European Muslims Want Participation, Not Integration: Role of the Gulen Movement


Date posted: May 11, 2012

A conference hosted by the Catholic Academy in Stuttgart together with two associations of the Gülen movement (aka Hizmet movement) in Baden-Württemberg, “Süddialog” and “Begegnungen”, focused on Christian and Islamic initiatives in cooperative public welfare efforts. The story gives clues about Gulen movement’s role in Muslim’s integration and participation in Germany.

While German politicians continue to argue whether Islam is part of Germany or not, German Muslims have for quite some time been making a contribution in many social spheres. But many institutions in Germany are still at the beginning of a process of intercultural opening. Claudia Mende reports

The political debate in Germany has masked the fact that Muslims have long been participating in many social spheres. They have been insisting on more participation in communities, schools, and social welfare institutions. A new generation of young and well-educated Muslims is confidently raising the issues that affect their community, just like their Christian and secular co-citizens.
fethullah-gulen-14A conference hosted by the Catholic Academy in Stuttgart together with two associations of the Gülen movement in Baden-Württemberg, “Süddialog” and “Begegnungen”, focused on Christian and Islamic initiatives in cooperative public welfare efforts.

In recent years, the Catholic Academy in Stuttgart has gained a reputation for promoting constructive and open dialogue with Muslims. The participation of the “Süddialog” and “Begegnungen” associations marked the first time an event was held with representatives of the Gülen movement. The movement, founded by the US-based Turkish intellectual Fethullah Gülen, remains controversial, yet it has primarily concentrated on the issues of education and dialogue.

Everyday local problems are at issue

“The Muslim basis is very open to engage in dialogue. There is great interest among Muslims, even young Muslims,” says Jürgen Meyer, chairman of the coordination committee of the Christian-Islamic Dialogue association. “It is not politics that moves us forward, but rather local interests.”

What are at issue are everyday local problems. First generation immigrants are getting older and issues such as healthcare and support of the elderly are becoming key concerns. Families require counselling on education and support in a school system in which children’s success is increasingly dependent on initiative by their parents. According to a study entitled “Islamic Community Life in Germany”, published in April by the Centre for Turkish Studies, Islamic mosque communities and Alevite communities in Germany offer a great variety of social services in addition to their religious activities.

The study, commissioned by the Islam Conference, provides for the first time country-wide statistics on the internal lives of Muslim communities in Germany. It asserts that over 40 percent of Muslim communities offer their members social and educational counselling and more than half of them provide students with tutoring assistance. Around 36 percent of mosque communities also offer health care counselling for the faithful. The vast majority of these social activities are carried out by volunteers.

German Muslims and Christian welfare organisations

Until now, Muslims have hardly built up any institutional structures in the social sphere. Yet, social welfare needs will continue to grow in the future, stresses Havva Engin from the Heidelberg University of Education.

Even when old-age homes and care facilities for the elderly remain unimaginable for many traditional Muslims, the support and care outside of the family for elderly Islamic migrants will be a pressing concern in the coming years. It is a certainty that there well be a need for more hospices catering to the special requirements of Muslims. Such social services must be run professionally and can no longer be properly provided by volunteers.
eurepean-muslims-2The Christian welfare organizations Caritas and Diakonie carry out their social work in the areas of child day care, counselling, and old-age homes and care facilities with regular financing by the state. Such funding has not applied in the case of social work for Muslims.

Havva Engin envisages either the establishment of an independent Muslim social welfare association or that the Caritas and Diakonie Christian social welfare associations will have to include greater Muslim participation in their structures. The Central Committee of Muslims in Germany has already demanded an Islamic social welfare association. The Christian associations are still only at the beginning of a process of intercultural opening.

Caritas and Diakonie have indeed discovered the issue and their services are available to everyone regardless of denomination or religion. In this respect, they have currently begun intercultural training courses for some of their staff. Workers are taught how to better deal with interreligious concerns. Intercultural opening, however, requires much more. Immigrants must be included as staff members in these organizations and this entails that they will also help in determining their long-term future direction. This demand was also recently raised by the Baden-Württemberg Integration Minister Bilkay Öney (SPD).

It is difficult imagining Caritas implementing such moves. To date, there have been individual Muslims active with Caritas in the area of elderly care, for instance. But the intention of the Caritas association is to restrict this to a case-by-case basis at the federal level. A wider opening would mean a change in official Church regulations, and that is currently not open for debate.

Individual Caritas associations at the diocese level are much more open in this respect. The diocese of Rottenburg-Stuttgart has seriously discussed the issue in light of the rising number of qualified Muslims in the field.

