Panel Discussion – The Gulen Schools In Central Asia

Kazakh President Nazarbayev visits a Kazakh-Turkish High School
Kazakh President Nazarbayev visits a Kazakh-Turkish High School


Date posted: August 13, 2016

Bruce Pannier

The events in mid-July in Turkey, events Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan called an attempted coup, have had implications on Turkey’s relations with many countries. Erdogan blames Fethullah Gulen, a cleric living in self-exile in the United States, for being the mastermind behind the alleged plot to overthrow his government.

After the Turkish government reestablished itself in power and started rounding up suspected participants and leaders, Ankara called on countries where Gulen-sponsored schools had opened to close down those schools. Among the countries the Turkish government called on to shut down these “Gulen schools” were Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, Ankara’s partners in the Cooperation Council of Turkic-Speaking States.

But the governments of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan did not comply.

To look at the reasons these two countries declined to acquiesce to Ankara’s call, and review the difference of opinion among the Central Asian states as regards the Gulen schools, RFE/RL’s communications office arranged a Majlis, a panel discussion.

Moderating the talk was RFE/RL Media Relations Manager Muhammad Tahir. From Bishkek, Emil Joroev, professor at the American University of Central Asia, joined the discussion. Alan DeYoung from the University of Kentucky in Lexington, who taught in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan and has authored many works on education issues in Kyrgyzstan, also participated. And I naturally threw in a few comments from the studio in Prague.

Kazakhstan’s President Nursultan Nazarbaev rather quickly defused the problem with Turkey by making a visit to Ankara to meet with President Erdogan. Nazarbaev did not agree to close down the Gulen schools in Kazakhstan, but he did promise to carefully scrutinize those running the schools and those teaching in them. Joroev said Nazarbaev explained to Erdogan that Kazakhstan does “take the warnings of the Turkish government seriously and that if there is any confirmed reason for taking some serious actions against these schools that Kazakhstan stands ready to do that.”

Ankara urged Kyrgyzstan to close the Gulen schools also, warning they were dangerous, but Bishkek flatly rejected doing so.

Joroev said that shouldn’t have been a surprise. “These 20 or so schools related to Gulen are really some of the most high-performing, highly regarded schools in the country, which are currently educating many thousands of children,” he said.

DeYoung pointed out the schools have filled an important need for many in Kyrgyzstan. “The Gulen schools came and actually created schools in places where there used to be schools that weren’t doing so well anymore…they provided opportunities and they provided resources, they provided classrooms with electricity.”

Both Joroev and DeYoung agreed the Gulen schools appear to be providing students with a quality education. Joroev also pointed out that after the collapse of the Soviet Union, when the majority Muslim Central Asian states became independent, there were many questions about what form of Islam was best suited to their countries.

“I think Kazakhstan and especially Kyrgyzstan did not have a settled policy of exactly what sort of Islam we are going to teach, and in that regard I think the Gulen version of Islam, which is open to science, [a] modernizing version of Islam, sounded like an acceptable option,” Joroev said.

The Majlis participants noted that is not the view in Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, or Turkmenistan.

Gulen’s ideas of Islam are inspired by the life and work of Sufi scholar Said Nursi (Nurchi). Tashkent was the first to believe there was a danger in the works of Nursi. In August 1997, Uzbek President Islam Karimov recalled all students studying at Nursi schools in Turkey. Nursi teachings are banned in Uzbekistan and people have been sentenced to prison for being members of the group.

Tajikistan closed the last of its Gulen schools in 2015, though that could be explained as part of a wider campaign against Islamic groups in Tajikistan that are not totally subservient to the government.

Turkmenistan, where the group is also referred to as “Nurchilar,” closed the sole Gulen-linked school operating in the country at the start of August.

“It’s likely the moral teachings of the movement which alarmed officials in each of those republics,” DeYoung said.

Joroev said that in Kyrgyzstan, when the Gulen schools started to appear in the 1990s “there were lots of rumors about how these schools tend to indoctrinate and brainwash the kids.” He said in Kyrgyzstan’s case, the performance of students in those schools and lack of evidence of ulterior motives had persuaded many in the country that the Gulen schools pose no threat.

Of course, there are still doubts. “That’s possibly the most important question these days, exactly what is the ultimate objective of the movement that we associate with Gulen,” Joroev said.

