More Divisions, More Democracy


Date posted: December 11, 2013

Mustafa Aky0l

Foreign journalists writing about Turkey like to focus on the most fundamental divide in Turkish society: the rift between religious conservatives and secularists. But these days an internal clash is raging among the conservatives themselves. And it could be a boon for Turkish democracy.

On one side are the supporters of the prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who is enjoying his 11th year in power and facing increasing criticism for his authoritarian style of rule. On the other side, there are the supporters of Fethullah Gulen, an Islamic scholar and preacher who now lives in Pennsylvania, and whose teachings have inspired Turkey’s most powerful civil society group.

Until a few years ago, Mr. Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (known as the A.K.P.) and the Gulen Movement, as it is often called, were very close allies. They had a common enemy: the staunchly secular military, which menaced both religious conservatives and democracy itself, having staged or threatened many coups. Many of Turkey’s secular liberals had joined this alliance, hoping that the taming of the military would take Turkey closer to European-style liberal democracy.

However, once the military was subdued in 2010-11 — partly through controversial legal cases in which hundreds of officers were sentenced to long prison terms — this alliance of Erdogan supporters, followers of Mr. Gulen and liberals began falling apart. Gradually, most liberals withdrew their support from Mr. Erdogan, arguing that he had begun imitating the authoritarian habits of his predecessors.

At the same time, differences between the A.K.P. and the Gulen Movement began to surface.

The Gulen Movement, though it is pious and unmistakably Muslim, has always steered clear of Islamist ideology. Unlike the Islamists, who constitute an influential strain within the A.K.P., Mr. Gulen’s followers have always valued Turkey’s relations with the West, championed accession to the European Union, and have been friendly toward Jews and Christians. In return, some paranoid Turkish Islamists (and even some secular nationalists) have accused Mr. Gulen of being a “C.I.A. agent.”

But there is another, more complicated layer. The Gulen Movement is known to have many members within Turkey’s judiciary and police force. Many believe this “state within a state” began to act hawkishly against its opponents, including secular generals, certain journalists and Kurdish separatists, leading to many controversial arrests.

These tensions peaked in February 2012, when an Istanbul prosecutor summoned Hakan Fidan, the head of Turkey’s intelligence agency, to question him about his covert negotiations with Kurdish militants. Since Mr. Fidan is a high-level confidant of Mr. Erdogan and has tried to broker a peace with the militants on Mr. Erdogan’s orders, the prime minister perceived the prosecutor’s move as a personal attack. He hastily passed a law that gave immunity to Mr. Fidan, and trained his sights on the Gulen Movement, which he believed was behind the attack on Mr. Fidan.

Mr. Erdogan then initiated a purge within the police and the judiciary, demoting suspected members of the Gulen Movement. Last month, the clash escalated when the prime minister announced that private weekend schools that prepare high school students for national university admission tests would be shut down. The Gulen Movement operates many of these schools, which are both a source of revenue and recruits. “By closing these schools,” a prominent Gulen follower told me, “Erdogan wants to dry our grass roots.”

The political fallout could be significant. Mr. Erdogan has lost the formerly unwavering support of the Gulen Movement, whose voting power is estimated to make up about 2 to 5 percent of Turkey’s electorate. There will be consequences in the coming local elections, and the presidential elections of June 2014. Although all other religious groups seem loyal to Mr. Erdogan, the lack of pro-Gulen votes could tip the balance in favor of other candidates.

It is beneficial for Turkish democracy that not all religious conservatives are united under one banner. Thanks to the A.K.P.-Gulen rift, Turkish media is today more diverse, as pro-Gulen newspapers like Zaman and television stations are offering a third way between Mr. Erdogan’s supporters and his diehard opponents.

The Turkish state has encroached far too much on the rights of the media, universities, NGOs and the lives of ordinary citizens. It has become a leviathan that must be tamed. If Turkey is lucky, this rift might help bring the country to a democratic equilibrium where the prerogative of the state and the rights of civil society and the individual can be properly balanced.