Committed to educational improvement

Muslims are also increasingly raising their concerns within the educational system. It is therefore not surprising that so far no new school models for Muslims have originated from the state system.

eurepean-muslims-3

The example of the Prisma schools in the Swabian city of Böblingen shows how immigrants are capable of creating a framework for the educational success of their children. The motivating factor has been a sober assessment of state schools and their own experience with discrimination.

A non-profit association close to the Gülen movement has established two private full-day schools here, in which religion does not play a role. The upper secondary school and the high school are open to students of all denominations and religions. They are focused on educational performance and offer a state-of-the-art educational programme.

Instead of religious instruction, only ethics courses are offered at the Prisma schools. In accordance with the theories of Fethullah Gülen, education is what is important, not religious instruction. Ismail Temel from the school board of trustees tells of his own experiences with discrimination when he went to school. He wants to spare his children from any similar misfortune. In addition, the board wants to do something for problem children in the district and is offering a scholarship for poor families. “What we want is not integration, but participation,” stresses Temel.

Interreligious opening of society

“The Gülen movement has brought a fresh wind to the situation in Germany,” is also the assessment of Jürgen Meyer. The movement is not directly linked to mosque associations and is primarily committed to educational improvement. Members of the Gülen movement are well-educated, have a good income, and are seriously involved in the movement’s projects.

Now German society at large is slowly coming to embrace plurality. For the 2012/13 school year, the Catholic school board in the Osnabrück diocese will open a so-called “three religion school”. The Ditib State Association of Lower Saxony, the Schura of Lower Saxony (the umbrella group of mosque associations in the state), and the Jewish Community of Osnabrück have all cooperated with the Catholic Church in order to realize the project.

In this first “three religion school” in Germany, Muslim teachers will be allowed to wear a headscarf and Jewish religion instructors can wear a Kippah. “The school is a shining example of religious coexistence in Osnabrück,” says Winfried Verbung of the Osnabrück diocese confidently. The school will be a significant contribution to the interreligious opening of society.

Claudia Mende © Qantara.de 2012

Translated from the German by John Bergeron

Editor: Lewis Gropp/Qantara.de

Source: Qantara.de May 11, 2012 http://en.qantara.de/We-Want-Participation-Not-Integration/19062c20064i0p9/

Photo credits: Qantara.de


Related News

My Nominee for the Nobel Peace Prize is Fethullah Gulen

Fehmi Koru, Houston, Texas 15 October 2005 I do not have a voting right for Nobel nominations, but if I did, my nomination for the peace prize is ready: Fethullah Gulen. Of course, I know he’s controversial even in Turkey, he doesn’t appear in public anymore, he seldom grants interviews, yet nevertheless many in Turkey […]

The Gulen Movement Is Not a Cult — It’s One of the Most Encouraging Faces of Islam Today

How will it end? Erdogan has beaten Hizmet decisively. But he is planting the seeds for his own destruction. How and when he will fall remains unclear. Meanwhile, on the international scene, Turkey is rapidly becoming a pariah. The country itself is now his primary victim.

Former Norwegian PM: Our center takes same approach as Gülen

KADİR UYSALOĞLU, OSLO Former Norwegian Prime Minister Kjell Magne Bondevik has said the ideas of Fethullah Gülen, a Turkish-Muslim scholar, and the activities of his movement are in complete harmony with the approach of The Oslo Center for Peace and Human Rights, which Bondevik currently heads. Bondevik yesterday paid a visit to the En Verden i […]

Turkish Civil society groups: Lack of hate crimes legislation hurts citizens

Some 60 civil society groups have come together in a campaign to demand legislation to deal with hate crimes in Turkey. Although such crimes have reached unprecedented levels, with numerous incidents of murders and assaults motivated by prejudice and hostility toward an individual or a group, they commonly go unpunished. The campaign to introduce hate […]

Fethullah Gülen extends condolences over death of Turkish literary giant

Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen has extended his condolences to the family and fans of Yaşar Kemal, one of Turkey’s greatest writers, whose works were translated into 40 languages.

Profiled lawyer files criminal complaint against MİT, MGK

Taraf began publishing a string of confidential documents suggesting that the Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government and MİT had collected information on a large number of individuals through 2013 at the request of the MGK. The targets were reportedly members of the Hizmet movement, a faith-based community inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen.

Latest News

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

University refuses admission to woman jailed over Gülen links

In Case You Missed It

Police raid business association in Malatya in new government-backed operation

Governor’s office rejects Kimse Yok Mu’s application for aid campaign

Unaffected by tension, TUSKON promotes Turkish economy

Gülen discounts neither past nor modernity

Texans experience Turkish culture by volunteering

President Museveni supports Turkey’s reaching out to Africa

When paths part…

Copyright 2022 Hizmet News