Lawyers, academics say ‘parallel state’ was invented to block graft probe


Date posted: February 7, 2014

İSTANBUL

Lawyers and academics, in a manifesto released on Thursday, say the concept of a “parallel state” was invented by the government to cover up the major corruption scandal which erupted on Dec. 17, implicating various businessmen and government officials, stating that this concept is being used by the government to place the blame for the unlawful acts on the Hizmet movement.

A total of 150 academics signed the manifesto, titled “Rule of law suspended.” The manifesto says the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK Party) government cannot ignore the corruption allegations just by making up claims of a “parallel state” — which has no meaning in political science or law — and placing the blame on the Hizmet movement, which is inspired by Turkish Islamic scholar Fethullah Gülen, for its unlawful practices.

The statement stressed that the reassignments of thousands of public servants and the worrisome attempts to curb the separation of powers through the judiciary have damaged Turkey’s respect for the principles of the law and security and have broken ties between the law and legitimacy.

Speaking with Today’s Zaman on the manifesto, signatory Ümit Kardaş, a retired colonel and former military judge, said he doesn’t find the government’s argument of a parallel state convincing. “Was this so-called ‘parallel state’ recognized only after Dec. 17 [when the corruption scandal was made public]? If it was really a parallel state, why did the government fail to recognize it before? If it is indeed a parallel state, what steps has the AK Party taken towards the [so-called] parallel structure in the last two months [since it put forward the argument for the first time]? There is the National Intelligence Organization [MİT]. You should have revealed this structure before this,” Kardaş noted.

Commenting on the defamatory expressions used against the Hizmet movement, such as “parallel state,” “gang,” “virus,” “secret organization” and even “Hashashin” — a shadowy historic group that carried out politically motivated assassinations during the time of the Seljuk Empire, Kardaş said targeting the movement without any concrete evidence is not acceptable at all, adding that some of expressions used by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan against the movement can be considered hate speech. “Using hate speech can polarize the public. Politicians should adopt a more moderate and sensitive language.”

Kardaş said the ruling party is trying to make its base believe arguments such as there is a conspiracy or plot being conducted against the government but Kardaş believes a majority of the public see such arguments as attempts to block the ongoing corruption investigation.

Also speaking to Today’s Zaman, Ergin Cinmen, a lawyer known for his activism in improving democracy in Turkey, said the parallel state is an invented concept. Pointing to the words of Erdoğan who defined the period after the corruption scandal as Turkey’s second “Independence War,” Cinmen said these words are very serious and desperate, adding that the prime minister is indirectly saying Turkey has entered a state of emergency.

Pointing to the local elections to be held on March 30, Cinmen said he believes the Gezi Park protests which erupted late in May of 2013 over the government’s plan to demolish Gezi Park in İstanbul’s Taksim district and the developments that have happened since Dec. 17 will affect the results of the local elections.

Another signatory, Professor Gencay Gürsoy, read the manifesto on behalf of the academics on Thursday. He said Turkey has been going through an emergency period in which the rule of law has been suspended.

Pointing to the reassignments of thousands of police officers and many prosecutors and judges after the corruption scandal, Gürsoy stated: “Some law enforcement forces refused to obey court orders and the orders of prosecutors conducting the bribery and corruption investigation. Furthermore, some judicial officials conducting the investigation were removed. The prime minister tried to legitimize this serious situation using the argument that Turkey is staging yet another struggle for independence,” asking the government if a coup was indeed being conducted as it claims, would it be contented with just changing the positions of those civil servants?

Gürsoy said if there is truly a parallel state in Turkey, why hasn’t the government launched a criminal investigation against this structure.

He says defining this situation as a “war of independence” means the judiciary can be suspended if it is deemed necessary, adding that Turkish history includes many examples of emergency periods which created an unlawful environment in the country.

Source: Todays Zaman , February 7, 2014


Related News

No measures taken against ‘parallel structure’ at top security meeting: General Staff

The Turkish General Staff has dismissed reports that measures against the “parallel structure” – the government’s code word for the movement of erstwhile ally Fethullah Gülen – in the army have been taken during a National Security Council (MGK) meeting on April 30.

Gulen wants Anatolian [interpretation of] Islam

What does Gulen say? He says: “Work hard and earn money, but be honest. Allah will reward your hard work and honesty. But do not squander that reward. Turn it into an investment and help others.” It sounds a lot like the Protestant work ethic. This is the underlying vision of capitalism. The Gulen Movement looks a lot like the Ottoman-era Ahi movement. It is a kind of a solidarity group that provides people with jobs, education, and reintegration into society.

Police chiefs removed in four provinces across Turkey

The purges are thought to be an attempt to remove those the government believes are members of the Hizmet movement from public sector jobs.

‘Parallel’ paranoia reaches the kitchen of Parliament

In the latest example of the Justice and Development Party’s (AK Party) “parallel” paranoia, the ruling party’s Sinop deputy and head of the Parliamentary Interior Affairs Commission, Mehmet Ersoy, ordered restaurant officials in Parliament to remove a dish called “samanyolu kebap” as it reminds him of institutions affiliated with the “parallel structure,” a daily reported on Monday.

Teacher arrested after repairman found Gülen’s audio CD in computer

A Samsun teacher, identified as Osman K., was detained after a repairman found in his computer a CD that features speeches by Fethullah Gulen. The audio CD, titled Kalbin Miraci, featured faith-based sermons Gulen delivered at mosques in Turkey in the past.

Central bank data disprove interior minister’s rigging claims

Ala’s remarks were widely interpreted as a reference to Bank Asya, a participation bank affiliated with the Hizmet movement, which the government has tried to scapegoat through conspiracy theories to evade corruption allegations. Some news stories broke soon after Ala’s claims, reporting that Bank Asya’s accounts were being scrutinized for misconduct.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Gülen extends condolences to Egypt victims

Turkish gov’t pays cash rewards for arrest or death of Gülen supporters

BBC interviews families of abducted Gülen followers

Turkish Canadian institute presents peace and dialogue awards

Kimse Yok Mu offers cataract surgery to 2,000 Nepalese

Fil-Turkish gives out beef amid terror threats

Amnesty: Civil society under massive crackdown in Turkey, Gülen movement main target

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News