers implicated, said that Erdoğan’s remarks cannot be explained in a rational way, as the prime minister is waging a defamation campaign against the Cemaat instead of making arguments founded on facts.

Criticizing the hate speech Erdoğan has used in his endless smear campaign, Günay accused the prime minister of making a concerted effort to agitate enmity and hatred in society, saying, “No one who has a bit of conscience can claim that the current hate speech is appropriate. We observe an endless disrespect in Erdoğan’s words against Gülen and the Hizmet movement, with whom he once worked together for a common cause. No more than a year ago he sent his close associates to pay court to Gülen, who serves his country, while the prime minister is now directing unconscionable hate speech against the cleric and the Hizmet movement. This approach hurts people’s feelings. As for the AK Party deputies, they do not use the same vitriolic language as Erdoğan and prefer to remain silent in the face of the smear campaign. But they should object to Erdoğan’s insulting remarks. They should not endure his onslaught. These deputies are also aware of the provoking nature of these words. They do not agree with Erdoğan’s accusations against Gülen and his followers. Those who support Gülen are our friends and brothers. We have contact in daily social life with these people and cannot afford to be on bad terms. One should be ashamed of using this offensive and ‘othering’ language against those who are not expected to vote for his [Erdoğan’s] party in the upcoming elections.”

Former AK Party deputy İdris Bal, who resigned from the AK Party ahead of the corruption probe, accused the AK Party and Erdoğan of evolving an authoritarian approach, considering Erdoğan’s recent moves against the Hizmet as the part of efforts to assume absolute control over civil society in accordance with his political aspirations.

Offering a different perspective on Erdoğan’s hate speech against the Hizmet movement, Bal said the graft probe turned out to be a litmus test for the prime minister’s vision for Turkey — a test he failed by dynamiting social peace with his hateful attacks on a certain segment of society. “Erdoğan should decide whether he wants a Turkey that is like Lebanon, where sectarian, political and ethnic discrimination split the country, or not. In democratic societies, civil society, nongovernmental organizations and faith-based groups may wish to participate in politics and decision-making in order to cure politicians’ blindness to society’s demands. Ignoring civil society groups indicates the pursuit of an authoritarian regime,” Bal said.

Regarding the rift in the AK Party over Erdoğan’s hate speech, Bal said, “All political party members should determine their own priorities in accordance with the expectations of society. They should look into whether corruption, terror, illegal and unlawful activities, smuggling and bribery dominate the Hizmet movement. If there are no such signs, then they would be better off questioning what their leader says. AK Party deputies recognize that Erdoğan’s speech is full of derogatory and denigrating remarks, and consider it unethical and illegal. They also acknowledge that demonizing certain segments of society is unconstitutional. … But they are still worried about their political future, and that is why they remain silent in spite of the fact that they do not share Erdoğan’s insulting stance. They must be more courageous.”

 

Source: Todays Zaman , March 15, 2014


Related News

Did they make mistake?

We are experiencing a period of turmoil in which we strongly need the supremacy of law, the presumption of innocence and the individuality of criminal offenses. A grave campaign instead is being carried out to insult and denigrate millions of people. Why would the Hizmet movement consider forming a parallel state within the state given that its members hold no intention other than Allah’s will? Considering that democratic options are available for seeking positions within the state, why would people within the bureaucracy strive for greater political power?

Turkish authorities withdraw license of station linked to PM Erdogan’s opponents

Fatih Karaca, head of the media unit of Ipek group of companies, said Thursday Turkey’s radio and television watchdog revoked the license of KanalTurk television, citing a 2010 court decision. He maintained that the decision against the station — which is linked to a movement led by U.S.-based moderate Islamic cleric Fethullah Gulen — was “politically-motivated.”

Erdogan’s diplomats have become ‘Gulenist-busters’

A diplomat told me that there was no way he would do what Tayyip Erdogan was asking him to do. It was against everything he held dear: chasing one’s own citizens without any credible evidence. Soon, many diplomats who refused to turn into Gulenist-hunters were not promoted, demoted or, worse, expelled from the ministry.

Prominent businessman Akın İpek pledges huge support to Kimse Yok Mu

A huge support campaign has grown to back Kimse Yok Mu after the recent Cabinet decree which banned the charity’s ability to accept public donations without government approval. Koza İpek Holding Chairman Akın İpek has donated 1000 animals for Eid al-Adha, the Feast of the Sacrifice.

Pro-government Yeni Şafak daily fires critical columnist

Pro-government newspaper Yeni Şafak has fired journalist Osman Özsoy after the columnist hinted government pressure on the newspaper to let him go on his Twitter account on Monday.

Turkey’s harsh new reality: the gateway to Jihad Central

The capture of notorious Australian Islamic State recruiter Neil Prakash highlights an uncomfortable new reality for Turkey: it has become the gateway to Jihad Central.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

What’s Friendship Got to Do With [Mr. Gulen’s] Extradition?

Laughter-guaranteed terrorist organization indictment

Prof. Leo Lefebure on Fethullah Gulen and Gulen Movement

Division at home, cooperation abroad

Sarıgül’s first election promise: to protect İstanbul’s historic skyline

Erdogan’s vendetta against moderate Muslims threatens Turkey’s role in War on Terror

Turkish schools in Azerbaijan join SOCAR-financed int’l education complex

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News