Conspiracy theory par excellence [against Gülen movement]

Şahin Alpay
Şahin Alpay

Date posted: January 5, 2014


I woke up to the fact that conspiracy theories were poisoning the minds of many at home in Turkey and elsewhere, in the process of settling accounts in the latter half of the 1970s with the Marxist paradigm that had captured my mind and distorted much of what I was looking at in reality.

My humble struggle against conspiracy theories in Turkey began soon after returning home from a long stay in Sweden as a political refugee engaged in graduate studies. As a first step, in 1982 I translated into Turkish the great philosopher of science Karl R. Popper’s essay “Prediction and prophecy in the social sciences,” which to my mind laid bare the nature of conspiracy theories. Ever since, that is, for over 30 years, I have often had to write and talk against such theories.

Going through my archive the other day I discovered some of the earliest columns I wrote on the topic. This was what I wrote in a column titled “External enemies, internal enemies…”: “I sometimes get the impression that we as a society have fallen victim to national paranoia, to irrational fears due to a mental disorder. Those who believe that our most burning problems are created by foreign enemies and their agents at home who aim to dismember Turkey, to destroy our state or at least render it weak and decrepit are so very widespread… According to many all that is bad and evil in Turkey is due to the designs of either ‘the communist states and their local agents,’ or of ‘imperialists and their lackeys…’ or of Zionists, or Christian missionaries…” (Cumhuriyet, Nov. 27, 1991).

I tried to explain, in reference to Popper, that conspiracy theories are a consequence of the secularization of religious beliefs; that human beings first explained everything by the work of God, which was later replaced by laws of nature and history; that conspiracy theories are the most primitive form of the secularization of religious beliefs which hold capitalists, imperialists, communists, fascists, freemasons, Zionists, etc., responsible for all that happens in the world; that conspiracy theories conflict with social science, which seeks to identify the causes of social phenomena by the study of the unintended consequences of intended social action. I argued that theories which explain all that happens by the conspiracies of a single all-powerful actor poison our minds and prevent us from making an objective assessment of what we see happening.

Mine and others’ warnings against the dangers of conspiracy theories seem to have failed entirely. Today in Turkey, a new version of the conspiracy theory is embraced by a broad spectrum of people, including not only Islamist or secular fundamentalists but also people you would normally expect to be sensible. That broad spectrum of people appears to be convinced that Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, who has advanced an interpretation of Islam in line with liberal modernity, and the faith-based social movement he has inspired, is to be blamed for all wrongdoing and crime that is going on in Turkey.

According to this conspiracy theory par excellence, it is the followers of Gülen in the judiciary and the police who have, with forged evidence, jailed those charged for engaging in military coup plots, fabricated the judicial cases against those prosecuted for being Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) members, attempted to arrest the chief of the national intelligence service to undermine the peace process with the PKK, used illegally shot sex tapes to discredit politicians, wiretapped tens of thousands of people, concocted the case against a sports club president sentenced to jail for match-fixing, laid (as part of a global conspiracy involving the US and Israel) a trap to topple the Recep Tayyip Erdoğan government with the recent corruption probe, murdered three PKK women activists in Paris, tried to stop the truck carrying, on orders of the national intelligence service, supplies for Turkmens in Syria, etc., etc.

Many happily subscribe to this “theory” due to their secular fundamentalist or Islamist prejudices, but those who market it definitely find it a convenient tool for covering up much wrongdoing and crime.

Source: Today's Zaman , January 5, 2014

Related News

The real issue is the National Security Council [in Turkey]

A recent report by the Taraf daily indicating that the National Security Council (MGK) had formed a plan to destroy the Gülen movement has sparked discussions. This is only natural, considering that the current political administration is known for its adherence to religious values. This report is huge news because the government failed to oppose the military in the MGK meeting.

Fatih University graduates receive Feb. 28-like treatment at İstanbul University

Some graduates of the İstanbul-based Fatih University, affiliated with the faith-based Hizmet movement, have become the latest victims of the battle launched by the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government against the movement, as they have been subjected to apparent discrimination during post-graduate interviews at state-run İstanbul University, reminiscent of the days of the Feb. 28 military coup.

Teacher gets arrested, wife suffers miscarriage amid gov’t crackdown on Gülen movement

A letter sent Turkey Purge has received from the elder brother –known by the initials A.D.– of an arrested school teacher reveals that those detained within past few years as part of the witch-hunt have been subjected to many kinds of ill-treatment under custody.

American reporters got an intriguing glimpse into the political mind-set in Turkey

Turkish leaders said they were astonished that they had so far been unsuccessful in persuading the United States Justice Department to even ask a federal judge to extradite Fethullah Gulen. The Turkish government said it had provided the United States with extensive proof against Mr. Gulen, who has denied involvement. But Turkish officials refused in several interviews to publicize a single piece of that evidence.

Pro-gov’t daily proudly announces Gulenists put in ‘concentration camp’

Gulenists under custody as part of an investigation into Turkey’s July 15 coup attempt are kept in a “concentration camp” near Kayseri province, pro-gov’t Turkish news portal Kayseri Haber reported on Aug 13.

Operation against whom?

A claim made this past weekend by Hüseyin Gülerce, a senior columnist for the Zaman daily, affiliated with the Gülen (Hizmet) movement, increased tensions in Ankara when he suggested that a major operation will be carried out by the government against the Gülen movement, which it believes to be behind the graft investigation.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Kimse Yok Mu volunteer physicians bring light to eyes in Darfur

Hospital to be opened by volunteer Turkish doctors in Ethiopia

Kamel Daoud: Open letter to Erdogan – You’re not welcome in Algeria

How Erdogan is covering up the corruption scandal

Fetullah Gülen, the preferred enemy – Interview

Gülen has strongly rejected comparison to Iran’s Khomeini time and again

Bias about Gulen Movement in light of The Economist column

Copyright 2023 Hizmet News