DeYoung said the Gulen schools were a topic of conversation when he had been in Central Asia previously. “I’ve talked to people about how school leaders or university rectors are trained and the answer has always been ‘well, they’re not trained, they’re just volunteers who come along.'”

For some, lack of clarity on points such as the training of teachers fuels distrust of Gulen schools.

The panelists agreed the Gulen schools that still function in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan would be well advised to show complete transparency about their organization and curriculum to help allay concerns. But it’s unclear how far the schools would be willing to go or how much the authorities in those two countries would need to know to be assured there is no ill-intent.

The Majlis discussed these issues in greater detail and looked at other aspects of Gulen schools and Central Asians’ attitudes toward the organization.

You can listen to the Majlis in its entirety here:

Majlis Podcast: The Gulen Schools In Central Asia

Related article, academic paper: 

The role of Turkish schools in the educational system and social transformation of Central Asian countries

 

 

Source: Radio Free Europe Radio Liberty , August 13, 2014


Related News

Afghan leaders: Increase in Turkish schools would help bring about peace

Indicating that students who graduate from Turkish schools in Afghanistan are those who will save the country, Niazi said: “Since the opening of the schools, children from different tribes are sitting at the same table and praying together. These schools have allowed these children from tribes we once thought impossible to reconcile to grow up as brothers.”

The story of the government media’s smear campaign against Hizmet

The pro-government media — or more correctly the “government media,” as it has become apparent that they have been bought by businessmen under orders from the prime minister — has manufactured and published lies about the Hizmet movement, which has a four-decade proud history in Turkey, in an attempt to create the perception that it is a criminal organization.

Gulen says he is certain Erdogan behind failed Turkey coup

Asked if he was suggesting that Erdogan was behind the coup, Gulen said: “Until now I only thought that was a possibility. Now I think it’s certain.” Gulen said a Turkish officer had recently said that the chief of general staff and the intelligence chief met in the army headquarters during the night of the coup, adding: “They already knew everything that would happen later.”

PM Basindawa opens new campus of Turkish-Yemeni School

SANA’A, Oct. 21, 2012 A Yemeni-Turkish School was opened Saturday in the Aser neighborhood of Sana’a in the presence of a slew of Turkish and Yemeni government officials. The school, which is largely a symbolic gesture of the continued friendly relationship between the two nations, was funded by Turkish businessmen and began construction in February […]

Liberia: ‘Go Beyond Secondary Education’- VP Urges Liberia’s Turkish Light International School

Liberia’s Vice President Joseph Nyumah Boakai has urged the administration of the Liberian Turkish Light International School to improve the quality of education beyond the secondary level in the country.

Closing prep schools as a new form of official tyranny

Thanks to the prep school system, with reasonable payments, the children of the “Black Turks” or “Mountain Turks” gain the chance to compete with the children of “White Turks” under equal standards. They, after graduating from good universities, become judges, teachers and academics and act as a catalyst in undermining pathological ways of thinking like labeling people as reactionary.

Latest News

17,000 women, 515 babies in Turkish prisons: SCF report

Erdogan opponents being monitored in Denmark

Turkey Systematically And Deliberately Jails Women As Part Of Fear And Intimidation Campaign

Turkey Bars Entry Of Critics By Adding Their Names Next To ISIL Suspects

Turkey’s Erdoğan Regime Extends Post-Coup Witch Hunt Targeting Gülen Followers Abroad

‘Consider your husband dead, start a new life,’ prosecutor tells detainee’s wife

Turkey jails disabled teacher after dismissing him and wife from profession

Wife: Jailed Former Prosecutor, Heavy Cancer Patient, Needs Urgent Health Care

Woman looking after disabled children alone as prosecutor husband under arrest for 270 days

In Case You Missed It

Aid organization head blasts terror probe

India must understand Erdogan’s ideological motives for seeking extradition of Gülenists

Çağ Education Company in Azerbaijan held a conference to celebrate the 20th anniversary

Gulen-linked org’s statement on Turkish Govt’s arrest of pro-Kurdish Parliamentarians

New constitution must bear spirit of Abant

Food and fun abound at Turkish Festival

A Muslim Cleric That America Should Support

Gülen’s lawyer files criminal complaint against several Twitter accounts

German translation of Gulen’s book at Frankfurt Book Fair

Copyright 2017 Hizmet News