Mustafa Akyol is the author of “Islam Without Extremes: A Muslim Case for Liberty.”

Source: The New York Times , December 11, 2013


Related News

The Gülen Movement and Turkish Soft Power*

The Gülen approach to education aptly demonstrates the group’s global strategy—Gülen movement schools are open to both Turkish migrants and citizens of host countries, and they avoid advancing a religious agenda. These schools aim to help Turkish migrants succeed in their host societies without losing sight of their Turkish roots, and at the same time they promote social unity by serving the needs of migrants and local students alike. The success of Gülen movement schools stems both from the success of the students (and the satisfaction of the parents) and from the prestige and goodwill they enjoy among local and political authorities for promoting integration and acting as a social mediator.

Turkey’s Erdogan and onslaughts against opposition

Gulen movement, which is inspired by the highly-respected United States based cleric, Fethullah Gulen, has been brazenly targeted for total destruction by President Erdogan after the failed coup in that country few months ago. The iron-hand President accused members and sympathisers of the movement as being behind the coup.

Hizmet-affiliated schools removed from private school incentive list

The Hizmet schools were in the original list of those institutions which met all the criteria for eligibility to receive financial incentives to accept these students. Announced on Monday, the schools were listed on the ministry’s website until Thursday afternoon, when they were taken off without any explanation. However, an official written notice sent from the ministry to governorates on Thursday said: “It was not deemed proper to give such incentives to education institutions whose managers are under fiscal investigation and interrogation within the scope of the Law No. 5549 on the Prevention of Laundering of Crime Revenues and those that had received punishments fiscal irregularities after due inspections before,” and asked the governorates do what the notice requires.

Keep Incirlik, Extradite Gülen?

A true ally would not try to obstruct the international campaign against the Islamic State for the sake of a leader’s personal vendetta. To acquiesce to the extradition [of Fethullah Gulen] would be to signal that it’s open season to blackmail the United States.

Fethullah Gulen’s message to the “Ijma” symposium

Fethullah Gulen sent a message to the symposium entitled “Ijma as a Common Roadmap and Collective Awareness” which took place on April 27-28 in Istanbul. Gulen’s message received a standing ovation in the hall that a large number of guests crowded into. In the message, read aloud at the symposium in presence of a large number […]

Overwhelming public response in support of Bank Asya

Solidarity campaigns against the Banking Regulation Supervision Agency’s (BDDK) decision to have the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (TMSF) temporarily take over the management of Bank Asya have been springing up across the nation.

Latest News

Turkish inmate jailed over alleged Gülen links dies of heart attack in prison

Message of Condemnation and Condolences for Mass Shooting at Bondi Beach, Sydney

Media executive Hidayet Karaca marks 11th year in prison over alleged links to Gülen movement

ECtHR faults Turkey for convictions of 2,420 applicants over Gülen links in follow-up to 2023 judgment

New Book Exposes Erdoğan’s “Civil Death Project” Targeting the Hizmet Movement

European Human Rights Treaty Faces Legal And Political Tests

ECtHR rejects Turkey’s appeal, clearing path for retrials in Gülen-linked cases

Erdoğan’s Civil Death Project’ : The ‘politicide’ spanning more than a decade

Fethullah Gülen’s Vision and the Purpose of Hizmet

In Case You Missed It

Pakistan submits to Turkey’s ‘authoritarian demands’ on Gulen

Fethullah Gulen Denies Coup Involvement

Toward an Islamic enlightenment

Turkey’s efforts in Somalia

‘I like the vitality of the participation and the vitality of hospitality within the Hizmet Movement’

34,000 teachers, 5,882 academics, 1,372 university employees dismissed since July 15, 2016

Spy agency planning false-flag terror acts in crowded areas, whistleblower claims

Copyright 2026 Hizmet News