An instructive crisis

Etyen Mahçupyan
Etyen Mahçupyan


Date posted: February 23, 2012

The links revealed between the National Intelligence Organization (MİT) and the Kurdish Communities Union (KCK), which have been maintained by MİT to embrace Kurdish politics and blur the line between legal and illegal activities, were not surprising to anybody because, in terms of its personnel, MİT is still a military organization.

ETYEN MAHÇUPYAN, Thursday February 23, 2012

The government has replaced the top administrators in MİT to make sure that a hierarchy would emerge. However, it shouldn’t be all that surprising that a large portion of the organization displays a nationalist stance through its extra-institutional ties. At a time when the military had to back down and there was an initiative by independent units to distance themselves from nationalism in the judiciary and the police, it was already expected that circles within MİT would lead the way in neo-nationalist policies.

A number of commentators have argued that the Gülen movement was involved in this incident. All periods of political transformation create vacuums of power and opportunities within the bureaucracy. It is natural for members of the Gülen movement to use these opportunities for their careers and values. However, it does not follow that the Gülen movement would attempt to undermine the government through the MİT investigation while the neo-nationalists and the PKK were on one side of this disagreement.

On the other hand, the biggest clash in Turkey is still between the AKP and the status quo forces that seek to topple it. However, there is no chance for a military coup and it is not reasonable or realistic to expect the AKP to be defeated through elections. Therefore, a simple option has gained support and attention: the only thing that will ensure that the AKP is overthrown is its mistakes. One topic that leaves plenty of room for mistakes is the Kurdish issue because, in this case, the government needs the support of the bureaucracy. This puts the civilian administration in a delicate position wherein it could be deceived. The murder of 34 smugglers has raised suspicions that their killing was a deliberate move. These suspicions showed that the government is pretty dependent on the bureaucracy.

Uludere was a test of the government’s ability to stand tall in face of a shocking move; the government failed the test. Administrative measures to address the fallout of the incident were not taken in a timely manner, no proper political position was adopted and the government failed to address questions from the public. This experience made other similar moves that seek to undermine the government seem more realistic and doable. The Uludere incident paved the way for an investigation of top-level MİT administrators and executives, including MİT Undersecretary Hakan Fidan, former Undersecretary Emre Taner and three other MİT officers. However, while the link between MİT and the KCK deserves attention and a thorough investigation, it is not sufficient to focus on the top executives alone and skip the mid-level authorities. Besides, the prosecutor’s decision to take action without informing his superiors was not the normal practice. Furthermore, it is impossible to believe that the prosecutor and judge were unaware that they their decision to act without informing their superiors was a fairly political move.

It was obvious that this was a political move because all of the suspects in this investigation are the same people who held talks in Oslo with the PKK. However, it would be incorrect to conclude that those who initiated the MİT investigation wanted to make sure that there would not be further talks with the PKK. The actual goal of the MİT investigation was to undermine the image of the AKP government at its weakest and most vulnerable spot and make sure that MİT would return to a neo-nationalist discourse.

A number of commentators have argued that the Gülen movement was involved in this incident. All periods of political transformation create vacuums of power and opportunities within the bureaucracy. It is natural for members of the Gülen movement to use these opportunities for their careers and values. However, it does not follow that the Gülen movement would attempt to undermine the government through the MİT investigation while the neo-nationalists and the PKK were on one side of this disagreement. On the other hand, it is natural that the movement would ask for the links between the KCK and MİT to be exposed.

In the end, all parties learned their lessons in this crisis. Most probably, the Gülen movement realized that it has to maintain its responsibility before the public. Other than that, the crisis showed that the movement could be manipulated. The government realized how vulnerable the mistakes committed in Uludere made its administration. But apparently the AKP would not stop there. An effort introduced by the Undersecretariat of Public Order and Security to restrict freedom of expression during times of counterterrorism shows that they intend to pursue issues relating to terror further. A meeting with Işıl Karakaş — a judge who represents Turkey at the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and arrived in Ankara last week on the invitation of the Turkish Undersecretary of Public Security and Order — was held last week to discuss the views and principles of the court. We should also note the comprehensive report drafted by the presidential State Control Board as it relates to the Hrant Dink murder. The report says that Dink was murdered due to negligence on the part of relevant actors in different positions and further recommends reopening the investigation. All these occurrences demonstrate that the recent crisis offers an opportunity for the government to take bold steps towards further reform and that the government is willing to use this opportunity.

Source: Today’s Zaman http://www.todayszaman.com/columnist-272329-an-instructive-crisis.html


Related News

Turkey’s Coup Provides Reichstag Fire Moment for Authoritarian Erdogan

Unfortunately, the botched coup is likely to act like the infamous Reichstag fire under the Nazis and accelerate the Erdogan government’s race to the dictatorial bottom. He is likely to become more vindictive and paranoid—because he does have enemies everywhere. Never mind that he bears responsibility for the authoritarian policies and corrupt practices which have energized his most fervent opponents.

Judiciary acts in line with legally unfounded police report to describe Hizmet as terrorist

A National Police Department report accusing the Gülen movement of being a terrorist organization without any solid evidence is being treated as a document not to be questioned by the judiciary, which apparently views it as an “instruction” by higher-ups, recent investigations have indicated.

Lessons from Dec. 17: Who is parallel?

To prove whether the Gülen movement has a parallel structure , one has to establish that the investigations and wiretappings were not conducted within the scope of a legal investigation. If that is proven, one has to demonstrate that the police and prosecutors in charge of the investigations were receiving instructions not from the state but from sources within the movement. Both of these claims have to be proven with evidence.

Minister Şahin praises Journalists and Writers Foundation for courageous coverage

SEZAİ KALAYCI, NEW YORK Family and Social Policy Minister Fatma Şahin has praised the Journalists and Writers Foundation (GYV) for its members’ courageous coverage of important issues at a time when the country is taking steps for democratization. Şahin’s remarks came during a panel discussion on women’s issues held by the GYV and Peace Islands […]

Yet another woman detained due to Gülen links shortly after delivery

Teacher Esra Demir was detained on Monday, a day after giving birth in Batman, as part of a witch-hunt targeting the Gülen movement, news website tr724 reported.

Turkish School Leader Abducted, and Released, in Mongolia

Mr. Ganbat, the Mongolian general director of the Empathy foundation, which runs the Mongolia-Turkish schools, said the Mongolian police told him that the vehicle had a fake license plate and that three masked people were inside.

Latest News

Fethullah Gulen – man of education, peace and dialogue – passes away

Fethullah Gülen’s Condolence Message for South African Human Rights Defender Archbishop Desmond Tutu

Hizmet Movement Declares Core Values with Unified Voice

Ankara systematically tortures supporters of Gülen movement, Kurds, Turkey Tribunal rapporteurs say

Erdogan possessed by Pharaoh, Herod, Hitler spirits?

Devious Use of International Organizations to Persecute Dissidents Abroad: The Erdogan Case

A “Controlled Coup”: Erdogan’s Contribution to the Autocrats’ Playbook

Why is Turkey’s Erdogan persecuting the Gulen movement?

Purge-victim man sent back to prison over Gulen links despite stage 4 cancer diagnosis

In Case You Missed It

Gulen`s Interview with the German Newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung

Malian Medical Students: Ramadan feels different this year

Police, inspectors raid Gülen-inspired schools in Manisa for 3rd time

Prep school transformation plan violates Constitution, experts say

Gülen movement offers real alternative to clashes and conflict in society

TUSKON’s Turkish-Filipino Initiatives to Open New Trade Doors

Gov’t keeps purging, dozens of police officials across Turkey have been removed

Copyright 2025 Hizmet News